!!! & The Field [Video] - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- !!! & The Field [Video]
Pages (2): « 1 [2]

Posted by Guest on May-10-2008 14:07:

The Field's remix of Thom Yorke is hot.....so is his one ambient techno album From Here We Go Sublime. A1...sick.

Posted by Trance-M on May-10-2008 18:15:

Could someone explain to me why this is much better that what eg Underworld, Chemical Brothers and Faithless has been doing for years? It's presented like it's something new.

It does sound nice by the way.

Posted by PETRAN on May-10-2008 18:34:

quote:
Originally posted by Trance-MB
Could someone explain to me why this is much better that what eg Underworld, Chemical Brothers and Faithless has been doing for years? It's presented like it's something new.

It does sound nice by the way.

Hmmm, maybe the idea is not new, but the music definitely is. I mean, faithless' music was much more linear and mainstream with a typical EDM/pop structure of the era, whereas in this case The Field's loops accompanied by the live playing of !!!, creates a more non-linear, freestyle, kind of "jamming" session which is awesome to look and listen to. You don't see this interactive thing in modern EDM much often. I would definitely like to see future producers and musicians leave their bed-rooms and adopt more organic, hardware/live-playing ways of making music.

Posted by nefardec on May-10-2008 18:45:

it's already been said, but this is not exactly new either - it borrows heavily from psychedelic rock.

it just sounds really cool.

i fucking love it

Posted by PETRAN on May-10-2008 18:51:

quote:
Originally posted by nefardec
it's already been said, but this is not exactly new either - it borrows heavily from psychedelic rock.

it just sounds really cool.

i fucking love it

Yes i know, i was the one bringing the psychedelic-rock comparison, because it brought to mind Ozric Tentacles and some 60s bands. Yes, its obvious that muscially these things have been done before, it is not obvious that they have been done within EDM much often. Maybe Underworld and The Chemical Brothers have performed in similar ways but it is still rare.

Posted by idoru on May-10-2008 18:55:

It's certainly not new by any means (even Way Out West's live act had a drummer and a guitarist or two), but you can't really compare it to Underworld, who don't use a drummer or a bassist and Karl uses the guitar maybe only half of the time during their live performances.

Posted by Trance-M on May-10-2008 19:42:

quote:
Originally posted by PETRAN
Hmmm, maybe the idea is not new, but the music definitely is. I mean, faithless' music was much more linear and mainstream with a typical EDM/pop structure of the era, whereas in this case The Field's loops accompanied by the live playing of !!!, creates a more non-linear, freestyle, kind of "jamming" session which is awesome to look and listen to. You don't see this interactive thing in modern EDM much often. I would definitely like to see future producers and musicians leave their bed-rooms and adopt more organic, hardware/live-playing ways of making music.

True, although Faithless did have some nice and surpising live versions. Underworld and The Chemical Brothers probably jammed a lot more.

I think it would be best if only few would start performing like this, because it should stay special. Compare to vocals in nowadays trance...

I heard at ASOT350 one of the DJ's brought his synths, but to be honest, I need to listen again to hear that

There are/were some other live performers. In Holland around 1990/91 Quazar started performing live combining Techno, Clubhouse and funky acid and mainstream pop.

Also there is a Dutch dance/trance band called Dyna-Saw, but I never heard of them, just googled a bit.
http://www.dyna-saw.nl/MEDIA.html

Then I found one which some over here really might like:

Reflections - Live Trance Band

Posted by Ek0nomik on May-10-2008 20:12:

Posted by winston on May-10-2008 20:48:

quote:
Originally posted by Kris G
for you fags that missed this thread: this is real electronic music

no such thing, fag.

Posted by Trance-M on May-10-2008 22:28:

quote:
Originally posted by Ek0nomik
How is it presented like it's something new?

The other topic gives me that impression, but I don't think it's new and also don't believe it's going to be the future:

I think this is where the future of electronic music is heading...

Posted by SMC on May-11-2008 09:05:

quote:
Originally posted by PETRAN
Ozric Tentacles

The Ozrics ftw!

Posted by stev�sto on May-12-2008 02:41:

coldplay with no words

Posted by PETRAN on May-12-2008 02:43:

quote:
Originally posted by stev�sto
coldplay with no words

What? This video?

Posted by DOOMBOT on May-12-2008 03:26:

Great stuff. Thanks for the video link.

Posted by Ek0nomik on May-12-2008 04:50:

quote:
Originally posted by PETRAN
What? This video?

I don't think so...

Posted by stev�sto on May-12-2008 10:47:

quote:
Originally posted by Ek0nomik
I don't think so...

yea im just saying it reminds me of coldplay, it sounds like a coldplay song without the words, thats all. i think its very nice, but just pointing out some similiarity thats all. you could probably put the acapella of a coldplay song over it and it would line up.

Pages (2): « 1 [2]