TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Marcus Schulz vs.....?
Pages (4): « 1 2 [3] 4 »

quote:

Originally posted by Streakfury I used to be like that. If it wasn't hard or uplifting, and played at a relatively fast speed, then I didn't like it. But that's changed now. Although I still listen to the harder side of things, I think Markus is one of the best DJ's I've ever heard.

i used to be like that, i went through a prog phase a while ago back when prog boomed i nthe uk (late 2000ish) and i was like ,what is this? i quickly grew out of it though when realising it is a genre with the depth of a childrens swimming pool. mayeb the people who have been newly exposed to it will realise after a year or so too...


and im sorry, but:

quote:

His music wouldn't be good to dance to in a club (for me at least) because it's too slow, but that doesn't make him any less of a DJ (or producer for that matter).

...makes no sence, a dj is for a club, if you want something to listen to at home you get someone to compose something.

quote:

Originally posted by Ste i used to be like that, i went through a prog phase a while ago back when prog boomed i nthe uk (late 2000ish) and i was like ,what is this? i quickly grew out of it though when realising it is a genre with the depth of a childrens swimming pool. mayeb the people who have been newly exposed to it will realise after a year or so too...

heh? prog is all about depth

quote:

and im sorry, but: ...makes no sence, a dj is for a club, if you want something to listen to at home you get someone to compose something.

true, a dj is for the club, but prog/schulz' music IS danceable, may not be as explosive as energetic trance, but has a lot more musical content and a lot less of the 'plastic' feeling trance sometimes gives.

I guess this is all about opinons, and should be about nothing more. No matter what Dj/producer you are be it PvD, Ferry, Tiesto it would be impossible to keep up the momentum that they have all achieved over the years.
Commenting on anyones DJ skills is just an endless argument and criticism that goes around and around.

If you dont think Markus bangs up in the clubs, you should download any of his live sets, a good one would be:

Markus Schulz live @ Space(12-14-2003) part 2

and yes, choice of DJ's is a mtter of taste. I like my eggs scrambled, you may like them Sunny side up, some people like them with beans.

quote:

Originally posted by Ste ...makes no sence, a dj is for a club, if you want something to listen to at home you get someone to compose something.

right on.

quote:

Originally posted by DJ Mikey Mike Oh the irony. I might be wrong in assuming this, but you don't DJ do you? Don't you think it's a little hypocritical to tell Elevation that he cant make comparisons and voice his opinions on DJ's and their skills because he is a shitty DJ, when you don't actually DJ yourself? What makes it right for you to express your opinion but not him? At least he's trying / learning.

I've owned turntables for over 5 years and I know how to work them pretty well although I don't consider myself a dj anymore. but I'm first and foremost a musician, and I think I have acquired enough knowledge over years of experience studying music to come to a personal opinion that is backed up by theory and my trained ear.

yeah and it's great for him to be trying/learning. but still....since i think he's pretty tone deaf behind the decks, I laugh at his "rankings", which I think are stupid and ill-conceived. but hey, that's just my opinion. if you don't like it then cry me a river.

