TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Political Discussion / Debate
-- US should mind their own business
Pages (7): « 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 7 »
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Shakka And who created and essentially bankrolls the UN? In all honesty, I'm surprised you even had the gall to go there. I think Yoepus made his point rather well (Certainly better than I would've ) |
Anyways, here's my two penneth (not two cents worth! bloody Americans should mind their own God damn business forcing their culture and silly sayings on the civilised world!!)
There are many examples of when people have wanted America to intervine (well, not neccissarily America but the international community) like in Bosnia. If the US intervines on behalf of the UN (like in the Balkans or Somalia) then fine. When else should they intervine? When their security (or others) is jepardised I will give. But the problem here is that you get wars like Iraq where they claimed it was for security (but it blatently isn't) and then when everyone realised it had fuck all to do with security, it was about spreading democracy! If that is their aim (and it is an official neo-con policy to spread democracy) then they are quite capable of funding oppositions (when it is established that the opposition speak for the masses and they do want democracy - not some Pinochet wannabe) like in Afghanistan. If a conflict has broken out then America - with or without the UN's say so - and any other nation should get involved to keep the peace. There are only two actors in the world capable of taking on high level military operations - NATO and America, so you can see why people complain when America does not get involved (the EU is currently developing a capability in order to carry out high level military operations) This is also why I object to criticism at the UN for not doing enough to prevent attrocities - cos the UN has no military. Only NATO and America have the planning, control and command structures to take on high level ops so when they dont wanna get involved, there's not much the UN can do (if its a complex situation, obviously minor conflicts can be done by one country, such as operations carried out by the French or British).
But unfortunately, America is not concerned about humanitarian missions (even under Clinton they made it clear the Balkan conflicts were European problems to be sorted out by the EU). There is no way America will get dragged down in UN missions when it needs its troops where they are. America does not have the resources to fight another Iraq-type war for years - but obviously the current administration require that option so resources are gonna be directed at Iraq-style wars, and UN missions would divert resources away from that aim (this is why I think it is crucial the EU pulls its finger out of its arse and fully implements the Helsinki Headline Goals ASAP cos the EU's military raisin d'etre IS to carry out humanitarian missions)
So should the US mind its own business? Yes and no! If, one day with a new regime in charge America does feel the need to carry out humanitarian tasks then of course it should do everything in its powers to help. But under the current ideology then obviously it should "mind its own business" - but we all know that aint gonna happen!
US policy is centred around economic objectives. This is why there is tension with all and sundry in the Middle East right now and also explains the tension over Korea and Taiwan (S Korea and Taiwan both "allies" which means they are worth a bob or two to the Americans!) But I cant for the life of me see any conflicts over N Korea or Taiwan (not involving America anyway) so I guess the US will continue not minding its own business in the Middle East (altho no invasions for several years!)
| quote: |
| Originally posted by zig I suggest you do some research before you make your assertion about the US bankrolling the UN. http://www.globalpolicy.org/finance...get/large05.htm http://www.globalpolicy.org/finance...re/un-us-05.htm |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by George Smiley Yea I was gonna say summat too! Congress (who control the US economy) refuse to pay anything to the UN. In fact the US owes the UN billions of $!! |
A short list of questions for our American world helpers......
1. Which is the only country in the world to have dropped bombs on over twenty countries since 1945?
2. Which is the only country to have to have used nuclear weapons to take the lives of thousands of civilians?
3. Which country was responsible for a car bomb which killed 80 civilians in Beirut in 1985, making it the most lethal terrorist bombing in the middle east?
4. Which countrys illegal bombing of Libya in 1986 was described by the UN Legal Committee as a classic case of "terrorism".
5. Which country rejected the order of the International Court of Justice to terminate "its unlawful use of force" against Nicuragua in 1986, and then vetoed a UN security council resolution calling on all states to observe international law.
6. Which country was accused by a UN sponsered truth commission of providing "direct" and indirect support for acts of genocide in Guatamala in the 1980s.
7. Which country unilaterally withdrew from the anti ballistic missile treaty in 2001.
8 Which country renounced the efforts to negotiate a verification process for the biological weapons convention and brought an international conference to a halt in 2001.
9. Which country prevented the UN from curbing the gun trade at an arms conference in 2001.
10. Which country apart from Somalia has refused to ratify the UN convention on the rights of the child (For military reasons i might add). You could also ask another question here....which is the only western country to allow the death penalty to apply to chrildren.
11. Which is the only G7 country to not sign the 1997 mine ban treaty, forbidding the use of landmines.
12. Which is the only G7 country to have voted against the creation of the International Criminal Court in 1998.
13. Which was the only other country to join with Israel in opposing in 1987 a General Assembly resolution condemning international terrorism.
