producer vs dj - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- producer vs dj
Pages (2): « 1 [2]

Posted by 1_last_breath on Dec-27-2006 19:37:

i think we were talking about voting a bad dj just because he's a great producer

Posted by 1_last_breath on Dec-27-2006 19:38:

you can't compare a work of a dj with a work of a producer. there are two diferrent things on so many levels

Posted by Az on Dec-27-2006 20:09:

I'm sure i posted in this thread, about the incest?

Posted by distant on Dec-27-2006 20:19:

quote:
Originally posted by Soeder
I think it's great that people start crediting the producers instead of dj's. alot of dj's earns alot for lousy work!
while producing a great track doesn't nessesearly make much profit at all.
If there was more money and honor in producing i think there would be much more gifted musicians producing trance (or it would be more seriousity in producing), and the scene would be on a taken to a higher level.
That's my thoughts anyway

So you'd nominate someone for a Nobel prize because he's a good producer?

Posted by Soeder on Dec-27-2006 21:36:

quote:
Originally posted by 1_last_breath
you can't compare a work of a dj with a work of a producer. there are two diferrent things on so many levels

the point is that the dj depend on the producers and they won't be able to do their work properly with shitty productions.

quote:
So you'd nominate someone for a Nobel prize because he's a good producer?

no, wouldn't nominate a producer for the nobel prize.
If you think that's excactly the same thing, then that's you.

Posted by distant on Dec-27-2006 21:46:

quote:
Originally posted by Soeder
no, wouldn't nominate a producer for the nobel prize.
If you think that's excactly the same thing, then that's you.

Considering the post you quoted, your opinion is that a good producer should receive a best DJ award. So I think my analogy is correct.

Posted by skip on Dec-27-2006 21:55:

quote:
Originally posted by Soeder
I think it's great that people start crediting the producers instead of dj's. alot of dj's earns alot for lousy work!
while producing a great track doesn't nessesearly make much profit at all.
If there was more money and honor in producing i think there would be much more gifted musicians producing trance (or it would be more seriousity in producing), and the scene would be on a taken to a higher level.
That's my thoughts anyway

sure, i think producers should get more credit for their work. but that doesn't make the djs. so there's no point AT ALL to vote for them in a dj poll. even if the producer is a dj there's no point voting for him on a dj poll based on his productions, because the dj poll is about djing, not about producing.

Posted by Soeder on Dec-27-2006 22:07:

i get that point, but there's no public producer poll with many participants and media attention so it's not easy to credit producers any other way. It's not the best way to do it, but the way i see it, the only option. And they're allready nominated.

Posted by Jordan Stevens on Dec-28-2006 00:55:

flame me if you like but this thread is the dumbest thing i have ever seen on these forums. EVER.

THIS THREAD F T L

Posted by 1_last_breath on Dec-28-2006 10:34:

bad children, bad

Pages (2): « 1 [2]