Wow, this forum has really become corrupted with a lot of negative people lately. The constant disrespect, and the negativity really needs to stop. I am not just saying this because of what Yale Trance wished of me. There have been other comments about my mixing etc�that have really been negative (still a lot of positive however). This neither encourages new artists nor does it encourage me to continue producing and DJing, which I have been dreaming of since I was a kid. Instead of polluting the forums with nasty comments directed to certain people, why don�t you suggest to him/her something to improve on. I have taken piano and organ my whole life and am classically trained in music and am willing to admit that I am no Pro at mixing right now�if ud like to hear quality mixing from someone with 15 years of experience (Markus Schulz) as opposed to not even 1 of public experience listen to GDJB�in fact I don�t have the time to sit around perfecting my turntable skills playing to only about 100-200 people over an internet stream on Trancesphere (which is a big honor and privilege for me to be a part of). Not only am I doing it because I love the music and hope to improve, but I love bringing music to people�it�s a part of me. If you think my mixing or music is so atrocious then don�t listen to it. In fact, as far as I am concerned, I might just quit mixing and producing all together.
Tiesto isn�t what he used to be to me any more. I used to be a hardcore Tiesto fan, and I used to follow his latest tunes and sets regularly. I didn�t hope to bash tiesto in any way as I have huge respect for him in fact (not that it matters ) I�m actually waiting for the TIC DVD to arrive in the mail. IM sorry if I offended you. BTW tiesto has played clear blue a couple times�.which surprises me because tiestos style has been more close to techno now a days�.
You really degrade yourself when you bash others like you just have�and comments like those don�t help the industry at all�Who do you think is going to take over the scene when AVB PVD TIESTO and others are long gone?? Most of the new producers and dj�s you see now�are starting out just as the big guys have�.and are the next generation�.If you would like to see electronic music continue on�have some respect for the people who will make that possible��if you don�t have anything nice to say don�t say it at all �

- Elevation

this is to any other forum members also�

quote:

Originally posted by Elevation Wow, this forum has really become corrupted with a lot of negative people lately. The constant disrespect, and the negativity really needs to stop. I am not just saying this because of what Yale Trance wished of me. There have been other comments about my mixing etc�that have really been negative (still a lot of positive however). This neither encourages new artists nor does it encourage me to continue producing and DJing, which I have been dreaming of since I was a kid. Instead of polluting the forums with nasty comments directed to certain people, why don�t you suggest to him/her something to improve on. I have taken piano and organ my whole life and am classically trained in music and am willing to admit that I am no Pro at mixing right now�if ud like to hear quality mixing from someone with 15 years of experience (Markus Schulz) as opposed to not even 1 of public experience listen to GDJB�in fact I don�t have the time to sit around perfecting my turntable skills playing to only about 100-200 people over an internet stream on Trancesphere (which is a big honor and privilege for me to be a part of). Not only am I doing it because I love the music and hope to improve, but I love bringing music to people�it�s a part of me. If you think my mixing or music is so atrocious then don�t listen to it. In fact, as far as I am concerned, I might just quit mixing and producing all together. Tiesto isn�t what he used to be to me any more. I used to be a hardcore Tiesto fan, and I used to follow his latest tunes and sets regularly. I didn�t hope to bash tiesto in any way as I have huge respect for him in fact (not that it matters ) I�m actually waiting for the TIC DVD to arrive in the mail. IM sorry if I offended you. BTW tiesto has played clear blue a couple times�.which surprises me because tiestos style has been more close to techno now a days�. You really degrade yourself when you bash others like you just have�and comments like those don�t help the industry at all�Who do you think is going to take over the scene when AVB PVD TIESTO and others are long gone?? Most of the new producers and dj�s you see now�are starting out just as the big guys have�.and are the next generation�.If you would like to see electronic music continue on�have some respect for the people who will make that possible��if you don�t have anything nice to say don�t say it at all � - Elevation this is to any other forum members also�

To be fair, I think your productions are pretty mint and I really like Clear Blue. I can't say the same thing about your mixing, but that's a whole different story.

The thing is....(and this is a constructive criticism coming from a classical musician) I think you don't understand the art of mixing too well. Since you're underage I bet you probably haven't been to much clubs and seen most of these djs live haven't you? Well since 1999 I've seen all of these djs many many times and I'm gonna speak from a live-not an MP3-perspective.

Markus and Armin are talented, sure, but they are the Salieri to Tiesto's Mozart. They are djs that go for the instant atmospheric mix to please the ear at the moment with nice melodic flow, while Tiesto's violent contrasting schemes of counterpoint and rhytmic disbalances are just on a higher level when it comes to live appreciation, especially for a classical musician. Groovypants and I are probably the classical TAs with the most seniority, and we strongly agree on this point. It's not like I take criticisms personal, but sometimes when they are beyond the obvious (technical sloppiness et. al.) I feel the need to respond.

