LIVE Trance Producers..... Why are there none?

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Australia
-- LIVE Trance Producers..... Why are there none?
Pages (2): « 1 [2]

Posted by EgosXII on May-07-2008 01:24:

quote:
Originally posted by batemanscott
I think that if you love all of a producers tunes you will like them live but as much as i would probably lick sander van doorns balls i still dont think i would want to hear a whole set of just his tunes and he's the only producer that has blown me away with everything he has released.

i said in the last post as well tho-- even tho some tracks in his set aren't PRODUCED by him, they're all stuff that he WOULD produce, if he'd thout of the sound first
it's not like he's really playing random stuff- he plays his sound, which is one type of sound. so tho some aren't his productions, they might as well be... if that makes sense..
makes sense with Sander too, since a lot of people are mimiking his style atm..

sander tune
sander sound-alike
sander tune
sander sound-alike
sander sound-alike
sander tune

etc

Posted by EgosXII on May-07-2008 01:26:

quote:
Originally posted by tachyon
Once you start playing other people's tunes on Ableton, I don't consider it live, I don't even would call that a DJ set. Once you take beatmatching out of the game, unless you playing your own tunes, I consider that fucking cheating....

yeah i agree with you there mate- was saying that pvd tries to sit in the middle of it i think... not sure if it works...

Posted by ONION on May-07-2008 20:26:

A lot of producers cant actually play an instrument. Which is pretty amusing when you think about it. Therefore the musical aspect of a Live performance generally gets lost. Most guys that play Live now, just tweak the fuck out of the synths / loops playing in Ableton off a midi controler. When Cosmic Baby played Live [ at the Palace ] - he played the actual instruments in front of the crowd.

I think in order for a Live performance to be interesting for a lot of people, the tracks played should sound like a complete remix... where the crowd feels they are getting a spontaneous UNIQUE version of the tracks they like - just for them.

Posted by steve_may on May-08-2008 01:06:

totally down with scottsburn and dean0s on the live stuff... gets a bit "samey".
listen to a lot of an artists productions and they have a trademark sound in 95% of cases, and 60 mins of this same "trademark sounds" will get a bit.... sameish?
DJ = Disc Jockey
FJ = File Jockey (ableton) still smashing out tunes, track selection, so long as its good, i dont care how the person is delivering the tunes.

Posted by vanilla_cola on May-08-2008 05:12:

After playing around with ableton for the last few months the idea of watching someone play it live really diminished the magic.

Just to play your tunes you have to warp EVERYTHING at home before you play, it pretty much just eliminates beat matching for a DJ and gives you more control over manipulating the songs structure (through making loops in a gui over cdj, or jumping to different points in the song seemlessly). But by doing this you can create some interesting mashup's and remixes while playing live.

Having said that it's a fantastic tool to make sets at home as they will always be perfect tempo wise giving you more time to concertrate on other aspects (i.e. above & beyond, armin etc...).

I think I would still prefer to watch a producer slug their way on with vinyl and cdjs.

Posted by mmkoiman on May-08-2008 06:59:

quote:
Originally posted by pkcRAISTLIN
yuk. they both suck since they split.

clearly you weren't there then

Posted by Breeze on May-08-2008 11:18:

00.db

Posted by Dj_Es-Dva on May-08-2008 22:45:

quote:
Originally posted by tachyon
but why compromise integrity? Once you start playing other people's tunes on Ableton, I don't consider it live, I don't even would call that a DJ set. Once you take beatmatching out of the game, unless you playing your own tunes, I consider that fucking cheating. Have a look at Sasha these days for example. Fuck I love Mongoose but his sets are incredibly fucking boring these days. Digweed however, is entirely different story....

Back to our initial discussion, wasn't there a party a year or two back called Alive which mostly consist of Live acts? Maybe Bill can fill us in on that one?

I saw flyers for the second one b-live a while ago, bill knew nothing apparently...

Pages (2): « 1 [2]