TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Chill Out Room
-- The Secret: The non-sense and the practical truth
Pages (2): [1] 2 »


Posted by Lira on Oct-25-2007 15:34:

The Secret: The non-sense and the practical truth


In this video, two of Australia's most important social critics
analyse how "the Secret" operates, using an empirical method.

I'm surprised that, even though this has been a ubiquitous topic in popular culture, there's no discussion whatsoever about "The Secret" here yet. It's spawned a plethora of books, documentaries and therapies, all based in a single premise: ask � believe � receive (although there are disagreements within the school of secrecy). Certainly the CORe would be incomplete without an extensive debate on such fundamental principles of how stuff works.

The video embedded in this page highlights the most important features of "The Secret", so I'm not going straight to the point: Why the hell do people buy it? And, when I say "buy", I do mean it, literally. People have flocked to purchase their own copies of "The Law of Attraction" and "The Super Mega Extended Secret".

Metaphysics aside, it does make some sense (even if minimal). You can't achieve something if you're not trying, that's common sense. Also, you hardly notice things when you're not paying attention to them. Fans often say that geniuses are able to convey the deepest truths as if they were obvious. However, this has been said over and over by lots of people, and this so-called secret is far from being mysterious. Why is it popular, then?

It seems to "Harry Potterise" the world. It adds magic to people living dull lives, talking about "psychological magnetism", "the omniscient universe" and... "secrets". It's borderline absurd, at times, and the Australian critics of the school of the Chaser, currently declaring war on everything, pointed that out brilliantly.

But, if it makes people move their arses and do stuff they want, can it be considered a bad thing at all? Not really, but does this actually give people an extra push, or is it just an excuse to sit down and daydream? Can it have a negative impact? Have you seen people drowning in a parallel world full of unicorns, midgets and illusions because of this?

Have your say


Posted by Silky Johnson on Oct-25-2007 15:36:

Why do people buy it? Because they're fucking sad and lazy, and can't figure out their own "secret" for success. Also, common sense is not at all common anymore.


/Thread


Posted by Lira on Oct-25-2007 15:39:

quote:
Originally posted by jennypie
Why do people buy it? Because they're fucking sad and lazy, and can't figure out their own "secret" for success. Also, common sense is not at all common anymore.


/Thread

But, is it a bad thing? Is it a sign that, although people are sad and lazy, they're trying to do something for a change? Or is that an excuse to keep arsing around?


Posted by Silky Johnson on Oct-25-2007 15:41:

quote:
Originally posted by Lira
But, is it a bad thing? Is it a sign that, although people are sad and lazy, they're trying to do something for a change? Or is that an excuse to keep arsing around?



It's alright if people understand that the world comes to men of action, not men of mere thoughts, words, or ideas. I think shit like "The Secret" appeals to the lowest common denominator...so it's probably really only giving them false hope.


Posted by chach on Oct-25-2007 15:43:

How did you get the video on the side like that ?

/thread


Posted by Lira on Oct-25-2007 15:46:

quote:
Originally posted by chach
How did you get the video on the side like that ?

/thread

Quote, and you shall unveil the secrets of HTML

/thread
quote:
Originally posted by jennypie
It's alright if people understand that the world comes to men of action, not men of mere thoughts, words, or ideas. I think shit like "The Secret" appeals to the lowest common denominator...so it's probably really only giving them false hope.

hmmm... I guess you have a point.

*Lira sees a copy in his sister's bedroom*

You do seem to have a very good point

/thread


Posted by Silky Johnson on Oct-25-2007 15:50:

quote:
Originally posted by Lira
*Lira sees a copy in his sister's bedroom*




Ahahahahaha!

I'd like to pat(ronize) your sister on the head.


Posted by iclone on Oct-25-2007 16:03:

quote:
Originally posted by Lira
Quote, and you shall unveil the secrets of HTML

or you can use tables


Posted by MeLLyMeL on Oct-25-2007 16:07:

I have it.

Read like 80% of the book but then I recieved a copy of I am America ( & So Can You) So I'm reading that now.


The Secret is really good. I think reading it makes me think differently and want to change how I am. But if I'm not reading the book I'm a super bitch and super complainy!


Posted by Lira on Oct-25-2007 16:59:

That's interesting, Mel.

Does the book make you complain less, then? If so, why? And do you work more after (or while) reading it?
quote:
Originally posted by iclone
or you can use tables
No, don't do it Really, tables weren't designed for that purpose, and it gives you a lot more headache in the long run. As a matter of fact, if you do try to use tables here, you're going to have a sad surprise...


