TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Chill Out Room
-- Creative Zen or Ipod?
Pages (4): « 1 [2] 3 4 »

I have had an 8 gig ipod nano for two years now. I have had no problems with it so I don't think you would go wrong by getting one, the size is good (although they have changed it since I got mine) for the types of things you want to use it for. I got mine as a gift, if I was purchasing it myself I would have done a solid comparison to the sandisk and creative products before I got it.

hey lisa! =) long time no talk

FWIW I own a zen 16gb and I love it. Was never an ipod fan so I went this route. it's really light and compatible, you'll need to do some fiddling with the conversion software to load in videos but it's nothing big.

I have both, get the Zen.

u won't go wrong with either. Just choose one that fits u, and has what u want as far as storage and looks. Don't listen to these tools who say stay away from Ipod, as they probably dropped it down 3 flights of stairs or dunked it in a toilet and wonder why it doesn't work like it used to. They both are excellent players.

I bought my 80Gb classic a couple of months ago and i coudnt be happier with it and i use it all the time. In the car, in school (why listen to boring lectures when i could be geeking it out by watching anime) and while exercising. Like it was pointed out already, if you dont drop it on the floor all the time it will be ok.

I have owned both, and I'd go with the iPod simply because of size.

Fuck them both I tried them and they suck. Go with Sandisk or Iriver. The convenience with sandisk and Iriver mp3 players is that you wont need to install any kind of software. When you plug them into any usb port they will show up as another drive. Then you can transfer your music easy as drag and drop.

quote:

Originally posted by Direct Fuck them both I tried them and they suck. Go with Sandisk or Iriver. The convenience with sandisk and Iriver mp3 players is that you wont need to install any kind of software. When you plug them into any usb port they will show up as another drive. Then you can transfer your music easy as drag and drop.

oh my, using iTunes is extremely difficult, as the whole drag and drop thing takes some getting used to I guess...

I have a 4GB Nano (1st gen) and it's great...compact, just enough storage.

I bought my Zen for it's line-in recorder and it quickly usurped my iPod as my prefered player. The headphone level is a little colder, but the battery life is excellent and the interface is comparable.

I have a 30 GB Zen.

Problems:
- volume is too low even at the maximum
- started taking a bit long to search for tunes and will get a big confused at times, once I started filling it with lots of music, like 15GB
- the only way to charge it is by connecting it by USB to the computer, there's a normal electricity charger but you have to buy it separate

Apart from these issues, it rocks. Plenty of functions, good audio quality, etc.

quote:

Originally posted by KiNeTiC ENeRgY oh my, using iTunes is extremely difficult, as the whole drag and drop thing takes some getting used to I guess...

+1

it's not hard, seriously. i've had the 3rd generation iPod for years and I haven't had a single problem with it since, only thing i dislike is the battery life. if you take care of your things, they'll work.

I went with the Creative Zen. I really couldn't decide, they both seem similar, but in the end money played the main factor. As much as I wanted a big hard drive, I also wanted something small and that I could use at the gym. I also want to get some decent headphones and so I am using the money I saved from not buying the ipod for that. I also change my mind often and I will probably want a new one in about 2 years or so.

Thanks everyone for your help!

Hi- kidnyce!

quote:

Originally posted by KiNeTiC ENeRgY as they probably dropped it down 3 flights of stairs or dunked it in a toilet and wonder why it doesn't work like it used to. They both are excellent players.

I did that to my sansa and it still works.

No, I've never purchased an ipod - my knowledge of them being shit comes from several months of work experience as a vendor in a computer store specialized in apple products along with an official ipod specialist certification from apple on all 3rd gen ipods and prior models. I've seen everything in my time there - batteries dying after a week, tons of purchases being returned within a couple of days due to malfunction, all sorts of bugs (incompatibility, information transfer problems, frequent UI crashes), burnt screens, unresponsive controls - all of this on brand new products. There are far better products out there that don't get as much attention because they don't have the marketing ressources that apple has.

So maybe you got an ipod and by some stroke of luck, it hasn't let you down yet, good for you. The bottom line is, when you buy an ipod, you get a lesser build quality, less support and less features for a much higher price. It's a bad purchase any way you look at it.

quote:

Originally posted by KiNeTiC ENeRgY oh my, using iTunes is extremely difficult, as the whole drag and drop thing takes some getting used to I guess...

