TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- ATB is a thief!!!!!!!!!!
Pages (5): « 1 2 3 [4] 5 »
No, that's true, same with Timo Maas wanting to kick atb's ass in 2000...timo said he said that but says he changed his mind.
Re: ATB is a thief!!!!!!!!!!
| quote: |
| Originally posted by torontotrance Someone pointed out and I will confirm the following Atb's Remember is a ripoff, blatant josh winkesque stealing (yes wink is a dirty thief) but this is beyond a ripoff. Remember steals the riff from Scorchio, such an amazing tune that scorchio was but ATB should be shot for this. I wonder if Sasha's lawyers ever found out about this. It is too blatantly a ripoff.....please atb....get your own ideas. first you ruined your not alone and now this..sighs |
i'm kinda wondering how old u are torontotrance.
this situation feels kind of familiar. i remember:
teacher: i'm thinking of a number between 1 and 10 children.
Joe: 1!
teacher: no
Fred: 2!
teacher: nope!
Tom: 3!
teacher: you win!
Tom: I win I win! u all suck! You're all a bunch of idiots! I win! I win! What do i win teacher?
teacher: attention
o rite, this was the 2nd grade.
Does anyone listen to ATB anymore? Or does anyone that listens to Sasha listen to ATB anymore?
check my profile
Re: Re: ATB is a thief!!!!!!!!!!
| quote: |
| Originally posted by InfiniteSquare heh atb's remake of you're not alone is quite possibly the best real trance track i've ever heard BTW, ATB OWNS DJ HYPER so there |
I am a fan of Sasha (and digweed) as he was the first DJ i had ever seen live aobut 5 years ago in LA. Then i picked up a game called WipeoutXL and it had like 6 tracks made by him. Xpander, wow. His latest album is pretty awesome too. However, i do enjoy ATB as well. He's evolved past the "boing" sounds (haha). His music isn't #1 of course, but he does have a lot of talent in mixing. check out some of his mixes.
I have to agree stealing/sampling without permission is wrong
but you have to realize that not every producer listens to every single track out there
maybe it's a coincidence
It happens all the time.........I really don't think it's a bit deal either
Re: Re: Re: ATB is a thief!!!!!!!!!!
| quote: |
| Originally posted by dreamland ATB's remake of You're not alone is a travesty and not only does it ruin a great track, its more evidence that ATB has no originality of his own that he has to "remake" or "create new tracks - which are actually rip offs of others" Oh and also Hyper is 20x better than ATB. So much more talent! Geez, some people |
| quote: |
| no originality of his own that he has to "remake" or "create new tracks - which are actually rip offs |
ffs people...this was not tta diss up atb's mixing or production
this was simply that atb stole scorchio's guitar riff and put it in remember or at least it sounds like it. So do you think that I am right or wrong?
start the atb flame threads elsewhere (wait a minute, I normally start those...nevermind)
Re: Re: ATB is a thief!!!!!!!!!!
| quote: |
Originally posted by LiQuiD_FuSioN  |
you are just mad that I was right.
So if were to use the exact same riffs of 'scorchio' in my own production and call it mine, no one would care? cool! 
I just don't think anyone ever noticed probably because not many bought the CD period. If I was Sasha, I'd be mad as hell but all the ATB lovers want ATB to respond and I'd love to hear his reply to this one.
try posting on ATB's forum. He'll probably read there.
someone did
and the atb lovers were unhappy about it saying it was ok to do it and that atb would not respond....
http://forum.atb-music.com/showflat...sb=5&o=&fpart=1
may be you should post the samples
samples are posted in page 1...same ones as the ones that I put up.
or maybe he took them out.
edit...they are in there somewhere...lol..i remember
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Floorfiller i don't just see why if he wants to use the melody he doesn't just do: Sasha & Emerson - Scorchio (ATB Mix)?? why does he have to rename it? |
this is hilarious 
http://forum.atb-music.com/showflat...rt=1#Post295417
particularly:
| quote: |
| PvD is a baby compared to ATB! ATB is 1000 times better than that lil sissy! |
| quote: |
| Paul Van DYK is more cheese than any trance artist out there |
| quote: |
| go back to your sissy dyk website forum and say how much u dore that sissy who produces music (if u can call that music he makes) and i would shut the F*ck about movin melodies, that album is one of the best albums of all time you sissy dyk groupie! |
Production wise, ATB has really shown an evolution to shy away from his first "boing" songs. Through levels of talent, he would've exited "subpar" and started entering "average." I do enjoy some of the newer stuff, but i must admit that it's rather disappointing to see ATB using other's material, which may or may not be creditted (in the inside sleeve or something). It doesn't even matter if it's credited, because i feel he doesn't need to (yes T-trance, i'll use this word to describe it) STEAL other's work to promote himself. I'm still going to get the new album because of personal preference. It relaxes me.
as for PVD, he is a wonderful live act, and WAS a great producer. Seven Ways and Out There and Back contain some of the most beautiful songs i've ever heard, any genre, ever. ATB isn't too shabby of a DJ, of course, nothing compared to PVD. However, i felt the last ATB album i bought had more bang to the buck than PVD. It just seemed a lot more diverse than the PVD material, with something for everyone. Of course, i still like PVD, but there is a difference between "PVDs music is too complicated for you epic trancers" and "man, i'm bored."
but yes, i must admit that that tune was STOLEN.
but like i said earlier in previous posts, there is a plethora of big name artists using other peoples works (remixes) than creating completely original music.
shame on ATB 
since when was this pvd vs. atb?
this was yes or no...the work is stolen
Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.