Lolo - Why - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Album Reviews / New Releases Discussion
-- Lolo - Why
Pages (2): « 1 [2]

Posted by idoru on Nov-23-2004 02:03:

Posted by Radagast on Nov-23-2004 02:13:

quote:
Originally posted by Mr.Mystery
It's one thing to have similar style and melody pattern but when you copy a melody almost note by note it's a whole another thing.

None of those songs you mention are complete ripoffs, just similar sounding.

No. Lolo - Why is no more a ripoff of Xpander than Airwave is of Out of the blue. Minor key changes, same supersaw. Here are some more ripoffs, these even more obvious:

Solid Sleep - Club Attack
Dito - Sky

Klubbingman - Welcome to the club
Skysurfer - Colors

Happens all the time.

Posted by Mr.Mystery on Nov-23-2004 02:16:

quote:
Originally posted by Radagast
No. Lolo - Why is no more a ripoff of Xpander than Airwave is of Out of the blue. Minor key changes, same supersaw.

The leads are completely different as well as the chord progression in Airwave & OOTB.

The leads and chord progression are almost identical in Xpander & Why.

Like I said, similarities in sound don't count as a ripoff. Nearly identical melody and chord progression does.

Posted by Radagast on Nov-23-2004 03:07:

They aren't rip offs, they only sound similar. My bad. I misspoke. What was I thinking.

Posted by Salem on Nov-23-2004 03:13:

quote:
Originally posted by NoisyNeil
Everything nowadays is variation on variation ,... original is not an option anymore, everything is already been done,

Listen to u guys........holy shit, stupid ass opinion....maysawell stop listening to electronica then heh

Posted by Radagast on Nov-23-2004 04:25:

And how Max Graham - Airtight ripped off Airwave(the artist)(or was it vice versa), we can sweep that one under the carpet as well.

EDIT: It's Airtight that rips off Escape From Nowhere.

Or when Zombie Nation ripped off that video game track. Just look here. That's only trance.

My point is that people blow this out of proportion when it's happening all the time. Direct samples are used often and nobody cares. So why should this be any different.

Posted by isoterra on Nov-23-2004 17:08:

quote:
Originally posted by Radagast
They aren't rip offs, they only sound similar. My bad. I misspoke. What was I thinking.

Indeed.

Posted by trancedfarmer on Nov-24-2004 03:18:

KILL YOURSELVES!

Posted by placebo on Nov-24-2004 16:19:

I found this tune very boring...it seems like it never goes anywhere.

Just another cheesey prog track in my opinion.

Posted by SashaLitvinoff on Nov-24-2004 22:58:

I commited a fucking crime , I like Lolo's Why more than Xpander , now fucking eat me ...

Posted by 3xx3r7 on Nov-24-2004 23:22:

quote:
Originally posted by placebo
I found this tune very boring...it seems like it never goes anywhere.

Just another cheesey prog track in my opinion.

Yeah, kinda like Interstate - I Found U.

Posted by EverZ on Nov-25-2004 00:17:

quote:
Originally posted by Radagast
My point is that people blow this out of proportion when it's happening all the time. Direct samples are used often and nobody cares. So why should this be any different.

Yes it happens more, but everytime i hear this i think of Xpander, it's just so alike. It's a good track, just like Xpander is.

Posted by placebo on Nov-25-2004 04:22:

quote:
Originally posted by 3xx3r7
Yeah, kinda like Interstate - I Found U.

LOL.

I guess you have a point. But Interstate's I Found U doesn't sound simliar to alot of stuff out there, thats why I liked it :P

And the vocals are addicting

Posted by Ben_Lei on Nov-25-2004 09:05:

quote:
Originally posted by placebo
I found this tune very boring...it seems like it never goes anywhere.

I agree. but still love the melody . its relaxing

Posted by DJ_Hailstone on Nov-27-2004 15:53:

quote:
Originally posted by Algenis
The B-Side "Because..." is much better imo.

Why?

Posted by placebo on Nov-27-2004 20:00:

quote:
Originally posted by DJ_Hailstone
Why?

hahahaha

rofl

Pages (2): « 1 [2]