Here's a crazy concept you iPod lovers might not be familiar with:

"Removable hard drives"

Basically what that means is you just plug in your MP3 player into ANY computer and it's recognized as a removable hard drive, making the transfer of files much easier. It doesn't require the bullshit Apple process of doing everything through iTunes, which means that if somebody doesn't have iTunes, you're still fine (with a regular MP3 player). With the iPod, you're not getting those files on there without iTunes.

ps. another option for iPod though, is the Rockbox firmware which makes the iPod a worthwhile product. Just be careful cause it might void the warranty, and we all know how shoddy the iPods can be.

quote:

Originally posted by infinity HiGH Here's a crazy concept you iPod lovers might not be familiar with: "Removable hard drives" Basically what that means is you just plug in your MP3 player into ANY computer and it's recognized as a removable hard drive, making the transfer of files much easier. It doesn't require the bullshit Apple process of doing everything through iTunes, which means that if somebody doesn't have iTunes, you're still fine (with a regular MP3 player). With the iPod, you're not getting those files on there without iTunes. ps. another option for iPod though, is the Rockbox firmware which makes the iPod a worthwhile product. Just be careful cause it might void the warranty, and we all know how shoddy the iPods can be.

My Creative Zen V isn't like that either, but it IS properly supported by all of the audio library type apps. WMP, Winamp, Songbird, etc. So I am not annoyed with it at all.

ZEN!

I haven't posted here in months but you can believe me. And there is a larger size than the 16gig one, as I have a 30gig and am extremely happy with it. On the off chance you'll use it for videos, the playback is flawless and the picture quality for the screen size is phenomenal. Ipod's are simply inferior products to a handful of mp3 players floating around now days.

did you FINALLY get internet back!?

lol, i thought i was seeing things when i saw that D-res had the last post in COR.

No, posting at girlfriends house lol

Still working on that whole internet thing






Woop woop zen!

quote:

Originally posted by l�cid lol, i thought i was seeing things when i saw that D-res had the last post in COR.

lol when I saw his name I was like, wait is that who I think it is!? And sure enough, same avatar.

quote:

Originally posted by D-res No, posting at girlfriends house lol Still working on that whole internet thing Woop woop zen!

Well hurry up already!!!!!!!!! hehe

that zen comes in sizes of up to 32gb, and still sports an expansion slot using SDHC, which today, the largest available size is 16gb (expect 32gb to be available by the end of the year). so really, you *can* go up to 64gb of storage, just not yet (though, thats when its packed, this doesnt include other SD cards one may havine lying around)

The zen pisses all over the ipod when it comes to features and its still smaller. It plays back divx/xvid natively without the need for converting videos to h.264, radio, voice recorder....

the only thing i dont like about it, as i also dont like this about nearly every other player (except for iAudio and iRiver) is that it doesnt fast forward any faster than about 15-30 seconds per second of fast forwarding, this makes it very annoying listening to livesets that last more than 30 minutes. The ipods scroll wheel is best in this regards, as it allows you direct access to a particular point of an mp3 at any time. iRivers and iAudio do, however, allow you to scroll through tracks at various speeds; 2X, 4X, 8X and 16X which is extremely fast and does the job fine.

If it had that feature, I think id be sold.

Right now, Im waiting on the iRiver e100 revision which is a very similar player to the creative zen:




however iriver is pulling it from shelves and will offer an updated version of it sometime in the next few months.

ps. that iriver does have the 'super' fast forwarding, as well as many other goodies including a microSD slot.

The 32gb is available NOW.

Does the Zen have support for formats outside of mp3, wma, and aac? It doesn't say it does according to their site. The reason I ask, is due to the fact that I have a range of formats. MP3, WMA, AAC, FLAC, and some OGG also. I hate converting.

Oh yeah, definitely get Sennheiser CX300, I got them week or two ago and they're just too good.

quote:

Originally posted by Fledz Definitely stay away from the iTouch

I've personally love the iPod Touch, and it'll be even better once Firmware 2.0 comes out next month. Obviously price is big factor, but it is the ultimate media player.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.