Posted by SuspicionVandit on Oct-25-2007 17:01:

My father saw it when he was at the climax of a nervous breakdown and it "saved his life." Now he feels bad that none of the rest of the family wants to join his hogwash army.
As mentioned above, I think it appeals to the people in the slums and makes people grateful for small little gifts life brings them (shifting credit from the random of life to the law of Attraction).
I won a small coffee from McDonalds .


Posted by MeLLyMeL on Oct-25-2007 17:08:

quote:
Originally posted by Lira
That's interesting, Mel.

Does the book make you complain less, then? If so, why? And do you work more after (or while) reading it?
No, don't do it Really, tables weren't designed for that purpose, and it gives you a lot more headache in the long run. As a matter of fact, if you do try to use tables here, you're going to have a sad surprise...
Well things have gone pretty good in my life.

When I first moved alot of bad things were happening to me.
-My car got broken into
-Car batter died!
-Fired from my first job EVER

Now I can say I am happier. I want to read it twice so it can sink in.

Whether it's true or not.. It's still a great read. I'm a sucker for sappy movies and I like reading how people turned their life around. I'm all about Happy Endings

Obviously my life isn't shit and was never really shit compared to others. It's hard though to stay positive all the time.

Like the section about money is a bit ridiculous. But some people just always have a positive outlook on life! [I am not one of them]. I can't see a late payment and think something good about it. Especially if I don't have the money to pay for it atm. They want you to constantly think prosperity.


Posted by Halcyon+On+On on Oct-25-2007 18:36:

Positivity and prescribed individualism are the corporate new competence.

/broken record.

I'd never heard about The Secret before this thread; I guess people were keeping The Secret an actual secret from me. =/

It's mostly bullshit though. And the documentary footage even more so; if you focus really hard, invisible waves will emit from your head, making things suddenly go your way? Fuck that.

This is just telling people what they want to hear. It's smart control - all the forms of corporate and government control we know of through various books, media, etc. over the last century or so are easy to see from a mile away. It's not actually "brainwashing" someone if they buy the book and worship it willingly, now is it? It is, but it isn't. and that is how they can get away with it.

I'd compare this sort of thought to the majority of people who take up religion; they think that way because they want to. They want to believe in God because it makes them feel safe and it makes them feel as though they are never alone. People want to believe in The Secret because it makes them feel as though they can manipulate their reality to grant them whatever it is they wish in life, fully failing to realize that true enjoyment in ones life comes from not attaining whatever it is you want through wishful thinking, but through hard work; and the things we never actually work to get - those will remain dreams until the day we die. It not necessarily a sad thing - it's a human thing. But some would rather ignore it and submit to the new competence; work to achieve only corporate goals and corporate aims at indoctrinating people to believe they can achieve that brand new product and maybe this one, too - oh, and don't forget that one - everyone needs one of those!

It's a very ugly world out there. People want to believe in whatever because it changes the look of things for a short time - it's not a bad thing, essentially - but changing to change the nature of things, that is what people are being phased out of doing; they live in their illusion while nothing really gets resolved outside of it. And that can be a very harmful thing.


Posted by Lira on Oct-25-2007 19:05:

quote:
Originally posted by Halcyon+On+On
And the documentary footage even more so; if you focus really hard, invisible waves will emit from your head, making things suddenly go your way?

I'm at work and can't really write much but... that video was just a joke, mate, they're comedians

Or are you talking about the footage they're making fun of?


Posted by Halcyon+On+On on Oct-25-2007 19:07:

quote:
Originally posted by Lira
I'm at work and can't really write much but... that video was just a joke, mate, they're comedians

Or are you talking about the footage they're making fun of?


I know the video was a joke. The footage they were making fun of was from the BBC version of the book, no? I'm sure once people saw it on their television, they lapped it right up.

edit: Oh, and I forgot to say, the video was fucking hilarious. The part where they crashed their car had me in stitches. As far as I am concerned, humour/satire is one of the highest forms of communication.


Posted by Beatflux on Oct-26-2007 02:36:

Watching the Secret can be absolutely disguisting, yet inspiring because it has nuggets of truth hidden within. The entire philosophy is incomplete and it's presented in sort of a new age sort of fashion, and it that way the philosophy appears to be cheapened to the level of TV preachers, but if someone choose to investigate the matters of what goes into success they'll will find that the movie has some merit in what they are trying to teach.

The results in your life are directly correlated with what you are focusing on a moment to moment basis. This secret is absolutely so simple, you won't fucking believe it. Most people(including me) are on this autopilot mode where we are influenced by our environment to help us decide how we feel. Shitty job? Seems like a good enough reason to feel bad? Nobody wants to feel bad, but nobody wants to change how think. People want to feel bad. I know that's hard to hear, but it's the truth. People would rather keep knocking their head up against a stone wall than change their thinking and actions for the better.


