thumbs up or down for this melody?

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Producers Promotion
-- thumbs up or down for this melody?
Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Posted by Haak on Apr-26-2003 12:17:

thumbs up or down for this melody?

i've heard different opinions on this, so it got me uncertain

vote in poll

newtrancemelody4

Posted by b|p|3m on Apr-26-2003 12:21:

Good!

Posted by _Marco_ on Apr-26-2003 14:51:

decent but nothing special
but i must say the sound quality is very good in the sample

Posted by Haak on Apr-26-2003 15:43:

thanks for the feedback, i'm working more on it now, damn it's hard to get it right

Posted by mantisnl on Apr-26-2003 15:56:

sounds good, but it needs a bit more power and some variations, try putting some nice saw-synths in the background, that`ll sound very cool!
btw, it sounds a bit like an neo & farina production, very cool, new trance style

[edit]

when its done, will it be open for remixes? coz i might wanna do one!

[/edit]

Posted by Haak on Apr-26-2003 16:02:

quote:
Originally posted by mantisnl
btw, it sounds a bit like an neo & farina production, very cool, new trance style

that's funny cause i was planning on sending them a cd, they're looking for fresh tunes to include in their new compilation
http://trance.nu/v3/news_show.php?id=1578

thanks for the suggestions, i'm definately gonna add more layers (although my computer is stalling as the track is now, so it's probably gonna break down) and variations

edit: sure you can remix it

Posted by dj_hysterix on Apr-26-2003 16:03:

i think is good

Posted by mantisnl on Apr-26-2003 16:06:

quote:
Originally posted by Haak
sure you can remix it

cool, when its finished, could you send me an midi or flp file to
[email protected]

Posted by Endre on Apr-26-2003 16:24:

decent/nothing special.

sounds very, original

Posted by TOR on Apr-26-2003 16:46:

simple, but good

Posted by Haak on Apr-26-2003 17:20:

quote:
Originally posted by Endre

decent/nothing special.

sounds very, original

huh?

Posted by robstar on Apr-26-2003 17:21:

Voted for 'decent/nothing special'

It's has a good foundation but needs something extra too it.

Posted by MeLtrA on Apr-26-2003 18:47:

don't listen to thos fools, the melody is great, but it still need some work to sound proper.. and beside the melody the track sounds very very good!

Posted by Luke Terry on Apr-26-2003 18:52:

if u want neo + farina to get it you better finish it tonight and fedex it coz it has to be at hotdecks by wednesday

Posted by Haak on Apr-26-2003 18:55:

quote:
Originally posted by Project T
if u want neo + farina to get it you better finish it tonight and fedex it coz it has to be at hotdecks by wednesday

i was kinda planning to send it on monday hoping it will arrive on wednesday. there's no way it will be finished tonight heh

Posted by rqpeyruxvg on Apr-26-2003 20:14:

voted for "decent/nothing special"

yeah bit work it should be great, keep it up!

tezz

Posted by Endre on Apr-26-2003 20:21:

quote:
Originally posted by Haak
huh?

well, it sounds very simple but also good, there isn't much happenin' in the melody hmmz, i not very good at it either, but you should stick to what your good at haak, the prog-beats.

Posted by Haak on Apr-26-2003 20:47:

quote:
Originally posted by Endre

well, it sounds very simple but also good, there isn't much happenin' in the melody hmmz, i not very good at it either, but you should stick to what your good at haak, the prog-beats.

lol yeah, but i won't make any money out of that

Posted by auujay on Apr-26-2003 21:09:

It is not bad, but by no means good. Maybe like very the length of the notes. I mean the chord sequence works, but the timeing of the changes is really predictable after the first couple.

Posted by Endre on Apr-26-2003 21:11:

heh...who said anything about money?, i hope thats not your purpose with producing mate

Posted by DJ-Ande on Apr-26-2003 22:08:

quote:
Originally posted by robstar
Voted for 'decent/nothing special'

It's has a good foundation but needs something extra too it.

it needs to have mor emotion n more epicness n meaning, needs to stand out n PUMP abit more, e.g. mike'z tunes n ferry'z

Posted by DJ-Ande on Apr-26-2003 22:13:

quote:
Originally posted by Endre

heh...who said anything about money?, i hope thats not your purpose with producing mate

i agree

that would be a dissapointment cos all your prog and techno stuff is amazing, if u r only producing trance for some money then thats not good, keep to what ya do best e.g. techno n prog especially if ya only doing trance for ��$$

if not then keep up the work

Posted by Haak on Apr-26-2003 22:41:

lol, i was joking about the money damnit

i make trance cause i love trance ffs

Posted by burns on Apr-26-2003 22:55:

Haak, u got PM

Posted by nic01445 on Apr-27-2003 05:17:

i voted "decent/nothing special." The notes are nice, though a little more variation would be appreciated. The thing that i thought brought down the quality of the lead the most was the sound you used. I mean, the sound is ok, but it has no "umff." its kinda...blah.

Pages (2): [1] 2 »