Suburban Urban? - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Suburban Urban?

Posted by tubularbills on Apr-29-2003 20:06:

Suburban Urban?

Ok, so i'm a little confused.

On DJ Tiesto's album, "In My Memory" it lists the track as "SUBURBAN TRAIN" . then i've seen it on other compilation albums that call it "URBAN TRAIN". and i've even seen people reference the original one from INM as "URBAN TRAIN". which one is it?! how many mixes are of this track anyway? Its such a great track!

Posted by Nell on Apr-29-2003 20:09:

i have 15 versions on cd

there is no logic to the mix names i.e. suburban dosent always have vocals, all the releases i have contradict each other!

Posted by GrimReaper on Apr-29-2003 20:17:

Yes, there are some confusions but usually "Urban" has vocals and "Suburban" doesn't. The original promo version was called Urban Train even if it's now known as Suburban Train. Strange isn't it?

Posted by Goldenleon on Apr-29-2003 20:20:

iv also wondered this myself howver i alway thought that urban had the Vocals and Suburban didnt

however iv seen urban train on some compilations and it hasnt had vocals.

but all i know is its an amazing tune.

Posted by AndskiSpeed on Apr-29-2003 20:25:

yea I was always confused by this myself, has Tiesto not said anything about this at some point?

Posted by OhioTranceFan on Apr-29-2003 21:03:

I dont know if its a dub or what, but I have a DJ TIesto - Urban Train with no vocals. Even though Urban Train is a ripoff song, i dont think you can deny that its better than the kid vicious song it blatantly steals from (Kid Vicious - Reform). As for the vocals of this song though, Ive never heard them...

Posted by DJPrototypeX on Apr-29-2003 21:34:

i bet the search wouldve come up with a bazillion freakin topics about this, but no one ever listens to guys like Nell with every version of the song...lol...Grim is on the money though

Posted by Rakoon on Apr-29-2003 23:39:

quote:
Originally posted by OhioTranceFan
Even though Urban Train is a ripoff song, i dont think you can deny that its better than the kid vicious song it blatantly steals from (Kid Vicious - Reform).

I wouldnt call it a ripoff since Kid Vicious worked with Tiesto on the track.

Posted by OhioTranceFan on Apr-29-2003 23:48:

quote:

I wouldnt call it a ripoff since Kid Vicious worked with Tiesto on the track.

well, whether or not he worked with him on the track, you cant deny that those two songs sound incredibly alike.....that kinda makes it a ripoff to me

Posted by dj tek on Apr-29-2003 23:48:

Marc O' Tool's remix of "Urban" Train dub ROX !

Posted by Halcyon21 on Apr-30-2003 04:05:

all i kno is that i like suburban train better than urban train even tho the bassline in suburban train sounds a whole lot like the bassline in tiestos mix of silence

Posted by dj tek on Apr-30-2003 04:15:

quote:
Originally posted by Halcyon21
even tho the bassline in suburban train sounds a whole lot like the bassline in tiestos mix of silence

if u mix in suburban train into tiesto's mix of silence it goes perfect.. sounds like one long tiesto track as if silence never ended and evolved into suburban train..both great closers.. silence is a perfect closer.. long epic feel atmosphere with beautiful vocals and awesome climax.. then, suburban train take it one notch higher..the main melody for both tracks are similar and other elements in the tracks has tiesto written all over it ie : bassline

Posted by DJDigDug on Apr-30-2003 04:49:

quote:
Originally posted by Halcyon21
all i kno is that i like suburban train better than urban train even tho the bassline in suburban train sounds a whole lot like the bassline in tiestos mix of silence

hmm who would think an artists work would sound similar :P

Posted by Halcyon21 on Apr-30-2003 04:57:

bleh i just meant it was obviously similar even tho i like both tracks