Circ - Destroy she said (De Donatis remix) - Cheese or quality tune?

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Australia
-- Circ - Destroy she said (De Donatis remix) - Cheese or quality tune?
Pages (2): « 1 [2]

Posted by Psygnosis on Mar-31-2003 10:07:

quote:
Originally posted by escee
OOOOH

Tough guy alert.

UHHH here we go again...I was trying to make a point about cheese music. I mean i would bet a million bucks that your peoples opinions towards the CIRC song would be different if PVD never played it..

This just means one thing...and you know what it is.

And i'm not trying to be a TOUGH GUY...i don't care what you people listen to...go listen to country music for all i care...but don't be hypocritical.

Posted by escee on Mar-31-2003 10:11:

i said this song is cheesey, but its good. I, PERSONALLY, like it.

I didnt mind Fragma - Toca Me either, but it was fucked up when they added those vocals.

Edit: im not a huge pvd fan, starfox syle. Id like this song if pvd played it, armin played it, john digweed played it, your mum played it. It wouldnt matter, it doesnt change whats coming out of the speakers. PVD used to play sandstorm, i dont particulary like that track. Tiesto used to play that russian trance track (forget the name of it now, released on perfecto, first played by Oakenfold)

I think most people here would agree with me that the above two mentioned tracks are average at best, but PVD, TIESTO AND OAKENFOLD PLAYED THEM!?! HOW CAN THAT BE?!

Posted by dj_helen_k on Mar-31-2003 11:30:

TUUUUNE

farken!

Posted by Hybrid Junkie on Mar-31-2003 12:32:

quote:
Originally posted by Dj_Psygnosis
UHHH here we go again...I was trying to make a point about cheese music. I mean i would bet a million bucks that your peoples opinions towards the CIRC song would be different if PVD never played it..

This just means one thing...and you know what it is.

That gets the big meh, cos I got it before I heard pvd play it in melbourne, I liked it before I went along, and if anything i'd DISLIKE it more now after pvd played itand all the tops off 45 yr old muzzas are lovin it.

As itchy said, it doesn't matter who's played it. It's what it sounds like, not the stigma attatched to it. And I think you're the one judging it by it's potential cheese factor instead of giving it a fair appraisal.

Posted by screwtiny on Mar-31-2003 12:54:

Well there appears to be a great debate as to weather or not this track is worth a listen.. perhaps someone could provide me with a link so i provide my opinion on the matter?

Posted by waXology on Mar-31-2003 13:38:

i think its good that people disagree shows we are all passionate about the music..

anyways at firts ididnt like this track and thought it would be great if paul removed the vocals!.............but after extensive listening i began to change my opinion and then seeing him play the track both in Melbourne the Sydney it affirmed that this track is a TUNE.

as as was stated before dont look at trance listen, this is what im doing.! when he dropped it at QBH i seriously got goosbumps all over my body, and if a track can do that to me then i rate it extremely highly!

so for mine i love this track!

just a point on it, does anyone know who Circle Zero (Circ) are? because it does sound a lot like this track is influenced by pvd, i mean the bassline almost sounds like another way.

Posted by escee on Apr-01-2003 00:02:

I think there should be less vocals though. Just perhaps the main part. I also think the track should be longer.

PVD's Remix in a can techniques are welcome for this tune.

Posted by stipsy on Apr-01-2003 00:41:

its got the gayest vocal and the gayest melody that i could have done on reason in 90 seconds...

in conclusion this song is

Posted by Simon00 on Apr-01-2003 00:41:

I don't mind it. A dub would be good though. Is this the version he played in sydney sun night? I did go upstairs for 5 min when the dancefloor temp hit 1,000 degree's.

Posted by screwtiny on Apr-01-2003 03:15:

It's not a bad track. But by no means would I rave about it. I must agree with the previous comments concerning the poor vocals in this track.