Posted by Spacey Orange on Oct-26-2007 02:45:

lira

you sound like this guy always comes into my shop. i fucken hate the guy but only tolerate him for his money. :/


Posted by Vivid Boy on Oct-26-2007 03:21:

its just the same fundamentals of psychology just dressed up in bullshit. its like dressing up a piece of shit into a cute baby costume and making it look so adorable and cute. under it all its still just the same log.


basically whatever you focus all your mental power on, you will find a way to make it manifest. its no secret to the universe, its just the same log people shat ot years and years and centuries ago before this new one came out dressed in a different baby suit.


Posted by Halcyon+On+On on Oct-26-2007 03:26:


Posted by AnotherWay83 on Apr-11-2009 06:42:

recently my bro and mom have started to get into this in a big way.

so was thinking abt this and IMHO what its selling is not very different from what the authors of all those "pick up artist" books are trying to sell. i think we (most of us anyway) are absolutely terrified at the thought of not being in control of our own lives...and these types of books make us feel that we can in fact control our own destiny, that we can affect how things pan out in our lives. and thats why ppl. eat it up because it makes them feel like they're actually in charge of their own lives.

depending on who you ask, this might be a good thing or not. i'm a bit of a fatalist myself so IMHO its all just a bunch of bull


Posted by Sushipunk on Apr-11-2009 07:20:

Fuck you for bumping this thread.

I thought Lira was back


Posted by Vivid Boy on Apr-11-2009 07:22:

well ill say one thing abt the secret. i think its a half truth. im pretty sure theyre th message aka "the secret" is mindset.


now i always relate this to soccer when im trying to achieve a goal because i have been doing soccer for so long.I have learned after 23 years of play, In order for me to score 2-3 goals a game i need to have a certain mindset. I literally have to mentally prepare myself about a half hour - an hour before game time. If I don't I wont score at all. If I do and i o it right i find myself making these goals come true. my mental preparation consists of alot of visualization. I have to go over every play, and go over every goal in my head, and even celebration. I have to get a fire inside of me that not just would "like" 2 goa;ls but "want" 2 goals. This mindset also needs to carry itself ingame. Now alot of my goals don't come the way I imagine/visualize them but they come, and when the opportunity presents itself I capitalize.

trust me it works. once i build up a momentum I can go on long goal scoring streaks (if I'm healthy).

So In some ways I buy the shit. but i think they lace it with way too many frilly's making you think its magic......theres nothing magic about soccer to me.. I have played since I was 3. If i just started today there would be no way i could score 2 goals a game just by getting myself in the right mindset..

I mean truthfully if you focus on something long enough you'll figure it out. thats why i think the "secret" under all its marketing is just plain mindset.

If I spent every moment of every day on getting my ass rich, im pretty sure i could pull it off within a year or 2


Posted by Damerchi on Apr-11-2009 07:55:

complete shit. New Age moneymaker that has raped esteemed concepts of meditation, manifestation, etc. what the hell, this thing keeps training you to keep feeding the ego rather than containing the materialistic hunger.

fuck, I watched a videoclip of Hicks Abraham seminars on what to do regarding the economic crisis-my ears were bleeding. this nonsense claims you are responisble for EVERYTHING you manifest into your existence, so all you with a disease, it was your thoughts silly. This also promotes faith healing which is definately not the way to go.

This thinking also makes fortunate people feel at ease that those less fortunate are manifesting their shittyness by being negative-even to the extent that the soul of the baby is matched up to that family. and those less fortunate take the complete burden of their situation as a result of what they have manifested, creating very unneccessary guilt.

This is a recipe in the disaster for many in the long run-although it may create an intense short term euphoria. Those more moderate practicers who argue that this helps with confidence in various aspects, thats great, but they must realize that their rational thought is suppressing the outright whack concepts of this.

fuck oprah


Posted by pkcRAISTLIN on Apr-11-2009 08:28:

quote:
Originally posted by AnotherWay83
recently my bro and mom have started to get into this in a big way.

so was thinking abt this and IMHO what its selling is not very different from what the authors of all those "pick up artist" books are trying to sell. i think we (most of us anyway) are absolutely terrified at the thought of not being in control of our own lives...and these types of books make us feel that we can in fact control our own destiny, that we can affect how things pan out in our lives. and thats why ppl. eat it up because it makes them feel like they're actually in charge of their own lives.

depending on who you ask, this might be a good thing or not. i'm a bit of a fatalist myself so IMHO its all just a bunch of bull



wow. this must the first piece of bullshit you haven't swallowed hook, line and sinker


Posted by Ian on Apr-11-2009 09:57:

i miss the chasers


Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.