TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Chill Out Room
-- The Debates: Issue #1 - Religion
Pages (3): « 1 [2] 3 »
HEHE, poor old man Bush. He also did a great job of convincing the coca farmers of Columbia to grow bananas instead
You ever read about that little idea he had Thor?
Hmm not sure, what wonderous Idea was that? Make it a capital crime to be athiest? 
Here are some good links to get you thinking.
First a well-written essay (makes some good points, methinks)
http://www.churchofreality.org/opinion/christian.htm
Some odd theories about the relationship between mystery and contradiction
http://web2.airmail.net/dsh440/
Great site about Atheism, and it's core beliefs. Also, picks apart elements of Christianity in an intelligent way.
http://www.jestercourt.com/~capella/aguide/
Enjoy 
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Thor Hmm not sure, what wonderous Idea was that? Make it a capital crime to be athiest? |
Wow...such vehemence....
Obviously there are some strong personal beliefs in here. 
(I to could use google for my arguements...)
But I will say this. Bush is right. The founding fathers of the USA were all God-fearing, righteous men with a strong sense of liberty, peace and justice for all. It's written in their laws and even on their own money. Why should he turn his back on the very foundation his own government believes in for a small minority? 
How do I know this? I've been to a business meeting where a political figure spoke and they answered a question regarding religion in politics.
It's much more integrated than most people think.
And oh yea...no one has ever built a statue of a critic... 
thank you for Capella's Guide to Athiesm.
by the way, i have argued the case of Agnostics for a while, and i have recently learned that it's a lost cause. I only whip out the facts when others start to attack mine. 
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Fir3start3r Wow...such vehemence.... Obviously there are some strong personal beliefs in here. ![]() (I to could use google for my arguements...) But I will say this. Bush is right. The founding fathers of the USA were all God-fearing, righteous men with a strong sense of liberty, peace and justice for all. It's written in their laws and even on their own money. Why should he turn his back on the very foundation his own government believes in for a small minority? ![]() How do I know this? I've been to a business meeting where a political figure spoke and they answered a question regarding religion in politics. It's much more integrated than most people think. And oh yea...no one has ever built a statue of a critic... |
Every great theologan, artist, etc... Most of them were contraversial, and you better believe they were critical of the world...
Mwuahaha.
Believe it or not, there are a lot more then "just a few atheists."
Now though, that comment about Bush being right has riled my blood.
"But I will say this. Bush is right. The founding fathers of the USA were all God-fearing, righteous men with a strong sense of liberty, peace and justice for all."?
That is ignorance and bullshit rolled into one.
Thomas Jefforson, the slave-holder believed in liberty, peace, and justice for all?
Please, staments like the one you just made are what pisses people off.
God-fearing? People aren't supposed to be afraid of God. Control through fear is called Totalitarianism, and Stalin did I mighty fine job of that, making himself into a demi-god.
Now the flame-war has begun. 
Actually you should be afraid of god.
In the old testament he regularly punishes ppl for their mistakes and even kills everything in the world via a flood to get rid of supposedly bad ppl (hard to believe noah was the only good person).
God also loves to torture ppl by starving, burning, and etc. i could go on and on. Just read the bible, it does eventually get quite interesting.
On another topic, if god was always around then why can't the universe, or at least the big bang, just always be around. They both are quite unbelievable, so why have an unbelievable thing do a miracle when we can have an unbelievable thing half explained.
| quote: |
| Originally posted by dr me Actually you should be afraid of god. In the old testament he regularly punishes ppl for their mistakes and even kills everything in the world via a flood to get rid of supposedly bad ppl (hard to believe noah was the only good person). God also loves to torture ppl by starving, burning, and etc. i could go on and on. Just read the bible, it does eventually get quite interesting. On another topic, if god was always around then why can't the universe, or at least the big bang, just always be around. They both are quite unbelievable, so why have an unbelievable thing do a miracle when we can have an unbelievable thing half explained. |

Now I may have said that Bush was right, but I never did say I agreed with it now did I?
There seems to be some great assumtion here.
I'm not saying this to appease the two obvious atheists/agnostics here, just stating facts about a country and it's beliefs.
There no need to finger point in a debate or get personal here.
I'm stating Bush's beliefs and facts here people and the country he serves.
If you feel threatened then phone HIM and explain is to HIM; I didn't attack anyone here, rather I was asked for my opinion.
It's fine that some may not agree with the most powerful country in the world but just because I state facts does not call for the hissings or personal derision.
I asked a question whether or not Bush should turn his back on the foundation of his government, and got no clear answer, hoping that I'd get a interesting answer and I get attacked.
I stated that religion is very much integrated into politics; this is true (there's no debate here, if you really want support I'll give it).
Someone wanted a debate. There's no right or wrong in a debate; that's why it's a debate.
I'm not saying I'm right and you're wrong here.
My suggestion is if you can't help but get personal then leave the arguement or act like a mature human being.
Will you always like what you read? No.
Do I agree with everything everyone says? No.
Nor should you here.