Posted by OzTi�sto on Apr-01-2003 19:56:

I have to say.....if you had to say whether it was cheesy or not...it's closer to cheese than not cheese....but hell...I like it

Posted by eRRaTiK on Apr-02-2003 02:09:

shut up all ! looky here...

that is all

Posted by JayKuE on Apr-02-2003 02:25:

quote:
Originally posted by eRRaTiK
shut up all ! looky here...

that is all

*grin* that goatie does it for me everytime

anyway, circ -destroy she said?
high on the cheesiness scale, but occassional cheese is fine.
but those vocals.... eew.

edit: also i think a lot of cheese[not all, espesh the euro trash.. uggh] are immediate tunes, until they get overplayed or reach commercial success/exposure. e.g. ian van dahl, 4 strings. man, i'm hearing a lotta 'diving' n 'into the night' on the radio as of late.

Posted by JulesPLees on Apr-02-2003 18:43:

Just heard it.

No I dont like it.

Posted by Ves on Apr-03-2003 11:48:

Well I just downloaded this tune, and what can I say...

What a saccharine, pansy piece of fluff! it was an alright tune until those vocals came in. It did seem like a rather mediocre track, something I'd listen to three or four times, and then never touch again. But then those fluffy, overly sentimental vocals came in, and the tune lost the little credibility it had in the first place. Those vocals combined with the 'happy happy' melody is so syrupy! I don�t know whether those are qualities that you all look for in your music, but for me, I don�t like tunes when they are sickeningly sweet.
When I listen to this I immediately imagine pretty doe-eyed young girls holding hands and swaying together amongst the cute little bunny rabbits, underneath a rainbow. It�s laughable!

Well, there is a definite sense of naivety conveyed with this track. Perhaps this is what the producer wanted to bring to the listener- this sense of childlike innocence and purity...
then again, maybe not...
however, I will cling to that idealistic concept as I can then see some sort of artistic merit in this piece; and then it does have credibility in that respect.

It looks like there is a very different response to this tune within a club environment, and I�d love to be able to make an assessment taking into account those factors. But I can�t...so this is the best I can do I�m �fraid.

ahh, whatever does it for you I suppose...!

& I hope you enjoyed this damning report

Posted by DJ Dowlz on Apr-03-2003 12:32:

quote:
Originally posted by Ves
& I hope you enjoyed this damning report

Absolutely! I think you've perfectly captured the essence of that song. Have you considered becoming a reviewer? Seriously!

Posted by escee on Apr-03-2003 13:37:

quote:
Originally posted by Ves
I hope you enjoyed this damning report

hahaha
harsh it up.

So young, so angry, damn that rap music.

Posted by jizza on Apr-03-2003 14:20:

quote:
Originally posted by Ves
& I hope you enjoyed this damning report

wow.

what can i say... cept that i disagree with you.

quote:
When I listen to this I immediately imagine pretty doe-eyed young girls holding hands and swaying together amongst the cute little bunny rabbits, underneath a rainbow.

oh how i yearn for those days again.

such a meticulously written piece of critique, perhaps u should work for rolling stone.

well done Ves, very well done.

Posted by JayKuE on Apr-03-2003 15:05:

quote:
Originally posted by Ves
I immediately imagine pretty doe-eyed young girls holding hands and swaying together amongst the cute little bunny rabbits, underneath a rainbow.

*nod* the way the world should be dun u think?

Posted by SQ-K on Apr-04-2003 01:11:

^^^ absolutely. with extra special emphasis on the doe-eyed young girls...

Nice review Ves. I still love the track , but you captured exactly why many people don't.

Posted by eRRaTiK on Apr-04-2003 03:39:

quote:
Originally posted by Ves
When I listen to this I immediately imagine pretty doe-eyed young girls holding hands and swaying together amongst the cute little bunny rabbits, underneath a rainbow.

wait, wasn't that you and some other TA's at syd two tribes? i'm sure there was a (laser) rainbow some time during armin's set that night

Posted by Jah on Apr-04-2003 04:27:

quote:
Originally posted by Ves
Well, there is a definite sense of naivety conveyed with this track. Perhaps this is what the producer wanted to bring to the listener- this sense of childlike innocence and purity...

i think he just wants the bling bling

Pages (2): « 1 [2]