PVD - Politics Of Dancing - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Album Reviews / New Releases Discussion
-- PVD - Politics Of Dancing
Pages (4): « 1 2 [3] 4 »

Posted by Eugene on Dec-20-2001 17:17:

For a man of such respectable fame and experience, PvD's shy musings about his DJ career and the trance culture (found in the CD booklet) sound a little silly and insincere.

I find it strange how he always emphasizes that he can't really express himself as a DJ unless there's a crowd in front of him, and that's why recording in the studio was difficult for him. This is simply stupid. A DJ expresses himself by his mix, by choosing a mood, or an atmosphere, carefully selecting the rights tracks that fit that mood and planning how they will sound, and mixing them with an artistic touch. Who said it's always necessary to have a crowd in front of you in order to make a good and pleasing mix? This is absurd!! A DJ mix can also be a reflection of how you feel, how you perceive life. And what's with the apologetic "this is actually my first mixed CD" -- I mean really, you're the most influential and experienced DJ (and a millionaire at that) for God's sakes!

Next he starts sounding intelligent by talking about the club/trance culture. "We have forgotten," he writes, "that this is NOT just about dancing. There's more to it. There is a global youth culture." He concludes his essay by saying "Whatever, it's all just about dancing." Huh?

Somebody above said that "Dreamland" is the best track.. I agree with that, but if, from so many progressive and ambient cuts and tracks, you chose the one with an uplifting/epic sound and build-ups and all that, what does that say about the OTHER genre you all claim to love so much... and the one mostly represented on this CD?

Posted by Kurve on Dec-20-2001 19:01:

quote:
Originally posted by Eugene
For a man of such respectable fame and experience, PvD's shy musings about his DJ career and the trance culture (found in the CD booklet) sound a little silly and insincere.

I find it strange how he always emphasizes that he can't really express himself as a DJ unless there's a crowd in front of him, and that's why recording in the studio was difficult for him. This is simply stupid. A DJ expresses himself by his mix, by choosing a mood, or an atmosphere, carefully selecting the rights tracks that fit that mood and planning how they will sound, and mixing them with an artistic touch. Who said it's always necessary to have a crowd in front of you in order to make a good and pleasing mix? This is absurd!! A DJ mix can also be a reflection of how you feel, how you perceive life. And what's with the apologetic "this is actually my first mixed CD" -- I mean really, you're the most influential and experienced DJ (and a millionaire at that) for God's sakes!

Next he starts sounding intelligent by talking about the club/trance culture. "We have forgotten," he writes, "that this is NOT just about dancing. There's more to it. There is a global youth culture." He concludes his essay by saying "Whatever, it's all just about dancing." Huh?

Somebody above said that "Dreamland" is the best track.. I agree with that, but if, from so many progressive and ambient cuts and tracks, you chose the one with an uplifting/epic sound and build-ups and all that, what does that say about the OTHER genre you all claim to love so much... and the one mostly represented on this CD?

listen to your self i think ur just bashin pvd just to bash him..nothing u said made one any sense.mayb ur just finding any lame excuses to bash on him ..come on dont be pathetic. first u said "A DJ mix can also be a reflection of how you feel" Come on listen to ur self....first paul was talking about himself and this is the way he feels he doesnt put down anyone elses cds he just telling everyone about how he felt in making his own cd...... and hes right a cd will never get the aspect of the live crowd ...djing is part mindreading and knowing what the crowd is feeling...... thats why u can listen to a set live and say wow this is amazing when your there but listen to the same set mayb at home on a boring evening or something it might be dull....thats what he ment ... djing is a art and not every set is sutable for everyone and everytime thats why the best djs read crowds to feel what they are feeling and what should be played....and u trying to down him for talking about the culture of clubbing and what it means .....bro hes been into the scene when u were still in diapers .. so dont put him down cuz hes seen more then ull ever seen in the culture....let me quote u " this is absurd!!" hmmm after reading ur post and seeing how big of a deal u make about something so small all have to say ur post is absurd and pointless!

ohh yeah one more thing ur signature shows me thatu need to stop looking at things negatively....signature something that reflects u and u bring up the songs u dont lik shows me u think way more negatively then positively on things....all i have to say be more positive mayb put the songs u do like on the signature rather then the songs u dont like ..make more sense

Posted by prgtrance01 on Dec-24-2001 18:33:

Big PVD fan and I enjoyed the CD. I must say I was a little up set with the fact that all these tracks have been pretty much been being played for some time on dance floors coast to coast. So there was no real big supprises.