Read with a grain of salt. 
me, i'm a dyslexic atheist.
i don't believe in an all knowing, all seeing, omnipetent dog
another specific problem i have with organized religion, and specifically Christianity here, is the whole 'if you dont believe you are going to hell.' i find that preposterous. what if YOU (who follow Christianity) are wrong? where will you go? i think its quite obvious that since there is NO concrete evidence a God exists beyond FAITH, and there is more than ONE type of religion that people shouldnt go around saying if you dont believe, its your ass! if i dont believe in your hell, how can i go there? all you do is believe in it, its not like you are the gatekeeper deciding who gets in and who doesnt.
i think that having faith or believing in a God should be for yourself, not so you can tell others how to live their lives...late/
editor's corrections
I wish some of you would put have a thought next time into baseless statements. I am sure this thread is full of them all ready, but here are just some that poked at me to much:
first, Thor's first post said:
| quote: |
The holy wars/crusades were wars being fought under 'gods' name, no different from Roman invasions of other countries. Yet to their own people they wrote it off to 'helping' bring people to their god.. |
| quote: |
Yeah, I always enjoy pointing that out. Well a principle element of Christianity is "Thou Shalt Not Kill," Christianity is responsible for millions of deaths. The crusades wiped out millions, all because beliefs differed. |
| quote: |
| But I will say this. Bush is right. The founding fathers of the USA were all God-fearing, righteous men with a strong sense of liberty, peace and justice for all. It's written in their laws and even on their own money. Why should he turn his back on the very foundation his own government believes in for a small minority? |
| quote: |
"Religions are all alike -- founded on fables and mythologies." "Certain teachings in the Bible are as diamonds in a dung-heap". Thomas Jefferson |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Fir3start3r Now I may have said that Bush was right, but I never did say I agreed with it now did I? There seems to be some great assumtion here. I'm not saying this to appease the two obvious atheists/agnostics here, just stating facts about a country and it's beliefs. There no need to finger point in a debate or get personal here. I'm stating Bush's beliefs and facts here people and the country he serves. If you feel threatened then phone HIM and explain is to HIM; I didn't attack anyone here, rather I was asked for my opinion. It's fine that some may not agree with the most powerful country in the world but just because I state facts does not call for the hissings or personal derision. I asked a question whether or not Bush should turn his back on the foundation of his government, and got no clear answer, hoping that I'd get a interesting answer and I get attacked. I stated that religion is very much integrated into politics; this is true (there's no debate here, if you really want support I'll give it). Someone wanted a debate. There's no right or wrong in a debate; that's why it's a debate. I'm not saying I'm right and you're wrong here. My suggestion is if you can't help but get personal then leave the arguement or act like a mature human being. Will you always like what you read? No. Do I agree with everything everyone says? No. Nor should you here. Read with a grain of salt. |
Sorry man!| quote: |
| Why should he turn his back on the very foundation his own government believes in for a small minority? |
| quote: |
| How do I know this? I've been to a business meeting where a political figure spoke and they answered a question regarding religion in politics. |
Sorry for the sarcasm, but you can't call yourself an expert over hearing one guy speak about the integreation. I agree that religion is more intwined with Politics, but it shouldn't be. Anyone who thinks seperation of church/state is a bad idea, I am very weary of.| quote: |
| And oh yea...no one has ever built a statue of a critic... |
atheists are bad people shame on them!
just a simple logical argument the christian folk who believe Atheists are bad people:
Do you believe that all Christians are good people because they are christians?
Then why do you believe that all Atheists are bad people since they don't believe in a God?
The argument as you notice points to a fact that your belief has little to do many times with the fact that you are or are not a Good or Bad person.
Thank you,
Yoepus
The Israelites were all waiting anxiously at the foot of the mountain, knowing that Moses had had a tough day negotiating with god. Finally a tired Moses came into sight. "I've got some good news and some bad news, folks," he said. "The good news is that I got Him down to ten. The bad news is that adultery's still in."
Crusades are defined as:
Expeditions undertaken, in fulfilment of a solemn vow, to deliver the Holy Places from Mohammedan tyranny.
I'm not justifying what the Christians or the Muslims did. I'm just saying that each believed that the Holy Places were their's rightfully, and that force was the only way to reclaim them, thus resulting in many deaths.
I also never said the reasons were petty.
As for an accurate number of deaths, I would definitely guess over a million.
8 Crusades in all. The first, 1095-1101, the second, 1145-47, the third 1188-92, the fourth where Constantinople fell 1204, the fifth 1217, the sixth involved two instances 1228-29 and 1239, the seventh 1249-52, and the eigth 1270.
Over all this time, I'm almost certain that the fatalities on each side combied exceeded over 1 million.
"Ok sorry.. but I have to try and save this board form all the ignorant remarks and blazing idiocies when it comes to history. Opinions are all good, but fact is fact. "
Gee. Thanx. You've done a great job. I feel saved now.
To conclude, I never argued about the purpose of the crusades, or who was right or wrong. I just stated the fact that "Thou shalt not kill" is one of the most deeply rooted Christian commandments, and overtime, Christianity has been the cause for a lot of killing.