14. And lastly which country refuses to fully pay its debts to the UN but reserves the right to veto United Nation Resolutions.
hhhmmmmmm......quite a list.....i could add much more.....
| quote: |
| Originally posted by zig A short list of questions for our American world helpers...... 1. Which is the only country in the world to have dropped bombs on over twenty countries since 1945? 2. Which is the only country to have to have used nuclear weapons to take the lives of thousands of civilians? 3. Which country was responsible for a car bomb which killed 80 civilians in Beirut in 1985, making it the most lethal terrorist bombing in the middle east? 4. Which countrys illegal bombing of Libya in 1986 was described by the UN Legal Committee as a classic case of "terrorism". 5. Which country rejected the order of the International Court of Justice to terminate "its unlawful use of force" against Nicuragua in 1986, and then vetoed a UN security council resolution calling on all states to observe international law. 6. Which country was accused by a UN sponsered truth commission of providing "direct" and indirect support for acts of genocide in Guatamala in the 1980s. 7. Which country unilaterally withdrew from the anti ballistic missile treaty in 2001. 8 Which country renounced the efforts to negotiate a verification process for the biological weapons convention and brought an international conference to a halt in 2001. 9. Which country prevented the UN from curbing the gun trade at an arms conference in 2001. 10. Which country apart from Somalia has refused to ratify the UN convention on the rights of the child (For military reasons i might add). You could also ask another question here....which is the only western country to allow the death penalty to apply to chrildren. 11. Which is the only G7 country to not sign the 1997 mine ban treaty, forbidding the use of landmines. 12. Which is the only G7 country to have voted against the creation of the International Criminal Court in 1998. 13. Which was the only other country to join with Israel in opposing in 1987 a General Assembly resolution condemning international terrorism. 14. And lastly which country refuses to fully pay its debts to the UN but reserves the right to veto United Nation Resolutions. hhhmmmmmm......quite a list.....i could add much more..... |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by zig I suggest you do some research before you make your assertion about the US bankrolling the UN. http://www.globalpolicy.org/finance...get/large05.htm http://www.globalpolicy.org/finance...re/un-us-05.htm |
| quote: |
| America's $1.7 Billion Debt to the UN Dateline: 10/31/99 From Where the UN Stands According to the United Nations, the United States owes them $1.7 billion in unpaid dues and must pay $550 million of that amount by the end of 1999 or lose its vote in the UN General Assembly. The U.S. is far from the only debtor UN nation. Secretary-General Kofi Annan has told the U.N. budget committee that without $2.15 billion in total unpaid dues by member states, "We cannot rationally manage the United Nations." Secretary-General Annan points out that the United Nations had allotted $900 million for peacekeeping in 1999, but it had to reduce that amount to $650 million due to the shortfall in back dues. From Where the US Congress Stands There are currently three bills before the US Congress addressing the UN debt, each in very different ways: 1. Pay them (some of it) 2. Don't pay them (any of it) 3. Get the US of the UN altogether [Online Poll] ...more Don't Pay Them (Any of It) H.R. 346, To prohibit the payment to the United Nations of any contributions by the United States until United States overpayments to such body have been properly credited or reimbursed., sponsored by Rep. Roscoe G. Bartlett (R. MD), proposes that the US debt claimed by the UN is erroneous due to unreimbursed expenses of $4.7 billion for peacekeeping services incurred by the United States during the years 1992 - 1995. |
| quote: |
| ...The United States is the largest contributor to the United Nations but also its largest debtor, owing about $1.7bn, according to UN figures. However, Washington puts the amount at closer to $1bn. ... |
| quote: |
| The United States paid more than $11 billion for international peacekeeping efforts between 1992 and 1997. |
| quote: |
| True, Congress has withheld some money from the UN: some members believe we are being overcharged, and others want to force UN reform. But it's also true that the administration has been diverting additional billions of dollars to assist the UN without asking it to credit them against our "dues." |
Your origional statement was that the US bankrolls the UN.....
Hardly likely, if you havent paid a penny in 2005.....and owe hundreds of millions........