And don't take my "threat" seriously, I won't tell Tiesto a thing when I see him tomorrow. I just travelled a thousand miles this morning to the Caribbean to see Tiesto twice this weekend, so my anxiety got me carried away. I'm sorry about that.

Anyways, good luck and keep up the good work.

This thread is humorous... I for one, like Markus, Paul Van Dyk, Tiesto, and Ferry... Why is there a need to compare them? It's pointless. As for the ridicule about Mike (Elevation). He is an excellent producer, and friend. He has already achieved much, at 16, and is nearly a musical genious. As for mixing, he has 3 or 4 years to perfect that particular part of DJing before he hits the clubs. And also, you contradict yourself quite humorously as well, you say internet DJing is a joke compared to real DJing, and mixing and flow is different on the internet than it is at clubs... Well you're judging Mike on his abillity to mix over the internet, at all hours of the night. Not to mention after a long fatiguing day of school. Even if you're not going to tell Tiesto that he'd put him at #6 in the world, which im sure the man himself wouldn't even care, and probally laugh at you, i still find that a funny comment... Reminds me of a 7 year old in elementry school telling the teacher on a kid for calling them gay. Anyways, enough with the bashing, who cares who's better... Different styles, different atmosphere, different person. Oh yeah, and listen to one of Mike and I's radio show's on trancesphere.com on a saturday night... I can't remember the last time either of us "trainwrecked".

quote:

Originally posted by TylerM This thread is humorous... I for one, like Markus, Paul Van Dyk, Tiesto, and Ferry... Why is there a need to compare them? It's pointless. As for the ridicule about Mike (Elevation). He is an excellent producer, and friend. He has already achieved much, at 16, and is nearly a musical genious. As for mixing, he has 3 or 4 years to perfect that particular part of DJing before he hits the clubs. And also, you contradict yourself quite humorously as well, you say internet DJing is a joke compared to real DJing, and mixing and flow is different on the internet than it is at clubs... Well you're judging Mike on his abillity to mix over the internet, at all hours of the night. Not to mention after a long fatiguing day of school. Even if you're not going to tell Tiesto that he'd put him at #6 in the world, which im sure the man himself wouldn't even care, and probally laugh at you, i still find that a funny comment... Reminds me of a 7 year old in elementry school telling the teacher on a kid for calling them gay. Anyways, enough with the bashing, who cares who's better... Different styles, different atmosphere, different person. Oh yeah, and listen to one of Mike and I's radio show's on trancesphere.com on a saturday night... I can't remember the last time either of us "trainwrecked".

of course i wasn't going to tell tiesto and of course he wouldn't give a shit...don't you people have a sense of humor? it's so easy to fuck with people here.



as for Elevation, we're having a respectful discussion over PMs, so that part of the debate is done.

admiy that tijs can't def mix. he plays great tracks indeed, but his mixing is worse than the british railway







you know you want me :*

quote:

Originally posted by arturob admiy that tijs can't def mix. he plays great tracks indeed, but his mixing is worse than the british railway you know you want me :*

shhhhhh

i just know i'm in Puerto Rico right now.

quote:

Originally posted by YaleTrance shhhhhh i just know i'm in Puerto Rico right now.

:P you knew that was coming. heh.

btw... i neeeed latinas mamacitassssssssssssssssss

wtf are you talking about his mixing is good, his track selection is a question to some and flawless to others...


but im not a fan
however i would rather see markus over pvd i just dont like pvd, its all about opinions really u twits....

quote:

Originally posted by DJ Mikey Mike I'll be sure to go see him next time i'm in need of a good nights sleep

hehehehehehe

no shit:

it is pretty redicoulus to compare him to Mr. Van Dyk or Corsten, cmon....

Tiesto is a fuckwad

there, I said it

Pio, I really don't see why you made that original comment. It was very harsh and extremely uncalled for. I think Mike's mixing sucks too, but ffs, he is spending tons of time producing great tracks, while going to highschool, and he is only 17 and hasn't been spinning very long!

