I just picked some random names.
It really doesn't matter to me who wins these things since there never is a decent way for everyone to make a sound voting decision. I highly doubt anyone here's heard every single DJ on the given list (and if you have, I have six words for you: get a life, you obsessive freak!). When the majority have only heard a few DJs, obviously they will choose from those DJs. Why bother having a huge list like that when maybe .5% of the users here have even heard enough of half of those names to make an educated vote?
The talents from DJ to DJ really doesn't vary much (unless we get into turntablism, but this is tranceaddict we're talking about here): get good tracks, mix competently, throw a few tricks in here and there to impress the trainspotters, and have fun with the crowd. Therefore, that really isn't the attribute DJs get voted on, as then nearly anyone could be at the top. Instead, folks vote for who they know (normally based on who does the best promotion), and who plays their favorite styles of music. Since I ignore PR hype (yes, even when they deserve it), and I enjoy all forms of EDM, my choices are randomized.
However, I do recall Josh Wink being at the top.
Everyone has an opinion. Mine just happens to be a little more informed than most.
Electronic Music Critic: Near-Daily Ruminations Of Music I Own, In Alphabetical Order!