TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Progressive House, Progressive Trance
Pages (3): [1] 2 3 »

Progressive House, Progressive Trance

Allright guys.

Can somebody explain the difference between the two genres for me ?

Would it be fair to say that this is progressive house:


Ivan Gough & Feenixpawl Feat. Georgi Kay - In My Mind (Axwell Mix) Full Version HD - YouTube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?featur...d&v=SZW7cW2QKf0


And this is progressive trance ?


Cosmic Gate & Emma Hewitt - Be Your Sound - YouTube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxMt...player_embedded


Is it a case of Prog house having more of a bassline , and Prog trance being more melodic?

I love the type of music in the posted links, and have done for a very long time!
I just find it hard to distiniguish between the different genres.

Is it just a case of trance being more soothing ?

What would you class this as, house ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eyaj...feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sINiFJNXr-o

You ever seen Die Hard II?

Cant I just get a decent reply? What is a forum for after all ?

The dry kinds are always require excess pushing yet do not need much wiping.

Neither of those tracks constitute progressive or trance at all anyways.

quote:

Originally posted by aStateOfTrance Cant I just get a decent reply? What is a forum for after all ?

Sorry mate, you post shit music you get shit replies. That's how TA works.

quote:

Originally posted by chris1011 Neither of those tracks constitute progressive or trance at all anyways.

What would you say those tracks are then ?
And no funny answers.

Could you post a video of what you believe to be progressive house and progressive trance ?

I love how you got your username after all these years without any spaces or derivation. Cheers.

Re: Progressive House, Progressive Trance

quote:

Originally posted by aStateOfTrance Would it be fair to say that this is progressive house: And this is progressive trance ?

No, it wouldn't be fair. Neither of those tracks are progressive house, nor progressive trance.

Here is what I believe to be progressive house:


And progressive trance:

those tracks are more trouse if anything.

Progressive house has got a bit silly now since everyone labels a lot of arena house as progressive.

Prog tends to be more intelligent and less centered around one or two build ups in a song.

heres a few prog songs

http://youtu.be/Oh-eDa5G62E


http://youtu.be/B3uXeJfoTWA

http://youtu.be/L4rRkI4vMzs

Well what have I just posted then ? What genre is that ?
Would the Emma Hewitt song be uplifting trance ?

quote:

Originally posted by aStateOfTrance Well what have I just posted then ? What genre is that ?

The Axwell remix is main room house, or "trouse" if you like. The Cosmic Gate track is Euro trance.

EDIT: Although calling the Cosmic Gate track uplifting trance would be fair.

Re: Progressive House, Progressive Trance

I don't disagree that this music isn't exactly very good, but I'm kinda tired of these smartass replies we keep giving new users. Discard your egos and actually answer his fucking question, please? If it isn't worth your time to listen to the tracks and give your answer, then don't bother replying. (Ninja Edit: Thanks for giving a good answer, Jack)

quote:

Originally posted by aStateOfTrance Ivan Gough & Feenixpawl Feat. Georgi Kay - In My Mind (Axwell Mix) Full Version HD - YouTube http://www.youtube.com/watch?featur...d&v=SZW7cW2QKf0

This is nowhere close to progressive house. It's like a slower, crappier version of melodic trance. It reminds me of some of those Future Trance compilations, with much less bass.

quote:

Cosmic Gate & Emma Hewitt - Be Your Sound - YouTube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxMt...player_embedded

This is basically just vocal trance.

Re: Re: Progressive House, Progressive Trance

quote:

Originally posted by SYSTEM-J

Maybe you can post some more recent examples that would be relevant to more people?

Re: Re: Progressive House, Progressive Trance

quote:

Originally posted by ziptnf I don't disagree that this music isn't exactly very good, but I'm kinda tired of these smartass replies we keep giving new users. Discard your egos and actually answer his fucking question, please? If it isn't worth your time to listen to the tracks and give your answer, then don't bother replying. (Ninja Edit: Thanks for giving a good answer, Jack) This is nowhere close

Thanks to you, my pride is destroyed and now I must humble myself by bending down wearing sackcloth.

Re: Re: Progressive House, Progressive Trance

quote:

Originally posted by ziptnf I don't disagree that this music isn't exactly very good, but I'm kinda tired of these smartass replies we keep giving new users. Discard your egos and actually answer his fucking question, please? If it isn't worth your time to listen to the tracks and give your answer, then don't bother replying. (Ninja Edit: Thanks for giving a good answer, Jack) This is nowhere close to progressive house. It's like a slower, crappier version of melodic trance. It reminds me of some of those Future Trance compilations, with much less bass. This is basically just vocal trance.

Thank you.
How exactly do you tell the difference ? There are so many genres and sub genres I find it difficult to tell what is what.

SystemJ - So the axwell mix Is just house music ?
And the cosmic gate uplifting ?
Like this song: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QH_vvo89AQ8

Re: Re: Re: Progressive House, Progressive Trance

quote:

Originally posted by Mattinsanity Thanks to you, my pride is destroyed and now I must humble myself by bending down wearing sackcloth.

I'm shocked you had any pride to begin with.

Re: Re: Re: Progressive House, Progressive Trance

quote:

Originally posted by aStateOfTrance Thank you. How exactly do you tell the difference ? There are so many genres and sub genres I find it difficult to tell what is what. SystemJ - So the axwell mix Is just house music ? And the cosmic gate uplifting ? Like this song: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QH_vvo89AQ8

yep its just a house song, and the cosmic gate is uplifting vocal

Re: Re: Re: Re: Progressive House, Progressive Trance

quote:

Originally posted by ziptnf I'm shocked you had any pride to begin with.

I take that as a compliment. You're a good samaritan.

ASOT, you can go to youtube, google, or discogs and type a year followed by the subgenre. That's how I discovered progressive house and progressive trance from different eras.

Re: Re: Re: Re: Progressive House, Progressive Trance

quote:

Originally posted by cropped yep its just a house song, and the cosmic gate is uplifting vocal

Ok, just to make sure.

This is house :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2lav8rqK4Y

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0hHTykSWV6U

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oUmvPgH5iD0

And this is Uplifting trance :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxN_...layer_embedded#!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PR9Z...player_embedded


Does uplifting trance keep the same beat throughout, just adding more 'layers' to it as it progresses ?
And house is 'louder' , having more bass ?
House has many different tunes throughout ?

i discovered trance through jesus.

Re: Re: Re: Progressive House, Progressive Trance

quote:

Originally posted by Adam420 Maybe you can post some more recent examples that would be relevant to more people?

I don't think so. Starting at the present and trying to figure things out backwards is how you end up with people who can't tell the difference between house and trance. The clearest way to learn anything about musical movements is to start from the beginning.

i'm abandoning this thread

Do you guys appreciate this more ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qxgWIEyttio

This is uplifting trance, right ? Has to be!

Im pretty sure I know the difference between trance and house, its just when you get these stupid sub genres I get confused.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.