TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Album Reviews / New Releases Discussion
-- Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004
Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004

A) Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Alphazone Remix) - 6.5/10
Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Markus Schulz Remix) - 9/10

B) Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Mike Shiver Remix) - 8.5/10
Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Original Mix) - 7/10
Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Tom Porcell Remix) -8/10

Comments?
Markus Schulz and Mike Shiver remixes really shine imo.
Tom Porcell Remix is very catchy and is growing on me really rapidly.

mp3 wh0re... this track isn't even out yet...

quote:

Originally posted by DJ NGE mp3 wh0re... this track isn't even out yet...

Most tracks in this discussion aren't out.

C Sharp "1999" owns all.

Well, the original from '99 is one of my all-time favourite tune so I expected a lot for this 2004 version and I must say I'm not disappointed.

All mixes are absolutely superb and all have their own style. More importantly for me young german producer Tommy Pi kept the spirit of the original. Hey the tune even makes me love a Markus Schulz remix !

Chris #19

Re: Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004

quote:

Originally posted by varun A) Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Alphazone Remix) - 6.5/10 Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Markus Schulz Remix) - 9/10 B) Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Mike Shiver Remix) - 8.5/10 Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Original Mix) - 7/10 Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Tom Porcell Remix) -8/10 Comments? Markus Schulz and Mike Shiver remixes really shine imo. Tom Porcell Remix is very catchy and is growing on me really rapidly.

additional review here - http://www.tranceaddict.com/forums/...threadid=193670 from when I got my cd promo, sadly it seems that it's taking time to get released.

Tomonari and Tommy Pi - C Sharp 2004(Markus Schulz Remix) is a let down to me. wish he culd have done a way better job and i know he could. however the original 2004 is a killer one ive been longing for ever since i heard it back in early spring...

the alphazone mix is horrible. sounds like something that the ice-cream van would play to attract little kids. think im gonna sand it off the one side of my vinyl, cause the markus mix is in the bag

quote:

Originally posted by djrory the alphazone mix is horrible. sounds like something that the ice-cream van would play to attract little kids. think im gonna sand it off the one side of my vinyl, cause the markus mix is in the bag

on the contrary, the markus remix is levelled so wrong and really makes a classic sound like shit, it's like asking someone like blank & jones to remix xpander for sasha, or letting scooter remix cafe del mar, it just should never happen. The Alphazone remix is the best of a relatively poor bunch with Mike Shiver's being the only other one i'd even play now

quote:

Originally posted by DJ NGE mp3 wh0re... this track isn't even out yet...

I've had the promo vinyl of the Shiver mix for like 6 weeks mate - that's a big assumption.

Alphazone Remix is d best of the lot!! The electric guitar fits in perfectly in d track! Amazing remix! Markus's work on this track is a very big let down for me

quote:

Originally posted by n0bben- exactly we don't need those crappy 2004 updates

yeah but how long do we have to keep moaning about it before producers take note. If they're so short of new ideas for good tracks they should just retire and leave it to people who have them

quote:

Originally posted by Ian^ yeah but how long do we have to keep moaning about it before producers take note. If they're so short of new ideas for good tracks they should just retire and leave it to people who have them

Exactly. The current rate of remakes/new remixes/whayever is just so ridiculous i could cry.. what the f00k are the producers thinking, if anything? IMO one massive thing to blame is ASOT, it should be changed to a monthly show instead of weekly. Would give us more time to digest the new tunes and dig them up while waiting for next month's show, not like it is now.. With the current rate of ASOT trancers released, we will suffocate here soon because we don't have enough time to listen the current tracks when yet another batch of new ones is pushed out. SO whether ASOT should slow down to monthly or the industry change the idealism and lengthen the gap between releases. Something must be done!

Just my 5 cents (Finland doesn't use single cents).

So are these all remakes of The Quest - C Sharp???

alphazone remix 10/10
Mike Shiver Remix 9/10
Original Mix 9/10

quote:

Originally posted by stamper So are these all remakes of The Quest - C Sharp???

yes...... of which the Alphazone & Mike Shiver ones are listenable a few times, the rest are tripe

quote:

Originally posted by Ian^ yes...... of which the Alphazone & Mike Shiver ones are listenable a few times, the rest are tripe

i suppose they are listenable a few, maybe even a couple of, times in my case, although i see absolutely nothing new that they bring to the scene...

quote:

Originally posted by AlphaStarred i suppose they are listenable a few, maybe even a couple of, times in my case, although i see absolutely nothing new that they bring to the scene...

that's the point, at the moment all these remakes are diluting down the amazingness of the early tracks to a point where in a few years time it'll be hard to look at any tracks without cringing at the thought of their remakes

quote:

Originally posted by Ian^ that's the point, at the moment all these remakes are diluting down the amazingness of the early tracks to a point where in a few years time it'll be hard to look at any tracks without cringing at the thought of their remakes

i agree nearly to the fullest extent, however i've nothing against The Digital Blonde's remake of Point Zero. As a matter of fact, virtually everything (and i put emphasis on the new stuff) that Ricky Smith produces is mint...this is indeed one of the sole Trance producers that i relish more and more with time and his progress in production skills.
As for other producers, including top ones like Tiesto, Ferry, Avb, etc....imo their new shit is quite often a hit or miss production.

I may've digressed somewhat from the subject but i hope i've made sense

cheers

the alphazone mix is by far the best! the alphazone style is what the song needed so its not boring imo. reminds me of "dave joy - second chase (alphazone mix)" in a way. a wonderfull club tune. the others are weak compared to alphazones mix.

Finally the release date for "C Sharp 2005" is set for 17th of january.


You can order limited promos at Chemical Records from now on:


Vinyl 1 SKYW20031



- Original Mix
- Mike Shiver Remix
- Tom Porcell Remix


Vinyl 2 SKYW20032



- Alphazone Remix
- Markus Schulz Remix

Personaly I prefer the original but Markus puts a nice chillout spin on the track.

just ordered both discs, excellent stuff

quote:

Originally posted by Ian^ on the contrary, the markus remix is levelled so wrong and really makes a classic sound like shit, it's like asking someone like blank & jones to remix xpander for sasha, or letting scooter remix cafe del mar, it just should never happen. The Alphazone remix is the best of a relatively poor bunch with Mike Shiver's being the only other one i'd even play now

i agree, markus kill the song i dont have any feeling with this remix, too monotone imo.
Mike Shiver remix is excelent.
For ever i will love this Benno production.

Alphazone mix is the best!

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.