Whatever, let's get back on topic, shall we?

i dont mean to hijack this thread even more. . .but

Tiesto is gonna be playing in VIETNAM!!!! Do any of you know how crucial this is?????

quote:

Originally posted by beema Tiesto is a fuckwad there, I said it Pio, I really don't see why you made that original comment. It was very harsh and extremely uncalled for. I think Mike's mixing sucks too, but ffs, he is spending tons of time producing great tracks, while going to highschool, and he is only 17 and hasn't been spinning very long! Whatever, let's get back on topic, shall we?

well...i haven't heard any sets from Elevation, but shit...yeah give him a break...he hasn't been at this long...

anyway,

back on topic...i really like markus' style. i like the fact that he has his own style of mixing and does lots of recontructions and stuff to make his sets unique...

quote:

Originally posted by Busy Child i dont mean to hijack this thread even more. . .but Tiesto is gonna be playing in VIETNAM!!!! Do any of you know how crucial this is?????

If we're lucky, he'll get gonorrhea from a Saigon WHORE!!!

j/k

this is like comparing apples vs automobiles, I mean I love Markus but I definitely dont think hes reached that level, it always appears that the newwer people, even though hes been a round a while, have like a fresher style and what not but I mean these people have serious accomplishments behind them and not to take away from Markus but he just isnt a PvD, Ferry, or Armin.

quote:

Originally posted by YaleTrance Markus and Armin are talented, sure, but they are the Salieri to Tiesto's Mozart. They are djs that go for the instant atmospheric mix to please the ear at the moment with nice melodic flow, while Tiesto's violent contrasting schemes of counterpoint and rhytmic disbalances are just on a higher level when it comes to live appreciation, especially for a classical musician. Groovypants and I are probably the classical TAs with the most seniority, and we strongly agree on this point. It's not like I take criticisms personal, but sometimes when they are beyond the obvious (technical sloppiness et. al.) I feel the need to respond.

It's always the same arguement. "My classically trained ear allows me to appreciate Tiesto's rhythmic... bla bla bla..." It's easy back up your arguement when you claim to know more than everyone else. I've been going to clubs for years now too and I'd like to think I also have a good idea what makes for a good atmosphere in a club. My untrained ear tells me Tiesto isn't the DJ god you make him out to be and I'm not only attributing that to his lack of technical skills....

On topic... I think Markus has some great productions and remixes. He's very slow and melodic but he can bang it out with his breaks mixes too... check out his version of Sasha vs. BT feat. Jan Johnston - Remember Magnetic North....

FFS still going at it...

*my milkshake...brings all....*

No need to compare him to DJ's with a different 'style'

Just enjoy Markus & the others DJ's mentioned!

I'll be there at Godskitchen for Schulz - should be a good night

quote:

Originally posted by beema Tiesto is a fuckwad there, I said it Pio, I really don't see why you made that original comment. It was very harsh and extremely uncalled for. I think Mike's mixing sucks too, but ffs, he is spending tons of time producing great tracks, while going to highschool, and he is only 17 and hasn't been spinning very long! Whatever, let's get back on topic, shall we?

i know, i already apologized...i said that after 48 hrs. of no sleep because i'd been traveling all day to see a certain dj in another continent. still no excuse, but i said i was sorry.

and choobak for the 1000000th time i'm not gonna discuss with you the relativity of something you can't understand.

quote:

Originally posted by paranoik0 heh? prog is all about depth

yeh, its so deep that it all sounds pretty much the same...


wob wob wob *filtered vocalllllllll* *sparkly ambience* wob wob *repeating 4 note melody in a deep style synth.* wob wob wob

quote:

Originally posted by Ste yeh, its so deep that it all sounds pretty much the same... wob wob wob *filtered vocalllllllll* *sparkly ambience* wob wob *repeating 4 note melody in a deep style synth.* wob wob wob

you can pretty much break down and generalise any genre the same way.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.