TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Judge Jules Night Out @ Amnesia
Pages (2): [1] 2 »


Posted by Luke Cartwright on Aug-14-2004 20:05:

Judge Jules Night Out @ Amnesia

Heres a quote from Jules diary on his web page

http://www.judgejules.net/index.php?page=2

Along with my manager Charlie and another couple of friends we hit Amnesia at 2am, and perched ourselves on a terrace overlooking the very packed dancefloor. On the one hand I'm keen to make this column interesting, on the other I don't want to court too much controversy. Suffice to say the main room set from one of the world's most famous dj's was one of the worst I've heard in a very long time. Not only did he fail to play a single track that you'd remember five minutes later, he generated no atmosphere, mixed without passion and looked utterly bored. In a holiday environment I was astonished to hear not even one or two tunes with the faintest degree of familiarity, especially in a 5000 capacity club. I've been dj'ing a long time, and the way I've kept my career buoyant is by trying to remain tuned in to the mood of the crowd at all times (although clearly it's impossible to get things right on 100% of occasions.) I couldn't believe how removed one of the biggest so-called 'Superstar dj's' was from the atmosphere on the dancefloor. The minute the following (younger, hungrier) dj started his set the atmosphere changed out of all recognition, but by that point I'd been put on a downer, and we left half an hour later. My precious social night out spoiled by one of the most disappointing sets I've heard in a long time.


Posted by swisstoni_uk on Aug-14-2004 20:13:

lol who is he talking about i wonder??

could it be Armin?


Posted by TJM on Aug-14-2004 20:35:

Bwahahaha!

I presume its one of these from last saturday at amnesia, probably not eddie halliwell tho as jules licks his ass.

MAIN ROOM
Paul Oakenfold
Armin Van Buuren
Fergie
Eddie Halliwell

TERRACE
Type Terrace
Seb Fontaine
Jon Carter
Nic Fanciulli

Whoever it was is besides the point though !!! I can't believe he's written that about anyone what a joker.

He's probably one of the worst DJ's iv ever seen, anyone who has suffered jules playing at a decent night will know the mans lack of ability and the groans that sound out when he comes on (a load of sets at crasher spring to mind). That diary entry is the funniest thing I've read in ages


Posted by sleepydragon on Aug-14-2004 21:13:

probably oakenfold as he mentions thats hes supposed to be a superstar dj


Posted by sleepydragon on Aug-14-2004 21:15:

quote:
Originally posted by TJM
Whoever it was is besides the point though !!! I can't believe he's written that about anyone what a joker.

He's probably one of the worst DJ's iv ever seen, anyone who has suffered jules playing at a decent night will know the mans lack of ability and the groans that sound out when he comes on (a load of sets at crasher spring to mind). That diary entry is the funniest thing I've read in ages


just cose jules is a crap dj doesnt mean he isnt entitled to his opinion he only wrote what he thought do u want him to lie instead?


Posted by swisstoni_uk on Aug-14-2004 21:30:

quote:
Originally posted by sleepydragon
just cose jules is a crap dj doesnt mean he isnt entitled to his opinion he only wrote what he thought do u want him to lie instead?


it is ironic though, a man who inspires so much cringing amongst trance fans criticises a DJ's set when his own sets are below par


Posted by on Aug-14-2004 21:52:

quote:
Originally posted by swisstoni5017
when his own sets are below par


Well when I saw him live, he played such an explosive set that blew the roof off the place... Gotta be one of the top 3 live shows I have been to... Next to Marco V, and Ferry Corsten..


Posted by mike_stefan69 on Aug-14-2004 22:04:

We were discussing this on another message board and came to the conclusion that he was referring to oakenfold - he refers to a "superstar DJ" and then refers to the "younger" DJ

to be fair oakenfold's sets are beyond a joke. not that judge jules' sets are better, but oakey clearly has a bigger standing in the world of EDM, not just in the UK but on a world wide basis
anyone who looks at the last few of oakeys sets will agree they are complete and utter gash

and no, just because he's shit doesnt mean he isnt entitled to his own opinion. if anything, i actually respect him a bit more than i did before, for speaking out. he clearly was pissed off enough to warrant him writing about it in such strong words.


Posted by on Aug-14-2004 22:25:

quote:
Originally posted by mike_stefan69
to be fair oakenfold's sets are beyond a joke. not that judge jules' sets are better,


actually I think most people would agree that Jules sets are ALOT better than oakenfolds... I have heard some of Oakies latest aswell as some of Jules latest... and there is a huge difference in quality.. Jules having the better of the 2... Jules isn't the greatest by far, but I think he deserves more respect from the community than he gets...


