PvD Politics of Dancing VERSUS. Ferry Corsten Trance Nation 2001

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- PvD Politics of Dancing VERSUS. Ferry Corsten Trance Nation 2001
Pages (4): « 1 [2] 3 4 »

Posted by billu on Feb-01-2002 16:06:

hmmmmmmmm..... personally i feel Trance Nation 2001 more, but u've got to understand, both compilations are COMPLETELY different in track selection and style!!!!!

Posted by ABTsportsline on Feb-01-2002 20:26:

hmmm.... i wonder if anyone even listened to Politics of Dancing?

I usually like PvD's livesets, but that album downright sucked.

i think people here are voting on the actual DJ's instead of the CD's....

Posted by toxa on Feb-01-2002 20:32:

In my opinion it was nice to see Ferry mix some tracks that he never mixed before into his livesets....like for example i never heard ferry play flight 643 but its good that he decided to explore new territory....as for PVD well Politics of Dancing was more or less his favorites from the past year and listening to his recent sets he still plays many songs from politics.
As big as i am a ferry fan....i think politics of dancing is a little better!!!

Posted by Xplorer on Feb-01-2002 21:47:

POD is the best compilation that came out in the last year or more with nothing even close to it, so my vote goes to PvD naturally

Posted by patticus on Feb-02-2002 00:15:

quote:
Originally posted by ABTsportsline
hmmm.... i wonder if anyone even listened to Politics of Dancing?

I usually like PvD's livesets, but that album downright sucked.

i think people here are voting on the actual DJ's instead of the CD's....

dude, what are you talking about, i listen to POD (disc 2) all the time. its not the greatest album of all time for sure, but it beats ferry's cheese nation 2001.. cmon.. who wants to hear 4:00 minute edits of tracks .. even tho his mixes are clean (of course)
and seriously, there's only one track i actually dislike on POD (the U2) but trance nation has several horrible nasty tracks, e.g. scot project...

that being said, i dont even like POD So much, id give it an 8/10 or so.

Posted by Rakoon on Feb-02-2002 00:43:

Ok, didnt know that it was what you meant by Trance Nation 5. Anyway my vote goes to Trance Nation. It has way more energy and great tracks than Politics. Politics sounds like it has the same bassline in every track and the tracks low energy, more like something you would listen to on your CD player when you go to sleep

Posted by dvd on Feb-02-2002 01:48:

IMO, trance nation 2001 cd 2 sucked =[ cd 1 was great. POD was good also but yeah, POD WINS... also my iPOD wins too =] as far as mp3 players go..but thats another story.

Posted by JM on Feb-02-2002 02:07:

Posted by dj_helen_k on Feb-02-2002 04:23:

hmmmm
u cant even 'compare' the 2. its hard to!
as they are both great, and unique in their own way ...

its not possible to compare. i love all the TN's ferry has done...
they are all uplifting and energetic/

POD is too, but, there is more originality and uniqueness to the CD,. as hes rewoked traks and stuff, and not plainly mixed it thru.

both get my vote of approval!

greets / helen

*currently playing: "illuminate" - Orbital (Charlie may remix)

Posted by Tranex02 on Feb-02-2002 06:27:

OMG!!!!!!!!!! I have to get that!!!!!!!
Trance Nation 2001....
why didn't anyone tell me before that this existed???

**runs out of the door**

Posted by Tranex02 on Feb-02-2002 06:30:

BTW......how old/recent is this???

I can't keep up with releases...

Posted by dj_helen_k on Feb-02-2002 06:46:

heh
it was released 30.04.2001

greeets / helen

Posted by Cable on Feb-02-2002 07:20:

although i didnt really like trance nation 2001 i chose it because i cannot take that same kick drum for 60 minutes at a time

Posted by djnick on Feb-02-2002 08:59:

trance nation 5, ferry has better track list that pvd, also seems pvd only likes to play people on his own label or something, and he just had to do all those damn reworks, liek i want to hear your shit pvd, your mixing the cd for god sakes i want to hear the original tune, not your souped up version of it, anyways he never plays, tiesto/armin/ferry productions, seriously pvd is waaaaay over rated, you guys get too much into the politics of all this shit, its about the songs, not the dj in mix cd's.