Re: editor's corrections
Wow, you miss my point. Religion christian/muslim doesn't matter, it brought wars because of belief. I'm not saying the Crusades weren't justified, the Muslims left no choice. But the point I guess I didn't make clear was the no matter the justification, killing for your god has been a popular pastime for 1000's of years.
You can call me baseless, but you also read a little too much into what I said and lets just say ran with it 
The mention of the Roman empire invading and comparing it to holy wars/crusades was that one was based on God (christians/muslims) the other was based on wealth/control... I quite admire the Roman empire, its downfall was when constantine made the Roman empire christian, which I recall was the period when Roma had lost most of its influence and the western Roman empire was all but done with thanks to the Goth/barbarian re-claiming their territory and defeating Romans to the brink of defeat.
Its funny but what you said to refute what I said was something I agree with fully. I love to see people who actually have learned something about this era since its effects on history are so important. But I think you mis-understood my meanings, and calling it baseless, when in fact it is not. You are not the only one who knows Ancient history, please don't assume I have no clue about it either 
The second quote was not from me, only the first one...
The second quote was mine, and as you said, you haven't read the entire thread, so don't jump to conclusions about statements which you don't fully understand the context of. Trying to belittle people when you admittingly don't have all the information is just ingnorant.
Gosh you call a few people stupid and they get all angry about it.. who would have known?
heheh
No but Thor it was a baseless claim as you did not back it up with anything. You just said they were similiar, I said they were far from similar. Other then being fought I can't see how similar they really were. As a generalization the Romans did not fight for God, the Chrisitans did. And I also believe that Christianity was a leading cause of collapse of the Roman Empire.. but I'm to lazy to get to an indepth anaylisis of that so you'll have to take my workd for it... Plus Thor already agrees with me here
Devbert, I have read all the thread. Secondly I do understand the statements. Of course there are no exact numbers on the people killed durning the cursades, but if you try and figure out how many people did live in land the Cursades took place, and size of the armies that were involved in the countless sorties more then a million over the periods you stated is quiet high. Further more you can consider other wars such as the internal conflict in the Bytazine empire (which you call the Cursades 5-8), as well as the Muslim invasion of the Bytazine empire durning this time of which many western Christians were urged to fight for and protect (though little really did).
But once again you are right.. it all could have been avoided. Previouly Christians were allowed to make pilgrimage to Jerusalem. Had they been continued to access such Holy sites this could have been avoided. Of course when the Chrisitans took over the holy site they did not grant Muslim pilgrims much benifits either.. but the game didn't start with them...
But oh well I see the point you were trying to make you said
| quote: |
| just stated the fact that "Thou shalt not kill" is one of the most deeply rooted Christian commandments, and overtime, Christianity has been the cause for a lot of killing. |
True, but from what I've read, armies ranged in size from a few thousand to up to 20,000. And there were multiple armies moving at a time, and fighting went on adding up to decades. So it is definitely possible.
And yes, you have corrected my slip in words.
Old testament pal, not Old bible.
Right back at ya slugger 
End of this debate???
Re: editor's corrections
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Yoepus Oh what's that you say? More stupidity? No you don't say...? What yes you do? Really? No!.. oh, oh yes you do... In God We Trust has always been on our money eh? It was on the money of our founders.. it must have always been there right?! Absolutely wrong. Don't believe me? You can check out what your own Treasury Department says (these are the guys who coin and mint them with that phrase) The Link Or in brief it says this; They came up with the idea to put God We Trust on the money in 1861. And only since 1908/9 has the motto been in continuous use on the US coins. |
| quote: |
| Ok sorry.. but I have to try and save this board form all the ignorant remarks and blazing idiocies when it comes to history. Opinions are all good, but fact is fact. |

). 
Re: Re: editor's corrections
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Fir3start3r Ok, so not all the founding fathers were Christians or God fearing. I admit defeat in not being 100% accurate and therefore must be stupid! Will no one answer my question without skirting the issue? I'll rephrase the question I guess. Now lets all have a momentary state of disbelieve (lol..that should be easy for the agnostics...). Should a President be basing his countries decisions on the feelings of a small minority? Whomever that minority should be; not necessarily a religious minority either... |

Re: Re: Re: editor's corrections
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Devbert I never said that you were stupid. I was just pointing out the clerical error being made. No personnal attack was stated. If so, please reference it. To your question about the President basing his countries decisions: the minority is always an issue. This country is made up of tons of different types of minorities, and they all need to be equally respected. You can't always please everyone, but you should try to as much as possible. Especially as the President, whose first job is to unite us Americans as human beings. That can't be done if he ignores and berates different minorities, be it religious, sexual, ethnic, etc. And if we're gonna play the quote game, I'll throw down a bunch of goodies. ![]() "People demand freedom of speech to make up for the freedom of thought which they avoid. " - Soren Aabye Kierkegaard (1813-1855) "Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former. " - Albert Einstein (1879-1955) "It was the experience of mystery -- even if mixed with fear -- that engendered religion." - Albert Einstein (1879-1955) "Everything has been figured out, except how to live. " - Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980) "Hell is other people. " - Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980) |


Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.