TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Album Reviews / New Releases Discussion
-- Robert Nickson - Spiral
Pages (8): « 1 2 3 4 5 [6] 7 8 »

Posted by InfiniteSquare on Dec-24-2003 03:18:

jealousy seems to be lonliness (in #ukta)
lonlinees seems to be a shortage of mp3s
how could you guess when your only thinking about yourselves

WHAT THE FUCK?

i really do feel bad for you guys...it must SUCK!

Posted by torontotrance on Dec-24-2003 03:25:

nah...tho i don't know what the others were thinking...they were told as well. I mean this is supposed to be cd reviews...not flame war 101. Keep it clean people...it's the holidays...be happy.

Posted by StalkerElmo on Dec-24-2003 03:52:

quote:
Originally posted by State of Matter
Hmmm. Threw the robert nickson - spiral melody and the darren tate vs jono grant - nocturnal creatures melody on a pad. Compare:

http://www.angelfire.lycos.com/elec...tter/spiral.mp3
http://www.angelfire.lycos.com/elec...l_creatures.mp3

Im not casting stones, just making observations. Robert's a talented producer, it mighta just been a coincidence.

The other synth melody sounds almost exactly the same too, as does the synth sound.


it's true, they do sound awfully similar in synths wise..

however melodies are completely different and there's where it really counts.. or am i wrong?

Posted by capricorn15 on Dec-24-2003 04:02:

quote:
Originally posted by RJOllos
You must have no soul ... or your brain is incapable of positive emotion due to too much drug use. Those are the only reasonable explanations.


quote:
Originally posted by kypez
That guys an idiot.. Spiral is probly one of the most emotional tracks out there.


you guys are both fucktards. its called an opinion. just because someone from TA made it doesnt mean everyone is going to like it. i myself have never heard it so i cannot comment on it, nor do i think that because someone from TA made that it is given a higher rating. everyone has their own taste, so why dont you respect other people's opinions.

btw, im sure it is good, because i think rob nickson is a good producer, not because he is from TA.

Posted by raditz on Dec-24-2003 04:20:

quote:
Originally posted by State of Matter
Hmmm. Threw the robert nickson - spiral melody and the darren tate vs jono grant - nocturnal creatures melody on a pad. Compare:

http://www.angelfire.lycos.com/elec...tter/spiral.mp3
http://www.angelfire.lycos.com/elec...l_creatures.mp3

Im not casting stones, just making observations. Robert's a talented producer, it mighta just been a coincidence.

The other synth melody sounds almost exactly the same too, as does the synth sound.


hrm, you're right, just on a different key. Not a big deal anyway as you pointed out.

Posted by capricorn15 on Dec-24-2003 04:30:

quote:
Originally posted by RJOllos
Yeah and its called a joke. Possibly you are just a little bit slow ? Damnit now i'm off topic.

yea, i dont know, some people just respond like that, put a happy face like this or something so others know you are joking. and dont call me slow.

Posted by State of Matter on Dec-24-2003 05:09:

quote:
Originally posted by StalkerElmo
it's true, they do sound awfully similar in synths wise..

however melodies are completely different and there's where it really counts.. or am i wrong?


Haha, of course they sound similar synth wise, its a synth i put the melody on. Its the melodies that sound the same. The Spiral melody is the Nocturnal Creatures Melody pitched down a halfstep and with a couple of notes shorten. But all of the note structure is exactly the same.

Not a big deal, its just the two songs sound like one should be a remix of the other.

Posted by Tiger on Dec-24-2003 09:06:

Nothing really special about this track to be honest, it's average at best. the main melody is nice and kinda reminds me Misja's remix of Recitation, but thats it.

The Kallokain remix on the other hand is a beauty, and probably rob's best work to date (for my taste anyway).

Posted by Switch on Dec-24-2003 11:04:

Arguing on the internet is like running in the special olympics, even if you win you are still retarded.


(edited after complaint of Ian )

Posted by Ian on Dec-24-2003 11:46:

quote:
Originally posted by Switch
Arguing on the internet is like running in the special olympics, even if you win you are still retarted.


Retarded

Posted by m0sh on Dec-24-2003 12:00:

quote:
Originally posted by InfiniteSquare
Thanks! I know I am..

And you are jealous!


OK....

quote:
Originally posted by Mr.Mystery
Yes, it's completely natural to be jealous to some mp3 whore lamer...




quote:
Originally posted by arctic
LOL

Whenever someone criticizes you, it's probably not the best idea to say 'omgz you're jealous!'.