Posted by Ian on Feb-02-2002 11:07:

I wasn't as impressed with TN2001 as 1 2 and 3, number 4 was slightly more cheesy, but if you put POD up vs the first 3 trance nations, there'd be no contest whatsoever, I'd have to call a draw in the 2 named ones though

Posted by E.Sv on Feb-02-2002 11:25:

quote:
Originally posted by dj_helen_k
heh
it was released 30.04.2001

greeets / helen

Mayday 2oo1 Paul played the best set that day!

My vote goes for:

Posted by patticus on Feb-02-2002 12:00:

yah no doubt the kick drum is annoying, and trance nation 1 and 2, maybe 3, would beat out POD..

but man.. just TOO much "radio trance" on ferry corsten's mix.

and pvd having way out west, lexicon 4, nu-nrg, sagitaire, and mirco de govia (not to mention solid sleep) clinches it for me tracks wise

Posted by Miss Proximus on Feb-02-2002 12:18:

Posted by Astronaut on Feb-02-2002 18:23:

quote:
Originally posted by DarkLordz
trance nation 5, ferry has better track list that pvd, also seems pvd only likes to play people on his own label or something, and he just had to do all those damn reworks, liek i want to hear your shit pvd, your mixing the cd for god sakes i want to hear the original tune, not your souped up version of it, anyways he never plays, tiesto/armin/ferry productions, seriously pvd is waaaaay over rated, you guys get too much into the politics of all this shit, its about the songs, not the dj in mix cd's.

better tracklist???? what the hell are you talkin about?
synaesthesia...baguio track...Skydive...man these are preety old IMO.
and what is this cheezy firwire????

Reach me, Epic Monolith, Dreamland, Starchildren, Activity.... just think about it!

and yes he plays Tiesto & Armin tracks....

Posted by Eugene on Feb-02-2002 19:13:

I do not like PvD's Politics of Dancing, I agree with Juricimo that it's pretty boring.

So yes, Ferry's Trance Nation wins, for me.

Posted by djnick on Feb-02-2002 20:15:

quote:
Originally posted by Astronaut

better tracklist???? what the hell are you talkin about?
synaesthesia...baguio track...Skydive...man these are preety old IMO.
and what is this cheezy firwire????

Reach me, Epic Monolith, Dreamland, Starchildren, Activity.... just think about it!

and yes he plays Tiesto & Armin tracks....

you also cant compare them when they were released far apart from each other, the time TN5 was out it had way better tracks.

Schiller/Das Glockenspiel
Push/Strange World
Tenth Planet/Ghosts
Cosmic Gate/Fire Wire
Warrior / Voodoo
Thrillseekers / Synaesthesia
Gouryella / Tenshi
Kamaya Painters / Wasteland
Bedrock - Beautiful Strange
Mekka - Diamondback
Freefall - Skydive (I Feel Wonderful)

those songs alone put POD to shame, i mean everyone down rigth knows cd 1 sucked, because theres nothing to look forward to, but cd2 didnt have much to offer for its $18.99 price tag, only song i liked from POD cd2 was dreamland, everything else puts me to sleep....ZZZzzzZZZZZ

Posted by Eugene on Feb-02-2002 21:47:

quote:
Originally posted by DarkLordz

but cd2 didnt have much to offer for its $18.99 price tag, only song i liked from POD cd2 was dreamland, everything else puts me to sleep....ZZZzzzZZZZZ

exactly!!!

Posted by Ste on Feb-02-2002 23:19:

theyre both shit.

crap comemrciallised bags of wank...

both made by MoS uncoincidentally...

i say burn ministry of sound...

Posted by JM on Feb-03-2002 03:26:

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by DarkLordz

but cd2 didnt have much to offer for its $18.99 price tag, only song i liked from POD cd2 was dreamland, everything else puts me to sleep....ZZZzzzZZZZZ
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

exactly!!!

exactly

Posted by djnick on Feb-03-2002 03:59:

quote:
Originally posted by DuMonde TrAnCeR
theyre both shit.

crap comemrciallised bags of wank...

both made by MoS uncoincidentally...

i say burn ministry of sound...

i could care less if DefJam records made it, as long as the tracks are good is that that matters.

Pages (4): « 1 [2] 3 4 »