TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Producers Promotion
-- Should "AMATEUR" be removed from the title of this forum?
Pages (5): « 1 [2] 3 4 5 »

quote:

Originally posted by oDrori IMO it shouldn't, if it will, should be replaced by "Future" thus it's both alerting and encouraging...

So this forum should be changed to serve people who are going to be producers but aren't yet?

Only if you wanna take it too literally I personally think "Amateur" is fine...

quote:

Originally posted by oDrori Only if you wanna take it too literally I personally think "Amateur" is fine...

Heh, yeah, like I said earlier I don't really care if the forum was called "pancakes and waffles on a stick"-forum if the content stays the same.

no

the name amatuer doesn't necessarily say how good or bad one is. It simply means that one doesn't do it for their profession hence the name professional. I think that it doesn't really matter one way or another but I will agree with some above it may encourage new artists to post some of their music even though it isn't amazingly great, that way we can all help more people which is what this is all about. have a good one folks keep rocking.

cornic

yes please remove it

Mesa think "Dj Promotion" and "Music Producers" will do.

if not. a question like this will rice.
"who is amateur, and who's not."

"you.....you.. not you... but you .... and you"

quote:

Originally posted by Endre "Music Producers Promotion" i dont see why that should stop someone to post here

Disco Stu Agrees with you!

Yeah, should leave 'Amateur'. There are a lot of more pro producers. Some of them much better than the ones who are at a label.

it doesnt really matter what's the name of this forum to me. so i voted yes (ok, that doesn't made any sense)

Music Producers Promotion has a better ring to it imo. Amateur is uneccesary.

no, more amateurs than signed producers.

it should be just music promotion section imo, it's not up to the producer to say if he/she is a pro or an amateur, you see it's the crowd that decides, and you are here after all to promote stuff, and if there is anything that needs to be corrected, people say it.

either way nik is right, if the content of this section stays the same, i don't really care.

I think that some producers here might be offended by being defined as "amature".
there are pleny people here who are much more than amatures,while some are as pro as every other well-known DJ.
so in my opinion,and as said before,best title would be Music Producers Promotion

I don't think dropping the amateur in the name will encourage more professionals to be in here, because if they're good what's to be afraid of anyway? I think the word amateur actually does encourage people who aren't as good as the pros to post their own tracks so that they can learn "the ways" as well. I'm seeing that from my perspective as a relatively new TA, and I'm not quite sure if I would have had the guts to post in there if it hadn't been for the word amateur, although I'm already pretty scared of you really really good pro people. *bow*

to be fair, how many people actually get payed for making music in this forum? i would guess at less than 5% of the users who post here, which makes most people amateurs in the literal sense of the word. but then again, a lot of tracks that come out of here (way more than 5%!) do not sound in any way amateur.

i think just 'music producers promotion' will be just fine, but i think people seem to get the wrong meaning of the word amateur. it isn't a derogetory(sp?) term, it just ,means you don't do it for money

but amateur producers who've recently started producing and so on could avoid to post their track there if name'll be like "pro" but this forum is all for their needs (amateur producers) and they have'nt to be afraid
so may be just combine the names?
like "amateur and professional music producers promotion"
it would be better to my mind
sorry for my english

i think the word "AMATEUR" should definitely be removed from the title of this forum...

i think the word "AMATEUR" should definitely be removed from the title of this forum...

Too much promotion, too few good reviews.



I think it should be "Review And Get Your Music Reviewed Section".

It definitely should be removed from both : Amateur DJs Promotion and Amateur Music Producers Promotion.

quote:

Originally posted by Digital Rain It definitely should be removed from both : Amateur DJs Promotion and Amateur Music Producers Promotion.

We TA's a getting goooouuuuuud!

quote:

Originally posted by Cosmic Energy but amateur producers who've recently started producing and so on could avoid to post their track there if name'll be like "pro" but this forum is all for their needs (amateur producers) and they have'nt to be afraid so may be just combine the names? like "amateur and professional music producers promotion" it would be better to my mind sorry for my english

surely "music producers forum" would have the same effect?

haha, true, I'vent noticed it myself
I think "music producers promotion" is better than "music producers forum" because we already have "Production Studio" forum here

Just a thought...
If you don't want to remove it why don't you change it to: Amateur & Professional DJs Promotion and Amateur and Professional Music Producers Promotion.

I think a possible problem is that it becomes long and unwieldy. Since "Professional & Amateur" is kind of redundant -- I mean, who else is there, really?

I like the idea of simplifying it.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.