TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Production Studio
-- Finally! A new synth announcement from Musikmesse that isn't "meh"!
Pages (2): « 1 [2]

i already pre ordered mine, can't wait till it gets here

quote:

Originally posted by Beatflux Gearslutz vs TA?

Naw, there are plenty of people here who can appreciate quality work without getting caught up in something as simplistic and meaningless as analog-vs-digital or hardware-vs-software debates. And there are plenty of people on gearslutz who wouldn't recognize analog if it bit them on the ass. Why some of you guys can't think beyond that is pretty puzzling and I don't think age is, or should be, an excuse.

The mere fact that some people can only come up with a poor attempt at condescension by referring to someone who admires a quality hardware synthesizer as "analog fanboys" shows a tremendous amount of ignorance. Most intelligent people can appreciate the time, effort, intellect, attention to detail, etc. that goes into creating an instrument like the Schmidt synth. To boil it down to analog fanboyism shows a total lack of ability to think beyond the tired old analog-digital debate or otherwise form any sort of coherent logic.

From a musician's standpoint it just doesn't look practical in any respect, even though it looks like a technical marvel.

To me it sounds really ordinary and old school. Seems like those analog fanboys just love to hear that same old subtractive/modular synth sound in a new shinier, prettier box with MORE BUTTONS! ANALOG POLYPHONY ALWAYS GETS ME HARD!

quote:

Originally posted by Beatflux From a musician's standpoint it just doesn't look practical in any respect, even though it looks like a technical marvel.

I totally agree. But, if there's one thing that synth is NOT about, it's practicality. As the designer himself said, (paraphrasing) he built the most incredible synth that he ever wanted. Not really something a bedroom producer would buy or a gigging musician would lug around to smoke-filled bars.

quote:

Originally posted by Beatflux From a musician's standpoint it just doesn't look practical in any respect

and tweaking knobs with mouse on VST does ?

you can't deny that this synth is a monster (with a monster pricetag)

i don't think its directed at performance though more of a sound design tool

quote:

Originally posted by cryophonik Naw, there are plenty of people here who can appreciate quality work without getting caught up in something as simplistic and meaningless as analog-vs-digital or hardware-vs-software debates. And there are plenty of people on gearslutz who wouldn't recognize analog if it bit them on the ass. Why some of you guys can't think beyond that is pretty puzzling and I don't think age is, or should be, an excuse. The mere fact that some people can only come up with a poor attempt at condescension by referring to someone who admires a quality hardware synthesizer as "analog fanboys" shows a tremendous amount of ignorance. Most intelligent people can appreciate the time, effort, intellect, attention to detail, etc. that goes into creating an instrument like the Schmidt synth. To boil it down to analog fanboyism shows a total lack of ability to think beyond the tired old analog-digital debate or otherwise form any sort of coherent logic.

if it was a digital synth (VA) with USB and a computer interface making these sounds i would totally agree with you on every aspect. sadly its a museum object of how things were 40 years ago imo. no wonder its expensive. i believe everything analog is possible to recreate cheaper and more effectively digitally without loosing anything, therefore i find things like this more of a collector/hobby product rather than a instrument for making music. of course its well made and stuff but its like building a fancy fireplace for heating your entire house today - not the smartest decision. some people like gear, others see gear as just tools for greater goal. i just dont get the analog obsession. sometimes analog even sound worse imo.

It looks pretty incredible. It's more the sheer joy of messing with knobs and sliders that gets me, rather then the sound. It's like how most people can't tell a sampled guitar from a real one, but the real one is much more rewarding to play.

Anyways, getting sidetracked. This is probably going to be a mostly collector's item. Well, until Jean Michel Jarre gets his hands of power on them.

quote:

Originally posted by rulzz and tweaking knobs with mouse on VST does ?

Rageback?

That's what people do now...

Don't like. I only get excited about products that might actually make it to mass production. If he builds 10 in his garden shed, it won't ever have an impact or help anyone other than rich collectors IMO.

Yeah, all you guys here who are surgeons or anesthesiologists pulling in a few hundred thousand a year can buy and enjoy, I guess.

I think its sexy but I don't understand how the good mood lasts once you imagine all the other things you can buy for the same price... that imo would be much much better and capable at inducing wood.

quote:

Originally posted by MrJiveBoJingles Yeah, all you guys here who are surgeons or anesthesiologists pulling in a few hundred thousand a year can buy and enjoy, I guess.

But it will push back the acquisition of my new yacht by a month.

Life is full of tough decisions...

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.