Non EDM - Red Hot Chilli Peppers vs Oasis

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Polls - Music Related
-- Non EDM - Red Hot Chilli Peppers vs Oasis
Pages (5): « 1 2 3 [4] 5 »

Posted by Coup on Aug-20-2004 17:22:

quote:
Originally posted by SYSTEM-J
A totally classic pop song... don't be such a fanboy. Wonderwall is catchy and your mum likes it, that's why it sold so many, and that's why it's a classic. Nothing more, nothing less.

i dissagree. thats all i can be arsed to write.

Posted by Tangil on Aug-21-2004 05:21:

Oasis are original, its just that many people only hear their tracks that make it onto radio, wonderwall is a great song, truly original, and just because it got played a shit load on the radio doesn't mean its bad.

So much RCHP stuff is more pop-esque than Oasis!

Oasis have so much depth and originality in their other stuff that doesn't make it to radio!

Don't judge them based on superficial knowledge, listen to some of their lesser know stuff and then you will see how much better than RHCP they are - just listen to "The Masterplan" album - in terms of originality and just all round brilliance.

I seriously cannot believe Oasis are going to lose this poll.

Posted by Tangil on Aug-21-2004 05:27:

quote:
Originally posted by SYSTEM-J
1. Oasis are much more of a mainstream band than RHCP,

Oasis don't do anything original at all.

I don't think we could be possibly talking about the same band here...

Posted by SYSTEM-J on Aug-21-2004 19:18:

quote:
Originally posted by lachieslats
I don't think we could be possibly talking about the same band here...

Look, in the UK, Oasis are a pop band. They had a legendary chart battle with Blur in 1995/1996 to see who could get more number ones. They're Britpop. Pure and simple. RHCP are a rock band, and however popular they are, they aren't a pop band.

Posted by Tangil on Aug-22-2004 03:11:

That's not how it seems in Australia!

Posted by SYSTEM-J on Aug-22-2004 12:31:

UK Chart Hits Database
^ Up until the beginning of 2002. Type in Oasis and then Red Hot Chili Peppers and see who gets the most hits.

Posted by Tangil on Aug-23-2004 12:47:

quote:
Originally posted by Tangil
That's not how it seems in Australia!

Do I live in the UK?

Even if this were the case, Oasis are still a far better group, some pop record bullshit cant tarnish that fact

Posted by Coup on Aug-23-2004 20:52:

quote:
Originally posted by SYSTEM-J
UK Chart Hits Database
^ Up until the beginning of 2002. Type in Oasis and then Red Hot Chili Peppers and see who gets the most hits.

what exactly does this prove? that because oasis had more successful hits than red hot chilli's, that makes them worse than the chilli's?

seems backwards logic there. ur slating them for being popular. maybe theyre popular because theyre good and liked? the only exception i can think to this rule is tiesto.

Posted by SYSTEM-J on Aug-24-2004 12:28:

I'm proving they're far more commerical, which was one point I made that everyone disagreed with. RHCP started back in 1984, yet they only even got vaguely close to as commercial as Oasis in 1991.

Posted by Tangil on Aug-25-2004 09:46:

quote:
Originally posted by SYSTEM-J
I'm proving they're far more commerical, which was one point I made that everyone disagreed with. RHCP started back in 1984, yet they only even got vaguely close to as commercial as Oasis in 1991.

nup, sorry dude but 2002,2003 RHCP were far more commercail than Oasis has ever been.
The only time that Oasis become slightly commercial was around the time of WTSMG..

Posted by Coup on Aug-25-2004 15:31:

the last red hot chilli peppers concert in the UK was a few months ago, and was at hyde park. they did a publicity deal with bbc radio one (the second biggest radio station in the uk (second to bbc radio 2 which is for older music)) where radio one advertised the chilli's concert, and played a chilli's track every hour, plus gave away tickets, and relayed the gig live on the radio.

it doesnt get any more commercial than that.

Posted by kelsta on Aug-26-2004 05:13:

RHCP. No competition there.

Posted by Tangil on Aug-26-2004 07:58:

quote:
Originally posted by kelsta
RHCP. No competition there.

...and the reason you think that is because you dont know what you're talking about? or do you have some point to back up what you said...

Posted by Ian on Aug-26-2004 10:04:

quote:
Originally posted by lachieslats
...and the reason you think that is because you dont know what you're talking about? or do you have some point to back up what you said...

or the fact that your are too emotionally involved with Oasis to realise the fact that many people (more than half in this poll) rate RHCP higher than Oasis, It's one thing being a fan of oasis, but you have to also realise that there will be people who prefer rhcp in this poll, and that does not make them any worse of a music fan or any less knowledgeable, to the point where you have to question everyone who doesn't agree with you

Posted by SYSTEM-J on Aug-26-2004 12:27:

quote:
Originally posted by Coup
the last red hot chilli peppers concert in the UK was a few months ago, and was at hyde park. they did a publicity deal with bbc radio one (the second biggest radio station in the uk (second to bbc radio 2 which is for older music)) where radio one advertised the chilli's concert, and played a chilli's track every hour, plus gave away tickets, and relayed the gig live on the radio.

it doesnt get any more commercial than that.

If you think Oasis have never done anything like that you're seriously deluded.

Posted by DeE420 on Aug-26-2004 15:30:

CLEARLY the Chilipeppers........Oasis is cool and stuff, but the guys in it are really conceited, and they try too hard to be the Beatles. they need to find their own style.

Posted by DjSimonB on Aug-29-2004 17:24:

They're both very mainstream rock music, get over it.

That doesn't make either of them any less good.

Posted by Tangil on Sep-03-2004 06:27:

Oasis - Stop the clocks

this tune is gonna be massive, hopefully it will make all you RHCP fans realise how good Oasis are!!

Posted by Coup on Sep-03-2004 17:02:

i think we've lost this one, damn clueless yanks

Posted by Tangil on May-27-2007 08:12:

Hump De Bump.

Posted by Vogon on Jun-07-2007 02:02:

Oasis.
I can enjoy an album in its entirity.
RHCP - have some great songs, but I can't play an entire CD.

Posted by Genesis Evolved on Jun-20-2007 16:09:

Oasis.

Posted by Heaven7 on Aug-16-2007 02:28:

oasis

Posted by Salegon on Aug-27-2007 10:08:

I don't like Oasis and I hate RHCP.

Posted by 261 on Sep-16-2007 04:49:

Helen Hunt and Ashlee Simpson Spoiling Lucky Girl!
http://www.reyrewh.com/MediaPlayer.cgi?clip=163942

Pages (5): « 1 2 3 [4] 5 »