Posted by capricorn15 on Dec-29-2001 13:10:

someone said most every mix is done in the studio without turntables, but i remember reading a tiesto interview, he said all his mix cds were live in turntables, i forgot what reason he said, but he said all were live mixes on tables
late

Posted by prgtrance01 on Dec-31-2001 04:00:

All I got to say is that if you think mix CD's are put toghther with Computers your sadly mistaken. Grant it there are some who do it. But most are mixed with tables, at least the people I know. And they run the mix threw those computer programs you all talk about to take out the little imperfections such as : needle noise, sound levels fom record to record and other imperfections. At least this is what DJ's I know do. But it is possabile to mix a cd with these computer programs BT's renisance Singapore is done like that but he also tells you on the cover.

Posted by Cable on Jan-01-2002 00:02:

i think eugene's post makes perfect sense, and i agree

happy new year btw

Posted by PsycoEwok on Jan-01-2002 23:15:

liked it but not the best

When I heard these cd's I admit that I do like them a lot, and they make me even more of a PVD fan, but in my personal opinion, the live set that he did at Knebworth, which contained many of the same songs, was done better than the cd. Once I saw that Sipping Soma - Superconcious was on their, I instantly skipped right to that track. (I LOVED this track in his knebworth set) but it turned out that it didn't sound nearly as good to me as it did at knebworth. Ok I know I'm just picking on one song, but I have reasons to say it's not the best trance set ever no matter how small the complaints are. Rapture didn't sound as good to me as it did in the live set. And, in my opinion, many of the songs were good, but not really any favorites of my own. Hehe maybe I'm just picky about my trance music, but hey, what sounds real good to you may not be so hot for me.

Posted by keke on Jan-04-2002 00:38:

YES !! PVD DID IT AGAIN !!! THIS ALBUM is SO GOOD

Posted by dbl on Jan-11-2002 09:52:

i love it..

i got it on the Internet first, but then i bought it caus it was sooo good...

PvD is just amazing

Posted by Hell_Copter on Jan-11-2002 17:38:

since no one has given a tracklist yet...
so here it is:

cd 1
1. Ashtrax - Digital Reason
2. Joker Jam - Innocence
3. Private Taste - First
4. Jimpy - Feeling good
5. Paul Van Dyk - Vega, Filmpalast, I Want
6. Southern Comforter - Another Late Thursday
7. Iio - Rapture
8. Sipping Soma - Superconcious (So Alive)
9. Timo Maas - Killin' Me
10. Maji Na Damu - B.W.Y
11. U2 - Elevation
12. Paul Van Dyk - Autumn
13. Viframa - Cristalle
14. Solicitous - Furthermost
15. Subsky - Four Days
16. Second Sun - Empire
17. Paul Van Dyk - Out There

cd2
1. Sagitaire - Shout' C'mon
2. Mirco De Govia - Epic Monolith
3. Ralphie B - Massive
4. David Forbes - Questions Must Be Asked
5. Way Out West - Activity
6. Connector - Interference
7. Blank & Jones - Secrets & Lies
8. Lexicon 4 - Reach Me
9. Jamnesia - Reset
10. 4 Strings - Into The Night
11. Active X - Let's Go
12. Signum - In Progress
13. Walter & Gelder - Section O
14. Solid Sleep - Club Attack
15. Guardians Of The Earth - Starchildren
16. Nu NRG - Dreamland

hope this helps

Posted by elena on Jan-15-2002 05:19:

this is an evil cd....it ownnnnnnnnnssssss
hah once again pvd outdoes himself --->

Posted by Arcticboy on Jan-22-2002 04:02:

Can't believe it's been out for this long and I've only got it a week ago. CD1 is OK, but CD2 is one amazing mix. Clearly one of the top 5 mixes ever, right up there with Tranceport and Magik 6. Amazing track selection, awesome mixing.

