TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Minimal is a FAD
Pages (8): « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 [8]

quote:

Originally posted by basd Even better: why would you be caring about what the fucking clown behind the decks is doing as long as the music is good?

Becauz CDJs require so much skilllLllLl!1

quote:

Originally posted by Clovis Becauz CDJs require so much skilllLllLl!1

Ah yes. How could I forget?

quote:

Originally posted by MoBreakz i have examples of Gui Borrato's minimal tracks, which goes against everything youve said in this thread. anyhow im over it.

1. Single case comparisons are hardly end-all, be-all descriptions. Essentially what you're saying is that because you can come up with one instance where a producer has produced a tune that is sort of close to minimal (or any genre), you can label them a a minimal producer. You can't. Intellectual loopholes are for idiots who aren't smart enough to make sound arguments.

2. You're obviously not "over it." The amount of time you've spent in this thread trying (and failing) to make yourself look even the slightest bit intelligent is a clear indication of that.

quote:

Originally posted by RJT 1. Single case comparisons are hardly end-all, be-all descriptions. Essentially what you're saying is that because you can come up with one instance where a producer has produced a tune that is sort of close to minimal (or any genre), you can label them a a minimal producer. You can't. Intellectual loopholes are for idiots who aren't smart enough to make sound arguments. 2. You're obviously not "over it." The amount of time you've spent in this thread trying (and failing) to make yourself look even the slightest bit intelligent is a clear indication of that.

When I was Referring to the minimal music I do like I said "I like some Gui Borrato". For a minute squeeze your brain hard and ask yourself In that context does it mean Gui Borrato is a solely a Minimal artist or that I like the Minimal flavor tracks he does make. Stop making up shit.

use this as reference : Originally posted by MoBreakz
Some Minimal is good earphone music though, cant totally diss it, but those tracks are far and few between. I like some Gui Borrato, Trentemoller, Gabriel Ananda, Minilogue, Audiofly, Extrawelt, Paul Kalkbrenner, Ame, Loco Dice and Radioslave stuff though.

Why dont you stop bumping this thread...it ended long time ago.

i like the strokes.

quote:

Originally posted by MoBreakz use this as reference : Originally posted by MoBreakz Some Minimal is good earphone music though, cant totally diss it, but those tracks are far and few between. I like some Gui Borrato, Trentemoller, Gabriel Ananda, Minilogue, Audiofly, Extrawelt, Paul Kalkbrenner, Ame, Loco Dice and Radioslave stuff though.

yeah, that's what everyone's using as a reference for saying you're wrong. They don't make minimal. Hell, most of those don't even have tracks in the minimal section on Beatport, which is inaccurate enough as is.

delete it.

minimal is a fad, trance is dead, get a fucking life.

there should be a c span for trance. t-span...

nationally, you all could go on podiums in a big room and debate about trance genres on television. it would be somewhat entertaining

quote:

Originally posted by MoBreakz Yah because Beatport DNA tests each track into the right Category? ::listens to Gui Boratto - The Rising Evil:: ^Minimal Techno. And your talkin out of ur ass. Go to Beatport. Type in Gui Boratto and about 35 of his tracks will come up. Tell me you dont find a single track labled as Minimal by him. If you dont, dig deeper. Why do morons keep bumping this thread lol.

minimal techno != minimal

quote:

Originally posted by inconspicuous minimal techno != minimal

IMO minimal = monolake, steve reich, alex smoke and richie hawtin.

quote:

Originally posted by AndreaCKY772 there should be a c span for trance. t-span... nationally, you all could go on podiums in a big room and debate about trance genres on television. it would be somewhat entertaining

trance genres??

Ok this thread is leading nowhere and was biased from the beginning.

Minimal is not a fad because it is not a genre.

Minimalism is a concept, which has been applied to painting, sculpture, music, architecture, interior design, etc.

For example, you can make minimal trance or minimal architecture, though you cannot make trance architecture. Trance, is a musical genre, not a concept.

Now what is it that you dont understand ?

quote:

Originally posted by julien2 Ok this thread is leading nowhere and was biased from the beginning. Minimal is not a fad because it is not a genre. Minimalism is a concept, which has been applied to painting, sculpture, music, architecture, interior design, etc. For example, you can make minimal trance or minimal architecture, though you cannot make trance architecture. Trance, is a musical genre, not a concept. Now what is it that you dont understand ?

actually trance is not a genre of music but a style of electronic dance music in which in itself is a genre : like

Genres
- -
Rock / Electronic Dance Music (edm)
STYLES / STYLES
- -
Indie, Metal,Punk.. / Trance, Techno, House , Tribal..
SUB STYLES SUB STYLES
- -
Indie pop, glam rock, heavy metal ... / Hard Trance, DnB,
/ Electro House...



UNDERSTOOD?

You are right. I oversimplified on this one.

quote:

Originally posted by julien2 you cannot make trance architecture.

Seems pretty trippy to me.

quote:

Originally posted by wotyzoid trance genres??

i mean edm in general... but there are different types of trance. i won't unravel that thread thugh...

quote:

Originally posted by AndreaCKY772 i mean edm in general... but there are different types of trance. i won't unravel that thread thugh...

i wasnt picking on you, i was just confused about what you said.

I KNOW MINIMAL AND ITS THE SHIT, IF YOU THINK ITS A FAD YOU CAN GO TO HELL.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.