I will research it further tomorrow......but i do remember a certain memeber of your congress or senate who blocked payments for years...year after year......
| quote: |
| Originally posted by zig A short list of questions for our American world helpers...... Which country list blah blah blah..... hhhmmmmmm......quite a list.....i could add much more..... |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by zig A short list of questions for our American world helpers...... 1. Which is the only country in the world to have dropped bombs on over twenty countries since 1945? 2. Which is the only country to have to have used nuclear weapons to take the lives of thousands of civilians? 3. Which country was responsible for a car bomb which killed 80 civilians in Beirut in 1985, making it the most lethal terrorist bombing in the middle east? 4. Which countrys illegal bombing of Libya in 1986 was described by the UN Legal Committee as a classic case of "terrorism". 5. Which country rejected the order of the International Court of Justice to terminate "its unlawful use of force" against Nicuragua in 1986, and then vetoed a UN security council resolution calling on all states to observe international law. 6. Which country was accused by a UN sponsered truth commission of providing "direct" and indirect support for acts of genocide in Guatamala in the 1980s. 7. Which country unilaterally withdrew from the anti ballistic missile treaty in 2001. 8 Which country renounced the efforts to negotiate a verification process for the biological weapons convention and brought an international conference to a halt in 2001. 9. Which country prevented the UN from curbing the gun trade at an arms conference in 2001. 10. Which country apart from Somalia has refused to ratify the UN convention on the rights of the child (For military reasons i might add). You could also ask another question here....which is the only western country to allow the death penalty to apply to chrildren. 11. Which is the only G7 country to not sign the 1997 mine ban treaty, forbidding the use of landmines. 12. Which is the only G7 country to have voted against the creation of the International Criminal Court in 1998. 13. Which was the only other country to join with Israel in opposing in 1987 a General Assembly resolution condemning international terrorism. 14. And lastly which country refuses to fully pay its debts to the UN but reserves the right to veto United Nation Resolutions. hhhmmmmmm......quite a list.....i could add much more..... |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by zig HUGE pieces of land? What the fuck are you on? Before they were colonized/massacred/conquered they had ALL of the land. The european colonizer had no fucking business being here in the first place. So I don't really see what you're point is. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by zig A short list of questions for our American world helpers...... 1. Which is the only country in the world to have dropped bombs on over twenty countries since 1945? 2. Which is the only country to have to have used nuclear weapons to take the lives of thousands of civilians? 3. Which country was responsible for a car bomb which killed 80 civilians in Beirut in 1985, making it the most lethal terrorist bombing in the middle east? 4. Which countrys illegal bombing of Libya in 1986 was described by the UN Legal Committee as a classic case of "terrorism". 5. Which country rejected the order of the International Court of Justice to terminate "its unlawful use of force" against Nicuragua in 1986, and then vetoed a UN security council resolution calling on all states to observe international law. 6. Which country was accused by a UN sponsered truth commission of providing "direct" and indirect support for acts of genocide in Guatamala in the 1980s. 7. Which country unilaterally withdrew from the anti ballistic missile treaty in 2001. 8 Which country renounced the efforts to negotiate a verification process for the biological weapons convention and brought an international conference to a halt in 2001. 9. Which country prevented the UN from curbing the gun trade at an arms conference in 2001. 10. Which country apart from Somalia has refused to ratify the UN convention on the rights of the child (For military reasons i might add). You could also ask another question here....which is the only western country to allow the death penalty to apply to chrildren. 11. Which is the only G7 country to not sign the 1997 mine ban treaty, forbidding the use of landmines. 12. Which is the only G7 country to have voted against the creation of the International Criminal Court in 1998. 13. Which was the only other country to join with Israel in opposing in 1987 a General Assembly resolution condemning international terrorism. 14. And lastly which country refuses to fully pay its debts to the UN but reserves the right to veto United Nation Resolutions. hhhmmmmmm......quite a list.....i could add much more..... |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Fir3start3r The european colonizer had no fucking business being here? What?? Good greif. What a convenient and selective history we have. Yes, HUGE pieces of land. Do a google and check it out yourself. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Fir3start3r I've said it before and I'll say it again; it was the era of exploration and colonization. To put a finer point on it; there was nothing wrong with doing what needed to be done at that point in time. Wealth was driven by LAND and the annexing of new lands. THAT was my point of answering the driveling question regarding the Native Americans (god knows why they even entered the equation). |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Fir3start3r Native Americans (god knows why they even entered the equation).[/B] |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by zig A short list of questions for our American world helpers...... 1. Which is the only country in the world to have dropped bombs on over twenty countries since 1945? 2. Which is the only country to have to have used nuclear weapons to take the lives of thousands of civilians? 3. Which country was responsible for a car bomb which killed 80 civilians in Beirut in 1985, making it the most lethal terrorist bombing in the middle east? 4. Which countrys illegal bombing of Libya in 1986 was described by the UN Legal Committee as a classic case of "terrorism". 