how come kontakt havent been sued yeT?

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- how come kontakt havent been sued yeT?
Pages (2): « 1 [2]

Posted by TOR on Sep-16-2003 12:51:

it's a strange situation

lots of records that hit the charts in Belgium are covers as well..

that desenchant�e tune by kate ryan was produced without permission of mylene farmer.. in an interview kate said (after the track had been #1 on the charts for a few weeks) "we might send it off to mylene and see if she likes what we've done with it"

sometimes artists get away with it sometimes they don't

i think it depends on how rich the artist that wrote the original tune is.. at the moment there's a maria carey cover in the belgian charts, but i don't think maria minds as she's got plenty of money already. M.I.K.E is in a totally different situation.. scooter took the melody from strange world and earned much more money with it than mike ever received.. that's why mike said "oh no you don't!"

dunno how the mike story unfolded in the end, but i know he wasn't happy with it at all..

Posted by eyeball_2003 on Sep-16-2003 13:39:

yeah iv got that song!!!
and damn iv never realised that its near enough binary finary with words

sue them!!

Posted by waXology on Sep-16-2003 14:19:

funk einsatz - punk was what ferry corsten - punk was called when it was given out as a white label....

he then added soem things to it and released it as ferry corsten - punk.

im sure of this.

Posted by Shamez214 on Sep-16-2003 15:03:

i think i agree with skip2 on this one. i am almost positive that, in USA, if an artist directly samples a track then they need permission. however, if they make a tune that sounds like another tune, with same melody and everything, i dont believe they need permission. who's to say that they even heard the original tune before making their own anyway? case in point: look at M.I.K.E. and L-Vee. both made tunes that are almost identical and were released, i believe, pretty cloesly with one another.

Solar Factor - No Return <<<< M.I.K.E.
Green Martian - Harmonic Minor <<<< L-Vee

so it *is* possible for two people to make the same song without knowing about it. it's also happened in hip hop alot. one particualr case involved Jadakiss and Cormega. both albums came out in the same month and 1 track on each of the albums contained the same exact beat. however, one was produced by cormega and the other.. well i'm not sure. but i think you get my point.

in the case of scooter, it's OBVIOUS that its a blatant ripoff only because, unless it is the largest coincidence in the world, there is no way they can make that many tunes that sound like other tunes.

Posted by GT40 on Sep-16-2003 15:57:

The most obvious rip off for me is:

Mauro Picotto - Verdi

and 4 Motion - Over For Me

Pages (2): « 1 [2]