FINALLY: Ishkur's Guide v2.0 - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- FINALLY: Ishkur's Guide v2.0
Pages (5): [1] 2 3 4 5 »

Posted by Cobalt on Sep-25-2003 23:40:

FINALLY: Ishkur's Guide v2.0

Just go there.

And thanks to Ish for his efforts.

Posted by armandzadza on Sep-26-2003 00:06:

This is incredible! Paradise for genre whores (like me!)

Posted by joeh on Sep-26-2003 00:13:

I really wasnt too keen on his views in the first one

But ive been looking foward to this for a few weeks anyway.

Thanks mate

edit:

The download for the flash file was bad enough in the first one. This one looks far bigger , nm i will be worth it

Posted by joeh on Sep-26-2003 00:18:

just reading it now.

DJ Jean - the launch is now uk hard house or as he calls it 'stupid house'.

Its good this guy put so much effort in to this buy he doesnt know it all.

edit:

Rank 1 - Airwave
System F - Exhale

are not trance apparently?

Posted by torontotrance on Sep-26-2003 00:28:

the fool knows nothing..now he is going to pollute people's minds with crap

hi-nrg is not under trance...it's euro....what i grew up to

epic trance - castles in the sky but not trance = rank 1 - airwave...what the fuck is he smoking....

he knows nada

then song 3 under tribal is not tribal....it's actually just breaks...with a tribal feel...

sighs...polluting people's minds imo.

Posted by Noisician on Sep-26-2003 00:36:

Posted by EliPsE on Sep-26-2003 00:37:

This Ishkur fool is a joke.

Posted by Ian on Sep-26-2003 00:39:

quote:
Originally posted by Acid Junkie

I couldn't put it better myself, though being sponsored by di probably affected him, they're tits up on genres at times

Posted by TeKnoHe@d2025 on Sep-26-2003 00:40:

LoL "A-Ha- Take On Me (Stupid Dance Mix)". Some of his discriptions are funny as hell.

I found the first version of this guide very useful and the added features of this one make it even better.

"Brian Adams- Heaven (Stupid Dance Mix)" DJ Sammy doesn't get credit from anyone!

Btw, the creator seems to be a house fan...particularly "Deep House".

Posted by torontotrance on Sep-26-2003 00:48:

Peace Division - Feel My Drums is NOT tribal techno....it's tribal house.

He puts sharpside under german techno......probably under belgian techno.

Pete Namlook's stuff is more ambient techno

Olive - Your Not Alone is NOT TRIP HOP

and sasha and digweed never said any genre was uncool...LOL!

Posted by Rakoon on Sep-26-2003 01:00:

How awesome would it be having to memorize all of this and take a test in school instead of all the other crap we have to memorize

Posted by TeKnoHe@d2025 on Sep-26-2003 01:03:

I really dislike how he describes one of the best songs ever though:

quote:
If there is anyone who is responsible for the complete and thorough pussification of trance, making it offensively lame to the point where not only newbie ravers but also their soccer moms could enjoy it, it's Robert Miles.

He goes on to slag "Children" even more.

Posted by Psionic on Sep-26-2003 01:03:

Give the man some credit! Stop scrutinizing, looking for the smallest errors. He did a better job than all you guys could probably do :P

Posted by joeh on Sep-26-2003 01:08:

quote:
Originally posted by Galapidate
Give the man some credit! Stop scrutinizing, looking for the smallest errors. He did a better job than all you guys could probably do :P

did you even look at it?

Because if you had seen that he says that Fragma - Everytime you need me is trance but Rank 1 - Airwave isnt trance at all...... then you might not be saying that

But yes he did spend months on it and put a lot of effort... but its still not good.

Posted by J.L. on Sep-26-2003 01:10:

lol... wtf is up with that "not trance" subgenre in the "trance" genre

Posted by Noisician on Sep-26-2003 01:11:

ffs, what's up with that vgm and casiocore crap? and not only that, apparently both of them are described as *techno* subgenres ... i'm speechless

Posted by TeKnoHe@d2025 on Sep-26-2003 01:11:

*OFFICIALLY PISSED!*

Ok, he just put my all-time favorite song "System F feat. Armin van Buuren- Exhale" under the "Not trance aka Crap" category.

Posted by Trance(PL) on Sep-26-2003 01:13:

Alice Dj-Better off alone
under epic trance......

Posted by moncster on Sep-26-2003 01:18:

OMFG!!!!! I DIE!!!!!! I CRY!!!!

Posted by Psionic on Sep-26-2003 01:20:

quote:
Originally posted by joeh
did you even look at it?

Because if you had seen that he says that Fragma - Everytime you need me is trance but Rank 1 - Airwave isnt trance at all...... then you might not be saying that

But yes he did spend months on it and put a lot of effort... but its still not good.

I was in the middle of looking through it when I posted. I just noticed the Rank 1 - Airwave thing and I am upset at that, but then again these are all his opinions in the first place.

Posted by Trance(PL) on Sep-26-2003 01:27:

This is a pile of shit.

Ok TA's we need to make our own, with multiple imputs from TA's.

Posted by EliPsE on Sep-26-2003 01:34:

quote:
Originally posted by Trance(PL)
This is a pile of shit.

Ok TA's we need to make our own, with multiple imputs from TA's.

Indeed, so who wants to take the responsiblity and start one

Posted by robstar on Sep-26-2003 01:44:

I think that guide is bullshit!
Maybe 10-15% of the genre descriptions there are legit, the rest is just made upbullshit IMO!

All this guide does really, is to cause confusion ( ) but it's rather entertaining!

Posted by moncster on Sep-26-2003 01:46:

quote:
Originally posted by robstar
I think that guide is bullshit!
Maybe 10-15% of the genre descriptions there are legit, the rest is just made upbullshit IMO!

All this guide does really, is to cause confusion ( ) but it's rather entertaining!

Still makes a great EDM sampler though
Through this, I've discovered lots of new styles, real or BS'ed up, I don't really care

Posted by spit_heron on Sep-26-2003 01:56:

hey are the songs under goa and psy a true and/or worthy example of these genres? I like what i hear, just might have to get into that..

Pages (5): [1] 2 3 4 5 »