5. Which country rejected the order of the International Court of Justice to terminate "its unlawful use of force" against Nicuragua in 1986, and then vetoed a UN security council resolution calling on all states to observe international law. 6. Which country was accused by a UN sponsered truth commission of providing "direct" and indirect support for acts of genocide in Guatamala in the 1980s. 7. Which country unilaterally withdrew from the anti ballistic missile treaty in 2001. 8 Which country renounced the efforts to negotiate a verification process for the biological weapons convention and brought an international conference to a halt in 2001. 9. Which country prevented the UN from curbing the gun trade at an arms conference in 2001. 10. Which country apart from Somalia has refused to ratify the UN convention on the rights of the child (For military reasons i might add). You could also ask another question here....which is the only western country to allow the death penalty to apply to chrildren. 11. Which is the only G7 country to not sign the 1997 mine ban treaty, forbidding the use of landmines. 12. Which is the only G7 country to have voted against the creation of the International Criminal Court in 1998. 13. Which was the only other country to join with Israel in opposing in 1987 a General Assembly resolution condemning international terrorism. 14. And lastly which country refuses to fully pay its debts to the UN but reserves the right to veto United Nation Resolutions. hhhmmmmmm......quite a list.....i could add much more..... |
ADD some more because some those i have never heard about before so keep on going to see if u can surprise me some more
| quote: |
| Originally posted by shaolin_Z You obviously don't understand what the guy who started this thread had in mind. The very conception of this nation began with massacre, bloodshed and opression. And not much has really changed since then when you look at US foreighn policy. |
| quote: |
You don't get it do you. "HUGE pieces of land"? Every inch of this soil belongs to the natives it was stolen from. |
| quote: |
That doesn't justify shit and it was COMPLETELY WRONG. You're a pretty sick individual if you think there's nothing wrong with genocide, oppresion and stealing other peoples resources and land. EDIT: Are you really that naive/biased? |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Fir3start3r Ever heard of a 'reserve'? They house Native Americans who wanted to secede themselves from the rest of the world. There are lots, especially here in Canada. |
@Yoepus: Ok, now I understand what your list is supposed to say. I definately do not agree with all being examples of the people crying out for help and getting it - benevolent style. But leaving that aside, I think that you managed to give me my concrete example (the Balkans).
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Yoepus Lets not get into "the people" definition problem, as debating definitions is never fun. For sake of argument I'm saying "the people" are either a majority or a large influential population of the country and/or the government repersenting (or not repersenting) said people. Obviously there are always dissenters and its never "all the people". ... I don't want to make this a who is the peoples/what is a democracy/legit government etc debate, because that would be endless... as above lets just stick to a broad definition. I don't think it disuades the point. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Shakka In all honesty, I'm surprised you even had the gall to go there. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by shaolin_Z That doesn't justify shit and it was COMPLETELY WRONG. You're a pretty sick individual if you think there's nothing wrong with genocide, oppresion and stealing other peoples resources and land. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by trancaholic I don't accept political correctness as a valid argument. Sorry if that offends you. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by zig 5. Which country rejected the order of the International Court of Justice to terminate "its unlawful use of force" against Nicuragua in 1986, and then vetoed a UN security council resolution calling on all states to observe international law. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by metalgearsolid Yeah well here in the US the reserves really suck and they need to make casinos in order to make $$ |
| quote: |
Can states tax Indian gaming? States cannot tax Indian gambling. The federal law specifically prohibits states from imposing taxes or fees on Indian gambling, except for fees that the tribe agrees to. These fees are intended to compensate the state for its costs in performing inspections and other regulation under the tribal-state compact. In other words, states cannot raise general revenue by taxing Indian gambling. States do have the right to negotiate agreements with tribes under which the tribe makes payments to the state in return for the state's agreement to maintain a tribal monopoly on casino gambling. Under such an agreement Connecticut tribes paid the state over $280 million in fiscal 1999 from its slot machine revenue from two casinos. Income earned by employees at Indian casinos, as well as casino winnings, are taxable if the employee or winner is a non-Indian, but the casino does not withhold state taxes on either winnings or wages. Income earned at an Indian casino by reservation residents is nontaxable by the state. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by trancaholic @Yoepus: Ok, now I understand what your list is supposed to say. I definately do not agree with all being examples of the people crying out for help and getting it - benevolent style. But leaving that aside, I think that you managed to give me my concrete example (the Balkans). |


| quote: |
This debate is either very important or totally irrelevant, depending on what exactly it is that you US-patriots are complaining about when you say that "they want to be able to dictate the terms of the aid they receive. i.e. make the U.S. their personal bitch until they get what they want, then stab the U.S. in the back when all is done and remind the world how much they hated the U.S. in the first place" |
| quote: |
A) Whatever we do *some people* are going to complain, or B) There's people who will ask for help and those *same people*, once helped out, will complain about the US for helping them? |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Fir3start3r Was it wrong? It depends on which end of the time scale we're looking at it from. |
American food is shit with the exception of Cajun/Creole food...and even that is French and African!!
Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.