Posted by Te Ka on Jan-24-2002 17:53:

quote:
Originally posted by Hell_Copter
since no one has given a tracklist yet...
so here it is:

cd 1
1. Ashtrax - Digital Reason
2. Joker Jam - Innocence
3. Private Taste - First
4. Jimpy - Feeling good
5. Paul Van Dyk - Vega, Filmpalast, I Want
6. Southern Comforter - Another Late Thursday
7. Iio - Rapture
8. Sipping Soma - Superconcious (So Alive)
9. Timo Maas - Killin' Me
10. Maji Na Damu - B.W.Y
11. U2 - Elevation
12. Paul Van Dyk - Autumn
13. Viframa - Cristalle
14. Solicitous - Furthermost
15. Subsky - Four Days
16. Second Sun - Empire
17. Paul Van Dyk - Out There

cd2
1. Sagitaire - Shout' C'mon
2. Mirco De Govia - Epic Monolith
3. Ralphie B - Massive
4. David Forbes - Questions Must Be Asked
5. Way Out West - Activity
6. Connector - Interference
7. Blank & Jones - Secrets & Lies
8. Lexicon 4 - Reach Me
9. Jamnesia - Reset
10. 4 Strings - Into The Night
11. Active X - Let's Go
12. Signum - In Progress
13. Walter & Gelder - Section O
14. Solid Sleep - Club Attack
15. Guardians Of The Earth - Starchildren
16. Nu NRG - Dreamland

hope this helps

I beleive the last song one disk one is Columbia ep?!

Posted by Te Ka on Jan-24-2002 17:54:

Posted by Freeza on Jan-28-2002 00:38:

I just bought it yesterday (i know im late) and i think that it's excellent.

Posted by Miss Proximus on Jan-28-2002 10:19:

quote:
Originally posted by Te Ka

I beleive the last song on disk one is Columbia ep?!

it's FROM the Columbia ep, but it is indeed called Out There

Posted by Hell_Copter on Jan-28-2002 14:37:

since u don't wanna take my word for it

Posted by xzit on Feb-07-2002 04:37:

Re: PVD - Politics Of Dancing

quote:
Originally posted by Mattyk
Well this has got to be.... absolutly the BEST Mix CD I have heard yet... EVER... both CD's are UNBELIEVEABLE.... OMG... I am in AWE... PVD has always been my favorite DJ... ever since the early days... and this CD comp is just FABULOUS! I can't even explain how fabulous it is... at least to me.... what is everyone else's thoughts on it?

-MattyK

I agree! PvD's great... I love both Politics of Dancing cds

Posted by inatrance on Feb-08-2002 01:18:

I am making a follow up about what I think about this cd.. CD 1.. is mm not so good, CD2 rocks!! I really like what PVD is upto.. overall good times

Posted by Vinylgroovah on Feb-12-2002 03:09:

CD 2 IS OBVIOUSLY A BETTER CD. BUT I THINK BOTH ARE AWESOME. THIS IS DEFINETLY THE BEST MIXTAPE CD TO EVER HIT THE FACE OF THE EARTH SINCE THE DAY MUSIC WAS BORN~ =X
I THINK CONNECTOR - INTERFERENCE (TRACK #6, CD2) IS THE BOMB DIGGITY~!

P L U R

Posted by .montecarlo. on Mar-08-2002 02:02:

hmmm, i thought cd1 was awsome! but i dont really like cd2.

definetly an album worth buying tho...

Posted by WaxDog on Mar-15-2002 02:12:

Less Talk

D/L CD2 lets all listen

Posted by infinity HiGH on Mar-18-2002 01:12:

I personally like CD1 better than CD2...by a small margin. Although both CD's are quite good. Can'd wait for another compiliation by PvD...hopefully he won't make us wait *too* long...

Posted by Mark on Mar-18-2002 01:32:

both CD's are good stuff. this double cd set definitely ranks right up there with magik 6, tranceport and trance nation 1.

Posted by infinity HiGH on Mar-18-2002 07:37:

quote:
Originally posted by M.A.R.K
both CD's are good stuff. this double cd set definitely ranks right up there with magik 6, tranceport and trance nation 1.

Who is Trance Nation mixed by? Ferry Corsten?

My top 3 favourite compiliations/albums at the moment are Politics, Hybrid's Wider Angle and the cd that started my interest in electronic music, Loveparade 2000 It will forever be one of my fav's, not just cause it got me into the genre, but of so many memories that come with it...me and my friend listened to it non-stop during the summer...I think I still remember the lyrics to Mr. X & Mr. Y - Back To Berlin...ahhhhh, memories Best summer of my life.

Pages (4): « 1 2 [3] 4 »