Join Andy's argument - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Chill Out Room
-- Join Andy's argument
Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Posted by torontotrance on Dec-18-2003 19:53:

Join Andy's argument

HI all

friend of mine is going on and on...stones are the world's greatest rock band

I tend to disagree...has to be bono and u2!

so ppl....what do you think...stones or u2?

Posted by Floorfiller on Dec-18-2003 19:55:

IN THE NAME OF LOVE!!!!!!!

BONO ALL THE WAY!!!!

Posted by Mr.Mystery on Dec-18-2003 20:15:

We can start talking about Bono/U2 when they've been around for as long as the Stones have.

No contest.

Posted by DjDeComp on Dec-18-2003 20:19:

GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

BONOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Posted by Slylee on Dec-18-2003 20:29:

U2 is more my era... even if the stones were too, i'd still go for Bono

Posted by buddy on Dec-18-2003 20:51:

The Who

Posted by Floorfiller on Dec-18-2003 20:53:

there isn't anything wrong with the stones...i don't think i've ever heard a bad song by either and other their productions...i prefer that of U2

plus bono will do anything for charity heheheh...

Posted by placebo on Dec-18-2003 20:54:

Tiesto is better.

Posted by Hami on Dec-18-2003 21:07:

quote:
Originally posted by placebo
Tiesto is better.

Damn right

Posted by Pete K on Dec-18-2003 21:16:

ffs The Beatles

Posted by arctic on Dec-18-2003 21:22:

I'm going with U2, partly because I love the piano in 'stuck in a moment', and partly due to Mick Jagger looking like a dried up prune.

Posted by tranceDJ on Dec-18-2003 21:25:

In terms of popularity, the Stones when they were at their peak.

But ultimately I would have to disagree with you both, Led Zeppelin beats them both.

Posted by Raptor on Dec-18-2003 21:29:

quote:
Originally posted by tennessee_raver
ffs The Beatles

i was waiting for someone to say this...

Posted by torontotrance on Dec-18-2003 21:42:

you are an idiot placebo

and many of you morons did NOT READ THE QUESTION

it was stones or u2

nothing else

Posted by Slylee on Dec-18-2003 21:44:

2 diff styles and 2 diff eras (sort of)...my vote is w/ U2

Posted by Yan on Dec-18-2003 21:46:

Beatles.

Posted by mezzir on Dec-18-2003 21:50:

quote:
Originally posted by tranceDJ But ultimately I would have to disagree with you both, Led Zeppelin beats them both.

damn right, zeppelin's better than both
beatles and the who also
but if i had to choose between those two, i dunno
thats tough
probably the stones

Posted by torontotrance on Dec-18-2003 21:51:

you can argue who is the greatest band in another thread

stones or u2 was the argument yet many fail to read the topic.

Posted by Slylee on Dec-18-2003 22:00:

i would definitely say U2.

Posted by biznology on Dec-18-2003 23:21:

quote:
Originally posted by torontotrance
you can argue who is the greatest band in another thread

stones or u2 was the argument yet many fail to read the topic.

but when you opened you asked which was the 'greatest' and I would argue neither of the two. just because music is old doesnt mean that it is 'better' just more nostalgic. but at the same time i wouldnt frickin say 'tiesto' is a better rock band. jeez|

Posted by arctic on Dec-18-2003 23:26:

If the Rolling Stones ever made anything with a piano like the one in 'Stuck In A Moment', i'd love to hear it. Once again, U2!

Posted by trancEyes22 on Dec-18-2003 23:27:

U2 by far!! make a poll!!

Posted by [ groovypants ] on Dec-18-2003 23:57:

For me, it would be U2.
From the top of my head right now, I could name almost 10 songs from U2 that I love...
But in terms of the Stones, I only know 2 or 3.

Posted by mezzir on Dec-19-2003 00:31:

quote:
Originally posted by biznology
but when you opened you asked which was the 'greatest' and I would argue neither of the two.

the man's got a point
would've been better to say who's better
but still
stones
gimme shelter
omfg ch00n

Posted by Dj O'Callaghan on Dec-19-2003 00:40:

U2 then again thats biased as I'm Irish.

The Stones good band however Mick Jagger looks like a fucking prick he looks like his licked a hornets nest and had his lips stung, and his Daughter Jade is a minging fucking **** how the fuck did she ever make it as a model. However Keith Richards is a hellraiser top bloke go on Keith rack up some more lines.

Pages (2): [1] 2 »