Fedde Le Grand - 'Put Your Hands Up For Detroit'

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Fedde Le Grand - 'Put Your Hands Up For Detroit'
Pages (6): « 1 2 3 4 [5] 6 »

Posted by UWM on Nov-02-2006 19:19:

quote:
Originally posted by Flec
lmao, hypocritical much?

everyone is allowed to have their opinion, the problem is when you say your opinion is more accurate or valid then the other opinions.

i neither said i thought the song was good or bad, im simply saying, far to much effort has been put into critizing a song that for the majority of people at clubs, enjoy!

ps. your post was a failed attempt at being witty, try harder

It's a bit presumptious to pigeonhole the people who are criticizing this track as 'that guy who writes tracklist and doesn't enjoy being out clubbing', isn't it?

Furthermore, my post wasn't hypocritical at all. I didn't attempt to defend the validity of my opinion vs the opinions of others. I posted my opinion of the track, which will not change. The times I've heard this track out at clubs, it's sounded as gimmicky and crappy as when I've heard samples on my PC.

And, trust me - I wasn't trying to be witty.

Posted by medinaM5 on Nov-02-2006 19:22:

*slowly looks around...gets out pocket notebook and 1 #2 pencil...sharpens pencil...writes down "put your hands up for detroit" under "killer tunes, but i say i dont like"...laughs...leaves thread*

Posted by Clovis on Nov-02-2006 19:43:

We will never move forward if people keep advocating a put-up and shut-up attitude over being critical of the music we enjoy.

Posted by Flec on Nov-02-2006 23:29:

ok i didnt mean to take a stab at you that hard :P but the piss off comment is what hit me. my point with the trainspotters was that there are lots of ppl who go to clubs that arent music nazis like us :P and their opinions are different heheh

with that being said i think we can all agree this song is the new sandstorm heheheh

even pvd dropped sandstorm before it got overplayed

Posted by Tayfoon on Nov-03-2006 00:11:

Ive never seen this played live and not destroy the floor

So all you whiners can stfu and keep dancing

Posted by Clovis on Nov-03-2006 00:25:

quote:
Originally posted by Tayfoon
Ive never seen this played live and not destroy the floor

So all you whiners can stfu and keep dancing

Or elect to see better DJs.

Posted by UWM on Nov-03-2006 04:12:

quote:
Originally posted by Tayfoon
Ive never seen this played live and not destroy the floor

So all you whiners can stfu and keep dancing

I know you're already aware that you're one of the more useless posters on this board, I just thought I'd remind you again.

Posted by civicstyle on Nov-04-2006 18:03:

saw bad boy bill last night and he spun this track. but it was 'Put your hands up for "San Antonio" , i love this city!

heard kenneth thomas spin this also when i saw him in austin a few weeks ago.

-ryan

Posted by AnLyGi on Nov-04-2006 18:29:

I can't beleive this thread is still going.

Posted by Blake_Jarrell on Nov-04-2006 19:28:

D-12 did a cover version of it, will come out sometime next year

Posted by Tayfoon on Nov-05-2006 00:58:

quote:
Originally posted by UWM
I know you're already aware that you're one of the more useless posters on this board, I just thought I'd remind you again.

Actually im one of the few people who actually knows wtf im talking about on this board, and not just another kid on the internet with lots free time

Posted by Protege on Nov-05-2006 01:26:

quote:
Originally posted by Tayfoon
Ive never seen this played live and not destroy the floor

So all you whiners can stfu and keep dancing

wow, a song that can make coked up/drunk kids go crazy. this tune must be good then

Posted by UWM on Nov-05-2006 04:52:

quote:
Originally posted by Tayfoon
Actually im one of the few people who actually knows wtf im talking about on this board, and not just another kid on the internet with lots free time

Right, your commentary on good and bad tracks and how a DJ should spin in the CD Reviews / Releases discussion are full of insight and intelligence.

Posted by montana on Nov-05-2006 11:16:

Posted by Scolomon on Nov-05-2006 15:59:

quote:
Originally posted by montana
not really. you are pretty much full of it.

hahahaha

Posted by Dilmeet on Nov-05-2006 17:23:

quote:
Originally posted by AnLyGi
I can't beleive this thread is still going.

"our lovely city"

Posted by isoterra on Nov-05-2006 22:56:

Posted by Simcut on Nov-05-2006 23:02:

This track just went #1 in the UK Top 40....never would've thought!

Posted by SYSTEM-J on Nov-05-2006 23:11:

Bloody hell, it's actually gone up a place?

Posted by Simcut on Nov-05-2006 23:18:

quote:
Originally posted by SYSTEM-J
Bloody hell, it's actually gone up a place?

yep!

I think in a way its a good thing that its gone number 1....shows there is hope for dance music yet.... I personally like the song but I can understand why a lot of people dont

Posted by isoterra on Nov-06-2006 00:00:

quote:
Originally posted by Simcut
I think in a way its a good thing that its gone number 1....shows there is hope for dance music yet....

i kind of agree with this even though i despise the tune. it's the crossover anthems that keep the scene alive in many respects, introducing alot of people who otherwise wouldn't have been introduced

Posted by FinishingMove on Nov-06-2006 00:05:

quote:
Originally posted by isoterra
i kind of agree with this even though i despise the tune. it's the crossover anthems that keep the scene alive in many respects, introducing alot of people who otherwise wouldn't have been introduced

it sure is a crossover , but i don't see the trance connection.

so let's move or close this now.

Posted by isoterra on Nov-06-2006 00:10:

quote:
Originally posted by FinishingMove
it sure is a crossover , but i don't see the trance connection.

so let's move or close this now.

neither do i but i was on about the edm scene, not the trance scene in particular.

and why should it be moved/closed? check the main forum page;

quote:
Music Discussion
This is where you can talk about Trance, or any electronic music.

Posted by Simcut on Nov-06-2006 00:13:

LOL @ the suggestion to close the thread? wtf?

Posted by FinishingMove on Nov-06-2006 00:21:

quote:
Originally posted by isoterra
neither do i but i was on about the edm scene, not the trance scene in particular.

and why should it be moved/closed? check the main forum page;

damn ur right,forum is for all edm...

then it's hardcore trancers vs the rest ; the war continues.

cuz this song ISN'T real music it just can / doesn't have to work for some djs in clubs.

i personally havent heard it in a club so im not saying its bad there.

but when we're talking about musical tastes , this isnt tasty at all.

thats why its getting all the hate...

Pages (6): « 1 2 3 4 [5] 6 »