Posted by irishclubbing on Aug-14-2004 22:50:

i agree with him that oakie has turned sour recently but publicizing it for all top djs, promoters and fans to see is a bad move and isn't the 1st time hes kicked himself into a hole.

irish TA's will remember quite recently admitting his Lush set was one of his worst as he was completely wasted. fcuking hate fudge jules. him calling me a bastard in shagaluff didn't make me want to join his fan club


Posted by th0m on Aug-15-2004 00:13:

quote:
Originally posted by mike_stefan69
and no, just because he's shit doesnt mean he isnt entitled to his own opinion. if anything, i actually respect him a bit more than i did before, for speaking out. he clearly was pissed off enough to warrant him writing about it in such strong words.


I would respect him if he would criticize a dj and then actually tell us which dj it was himself instead letting us figure out which dj it was.

No respect in this.


Posted by 2crazt66 on Aug-15-2004 00:50:

Clearly talking about Oakenfold.

To be fair, he's not tried hiding it - anyone can figure it out.

I'm usually one of the Judge's biggest critics, but this time I think he's got it absolutely right - Oakenfold was pathetic; Halliwell pretty good.


Posted by mike_stefan69 on Aug-15-2004 09:41:

wasnt this night that extended essential mix that went on for 4-5 hours?


Posted by swisstoni_uk on Aug-15-2004 10:17:

yeah the Radio 1 weekend from Ibiza


Posted by searchdestroy_1 on Aug-15-2004 10:53:

Paul Oakenfold
Sarah McGlachlan - Unknown (White)
Alberto Rivas - Como Tu [Paul Oakenfold Remix] (Trident)
North Stone - Unknown (White)
Paul Oakenfold - Southern Sun [Gabriel & Dresden Remix] (Perfecto)
Wave - Unknown (Perfecto)
Mauro Picotto - Lizard [Oakenfold 2004 Remix] (Virgin)
Ferry Corsten - Sweet Sorrow (Tsunami)
U2 - Beautiful Day [Oakenfold Mix] (Universal/Island)
Igor S - Boomerang (ID&T)
Derb A Hack - ICTUS (White)
Tina Hie - Traffic (White)
Unknown - Unknown (White)
Smith & Pledger - Believe (Anjunabeats)


Thats what Oakie played. Looks pretty shocking to me. Smith & Pledger is the worst release on Anjuna this year. Wouldnt mind hearing the remix of Lizard tho.


Posted by Luke Cartwright on Aug-15-2004 17:33:

Yea he was talking about Oakenfold.

Jules has got it bang on here, fair enough alot of us dont like him and he should stop fucking around with those accapellas but whats the point in being a Dj if you look like you dont wanna be there playing a set.

Its about time someone inside the music industry said something about Dj's like this that are only still playing cause of their names, Fergie is also another one like this his recent set at global was just the same.

Good on ya Jules, although I would have named and shamed the Dj in question.

Sorry forgot to do that in the original post.


Posted by Michael19 on Aug-15-2004 22:55:

it might be true about what he said, but he doesnt even have the balls to name the dj, the dickhead.


and i think he should look in the mirror before criticing other djs, as he is bollox himself.


Posted by THE_Chris on Aug-15-2004 23:02:

If he had named him -> Defamation of Character -> Lawsuit


Posted by Michael19 on Aug-15-2004 23:17:

quote:
Originally posted by THE_Chris
If he had named him -> Defamation of Character -> Lawsuit



i dont think so, if that was the case, then every reviewer of movies, singles, records, footballers etc etc would never be able to say they were crap.


you can say someone is a shit dj in your opinion and you cant be sued or anything like that.


Posted by th0m on Aug-15-2004 23:44:

quote:
Originally posted by Michael19
it might be true about what he said, but he doesnt even have the balls to name the dj, the dickhead.


and i think he should look in the mirror before criticing other djs, as he is bollox himself.


Yup, and the fact that readers are able to figure out who he was talking about is not the same, this is just lame.


Posted by Frase on Aug-15-2004 23:51:

On one hand, I respect Jules for talking out and giving his personal opinion.

However its VERY unprofessional to criticise a dj's performance. Even if you are the perfect DJ which i think Jules is far from.

No question about how much he's done for the industry, but that isnt on show here.

But maybe the fact he now understands what it takes to rock dancefloors then maybe this will improve Jules as a DJ? Heres hoping


Posted by integlspwr on Aug-16-2004 01:29:

im super the super star dj is paul oakenfold and the younger dj is Armin Van Burren.


Posted by Orange Project on Aug-16-2004 04:14:

Fuck you judge jules!! First get your dj skills up to a decent standard and then criticize other djs. You have competely ruined countless nights at Getecrasher.

GET A FUCKING GRIP!!!!!!


Posted by spec on Aug-16-2004 04:21:

Has anybody ever heard a decent Judge Jules set?

He's been to Australia countless times and I am yet to hear one.


Posted by on Aug-16-2004 04:28:

quote:
Originally posted by spec
Has anybody ever heard a decent Judge Jules set?

He's been to Australia countless times and I am yet to hear one.


The one time that I have been able to see him, he dropped a crazy ass set... like I said already.. prolly one of the best sets I have been to Live... aside from Marco V and Ferry Corsten...


Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.