TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Producers Promotion
-- Remix Compitition #3
Pages (10): « 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 »

quote:

Originally posted by oDrori I might finish my remix in time, but I don't want it to be rushed, so I might have tot take my name off the list in the last moments...

That's ok... If you don't have it finished in time there's no reason to submit it.

MadThijs, you're in.

im in!!!

I think there's still one thing we should decide on...

Are judges gonna be judging the mixes, or are we gonna let everybody download and vote? Personally I think judges will work best, but I'm not in the compo so I'll let the participants decide.

Here's why I don't like the idea of letting everybody vote... Who is gonna download 20 mixes, compare them and decide which one is best? It takes a lot of time... you must really be devoted to the compo to go through all this...

I'm afraid we will receive very little votes... or ppl will download only 5 mixes and pick the best one of that five, without listening to the other mixes...

Tell me what you guys think...

quote:

Originally posted by eieregooie I think there's still one thing we should decide on... Are judges gonna be judging the mixes, or are we gonna let everybody download and vote? Personally I think judges will work best, but I'm not in the compo so I'll let the participants decide. Here's why I don't like the idea of letting everybody vote... Who is gonna download 20 mixes, compare them and decide which one is best? It takes a lot of time... you must really be devoted to the compo to go through all this... I'm afraid we will receive very little votes... or ppl will download only 5 mixes and pick the best one of that five, without listening to the other mixes... Tell me what you guys think...

I agree

That's a good point

Which is why I think we should be a bit more devoted to this as well... How about each producer is going to create a sample of his mix to go along with the mix itself? so we can hear and vote as well, not only the participants but other TAs as well... then, depending on how much judges there are, we will dicede how decisive the vote results are goping to be and then mix them along with each judges' decisions to see who wins it... Kinda complicated but I do think TAs' choices should have affect in this comp.

I'd like to enter as well.

im in, if your mix is radio edit length is that ok?

quote:

Originally posted by dj dave b im in, if your mix is radio edit length is that ok?

Na, i think all remixes should be full length.

Im in Also

gonna make it nasteeeeey!!!

I agree mixes should be full length. So dave b, can I count you in?

so far i have 3:50, still can't decide on a good enough synth for the lead, but hopefully i can, then extend it from there

quote:

Originally posted by dj dave b so far i have 3:50, still can't decide on a good enough synth for the lead, but hopefully i can, then extend it from there

Well, I'd better count you in then

Re: That's a good point

quote:

Originally posted by oDrori Which is why I think we should be a bit more devoted to this as well... How about each producer is going to create a sample of his mix to go along with the mix itself? so we can hear and vote as well, not only the participants but other TAs as well... then, depending on how much judges there are, we will dicede how decisive the vote results are goping to be and then mix them along with each judges' decisions to see who wins it... Kinda complicated but I do think TAs' choices should have affect in this comp.

Nice idea... but will samples be good enough to judge a mix?

so much for the anonymousness then...

quote:

Originally posted by Luke Terry so much for the anonymousness then...

that's better dave

Of course there will be annonymousness... Everyone's gonna send their stuff to that guy in charge (Sorry can't rememvber nick) and he will up it to a main server and re-name and re-lable the mixes to numbers...

Regarding the judging issue, I don't think you can pick a select few people and have them vote on which track is the best. It's obvious that each person has his/her own preferences and I doubt you could pick 5 judges that will like the same song. I think everyone should get a chance to vote, you could perhaps take this one step further and have it be in the TA news section just like the normal singles are voted for, anybody that downloads would rate each track. And ofcourse people will vote for the one they like the most which should be all across the board (depending on the quality of the individual mixes ofcourse )

quote:

Originally posted by DC- Regarding the judging issue, I don't think you can pick a select few people and have them vote on which track is the best. It's obvious that each person has his/her own preferences and I doubt you could pick 5 judges that will like the same song. I think everyone should get a chance to vote, you could perhaps take this one step further and have it be in the TA news section just like the normal singles are voted for, anybody that downloads would rate each track. And ofcourse people will vote for the one they like the most which should be all across the board (depending on the quality of the individual mixes ofcourse )

Errr, no.

How many people would actually download ALL of the tracks and compare them? not one! It is only fair for judges to grade a track once he has heard all competitors.

we should've put a limit on the amount of people who could enter...

quote:

Originally posted by Robert we should've put a limit on the amount of people who could enter...

We can still do that... How about 20?

Grtz...

how many people are in so far?

quote:

Originally posted by eieregooie I just made a list of all the contestants... 01 robstar 02 Haak 03 Veldrid 04 DJ Chrono 05 oDrori 06 Peter Campbell 07 Trancevision 08 Lightworks 09 delphini blue 10 mantisnl 11 Project T 12 Mehari 13 big dave 14 TranceMasterUK 15 MadThijs 16 Robert 17 DaveC 18 DC- 19 xfer 20 dj dave b

Looks like 20 to me

!!!!!

I am having serious problems with opening my remix through Fruityloops... I don't believe I can make any good with it by the time I'm through with it so I will withdraw and give my spot to someone else... Anyone asking should get it.

I will be glad to be one of the judges, if no one minds, I will gladley DL each and everyone of the mixes.

sounds good, judges are needed.

Ok, looks like we're gonna judge then... Most ppl seem to agree...

Contestants:
01 robstar
02 Haak
03 Veldrid
04 DJ Chrono
05 Theotrope
06 Peter Campbell
07 Trancevision
08 Lightworks
09 delphini blue
10 mantisnl
11 Project T
12 Mehari
13 big dave
14 TranceMasterUK
15 MadThijs
16 Robert
17 DaveC
18 DC-
19 xfer
20 dj dave b

Judges:
01 oDrori
02 McBigMac
03 attacc
04 Vacant!!!
05 Vacant!!!

How many judges should we have? I'm thinking 5... In case we have problems finding enough judges I'm willing to judge too... But only if absolutely necessary...

So ppl...
Judges WANTED!!!

Grtz...

[EDIT] Theotrope sent me a pm... So he can take oDrori's place... [/EDIT]

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.