Yes, that's right, we're all jealous of a lamer who is clearly incapable of thinking for himself, can't spell, and likes to impress others by making comments like 'UTE OWWWWNNNNZZZZZZZZ' 'CDR PROMOOOO EXCLUSIVVVEEEZZZZZZZ'.

That's right, we're all jealous of you. You keep on thinking that, as they say, ignorance is bliss.


ignorance is bliss indeed



quote:
Originally posted by kypez
That guys an idiot.. Spiral is probly one of the most emotional tracks out there.


I don't like this track so im an idiot ?



======================================================================

ANYWAY InfiniteSquare , go do somthing better l33t mp3 boy

Posted by skip on Dec-24-2003 13:58:

very boring trance IMO! this is the kind of stuff i don't like at all! this track says nothing to me, nothing! it's weird IMO that people love this kind of stuff, but that just goes to show how opinions differ i guess! 2/10
i've never actually liked any robert nickson tracks for some reason, they just don't appeal to me at all!

Posted by noikeee on Dec-24-2003 15:56:

quote:
Originally posted by kypez
That guys an idiot.. Spiral is probly one of the most emotional tracks out there.


actually after reading this i decided to give it another chance and it hit me it's all bout the strings

Posted by InfiniteSquare on Dec-24-2003 18:42:

poor moshman has his shit in a knot

Posted by m0sh on Dec-24-2003 19:35:

quote:
Originally posted by InfiniteSquare
poor moshman has his shit in a knot



sure prefect super model boy

Posted by VaNFeCto on Dec-24-2003 19:50:

I know Im S U P E R late but Im just now hearing this track and its great, doesnt get the C Montgomery Burns Excellent but nevertheless a great tune, love Robert Nickson.

Posted by StalkerElmo on Dec-24-2003 23:59:

quote:
Originally posted by VaNFeCto
I know Im S U P E R late but Im just now hearing this track and its great, doesnt get the C Montgomery Burns Excellent but nevertheless a great tune, love Robert Nickson.


considering the vinyl hasnt been released yet.. your not that late..

Posted by Robert on Dec-25-2003 00:29:

quote:
Originally posted by VaNFeCto
I know Im S U P E R late but Im just now hearing this track and its great, doesnt get the C Montgomery Burns Excellent but nevertheless a great tune, love Robert Nickson.


dammit, i've always wanted the C Montgomery Burns Award for Excellent Excellency..

d'oh!

Posted by T_2199 on Dec-25-2003 00:45:

guys pls keep your stupid flamewar private cuz we (most ppl on ta) don�t care when childrens are arguing.. pls stick to topic here..

Posted by TOR on Dec-25-2003 15:05:

quote:
Originally posted by paranoik0
actually after reading this i decided to give it another chance and it hit me it's all bout the strings


it's all about the strings indeed..

i do feel he could have done more with the melody, could have made it longer and even more uplifting.

in any case, it is a massive track and it will definitely set any dancefloor on fire!

Posted by RJOllos on Dec-27-2003 07:31:

quote:
Originally posted by State of Matter
Haha, of course they sound similar synth wise, its a synth i put the melody on. Its the melodies that sound the same. The Spiral melody is the Nocturnal Creatures Melody pitched down a halfstep and with a couple of notes shorten. But all of the note structure is exactly the same.

Not a big deal, its just the two songs sound like one should be a remix of the other.


I knew this sounded familiar when i first heard it. Still a great soundign track though, and overall the track is more uplifitng than nocturnal creatures. I have really liked both tracks.

Posted by capricorn15 on Dec-28-2003 07:18:

this song is good. but as good as all you guys are saying,
although i like the breakdown a lot =)
good job mr nickson =), i look forward to hearing you develop more as a producer =)

Posted by Simcut on Dec-29-2003 02:03:

quote:
Originally posted by T_2199
guys pls keep your stupid flamewar private cuz we (most ppl on ta) don�t care when childrens are arguing.. pls stick to topic here..


well said!

Posted by Joca on Dec-29-2003 06:45:

quote:
Originally posted by T_2199
guys pls keep your stupid flamewar private cuz we (most ppl on ta) don�t care when childrens are arguing.. pls stick to topic here..


I'm calling you out on this hypocrit. As I remember quite cleary, you Mosh and trancEyes22 kept on flaming eachother for the first 5 pages or so in this thread
http://www.tranceaddict.com/forums/...40&pagenumber=1

Posted by refuge on Jan-26-2004 21:13:

An O.K. track... 7.5/10


Pages (8): « 1 2 3 4 5 [6] 7 8 »

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.