'As The Rush Comes On' ripped off another tune?

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- 'As The Rush Comes On' ripped off another tune?
Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Posted by j�c� on May-17-2003 04:25:

'As The Rush Comes On' ripped off another tune?

Voyager - Super C

and

Motorcycle - As The Rush Comes On

the melodies are almost identical..

Posted by arturob on May-17-2003 05:07:

ffs.

Posted by j�c� on May-17-2003 05:30:

quote:
Originally posted by Starfox
ffs.

lets try not get offended now

Posted by Slade on May-17-2003 07:11:

looks like G&D have joined the ranks of most trance producers then

Posted by LaCasta on May-17-2003 08:54:

Even if they did use the melody Gabriel and Dresden have made it better

Posted by DJDigDug on May-17-2003 09:30:

OK if you really fucking search hard enuff you can probably find an equal for every fucking song out there omfg why do you fucking people always post shit like this, the song is nice, leave it be, i mean for all you know the melody of both songs could be based on some old classical music composition, things sound similar from time to time, does it give you pleasure to rail on music most people enjoy, I feel gabriel and dresden bring a pretty unique element to progressive trance, and im not even going to bother with listening to that other song if it sounds the same i can give a shit less, i love as the rush comes that is that, i can care less about that shit.
With so many producers songs are going to sound similar, And then they start to dance sounds exactly the same as the prophet, kid vicuous used the bass line he developed for urban train in other material, yadda yadda yadda, it happens.

Posted by LaCasta on May-17-2003 10:54:

quote:
Originally posted by DJDigDug
OK if you really fucking search hard enuff you can probably find an equal for every fucking song out there omfg why do you fucking people always post shit like this, the song is nice, leave it be, i mean for all you know the melody of both songs could be based on some old classical music composition, things sound similar from time to time, does it give you pleasure to rail on music most people enjoy, I feel gabriel and dresden bring a pretty unique element to progressive trance, and im not even going to bother with listening to that other song if it sounds the same i can give a shit less, i love as the rush comes that is that, i can care less about that shit.
With so many producers songs are going to sound similar, And then they start to dance sounds exactly the same as the prophet, kid vicuous used the bass line he developed for urban train in other material, yadda yadda yadda, it happens.

Bravo

Posted by sifntj0r on May-17-2003 11:06:

any other producer/dj and they'd be bashed like a muthafucka...

sigh

Posted by tsunami on May-17-2003 11:12:

Posted by Mr.Mystery on May-17-2003 13:00:

quote:
Originally posted by sifntj0r
any other producer/dj and they'd be bashed like a muthafucka...

sigh

Double standards strike again.

Posted by capricorn15 on May-17-2003 13:07:

do you think it was on purpose?

Posted by allstar on May-17-2003 13:10:

When I produce, I often find I create melodies that are similar to others. Now I don't do this intentionally, but my point is it's not as hard as you might think.

Posted by Mr.Mystery on May-17-2003 13:29:

quote:
Originally posted by S2K
When I produce, I often find I create melodies that are similar to others. Now I don't do this intentionally, but my point is it's not as hard as you might think.

Yes, but it seems like when someone else does a melody similar to some other tune they get hanged from their balls, but if the same thing is done by a band/artist that's "in" at TA it's a cool tribute.

Posted by j_spot on May-17-2003 13:32:

now since I dont have that particular single, they might not have 'ripped them off'
ever think that they may have sampled the song? given credit, saying we used their stuff. It happens alot you know...

just a possibility.

Posted by T_2199 on May-17-2003 13:43:

Paaaanic!!!! ARG !! Gabriel & Dresden was bashed oh nooo let�s all bash the thread starter because he was so rude and said that one song of G&B sounds familiar with another one

Posted by joeh on May-17-2003 14:31:

quote:
Originally posted by T_2199
Paaaanic!!!! ARG !! Gabriel & Dresden was bashed oh nooo let�s all bash the thread starter because he was so rude and said that one song of G&B sounds familiar with another one

Posted by elena on May-17-2003 15:09:

*calmly waiting for davedresden's reponse/reaction*

Posted by cyberia on May-17-2003 15:31:

quote:
Originally posted by sifntj0r
any other producer/dj and they'd be bashed like a muthafucka...

sigh

quote:
Originally posted by T_2199
Paaaanic!!!! ARG !! Gabriel & Dresden was bashed oh nooo let�s all bash the thread starter because he was so rude and said that one song of G&B sounds familiar with another one

my thoughts exactly

Posted by j�c� on May-17-2003 17:53:

Posted by tu_face on May-17-2003 17:57:

i havent listened to the other tune that its supposed to have ripped off but i will say this.. just because an artist does something that is similar to another track, doesnt mean that he/she did it on purpose.. i mean theres the obvious ones like scooter, and there are many others that have done it blatently in the past, but on the other hand theres examples like armin - shamu and push - strange world.. and that was not intentional (mike commented himself on the forums on his website)..

Posted by Cyberwoo on May-17-2003 18:00:

quote:
ffs.

quote:
OK if you really fucking search hard enuff you can probably find an equal for every fucking song out there omfg why do you fucking people always post shit like ths

quote:
I honestly don't understand why "you fucking people" get so offended

quote:
Why don't you just fucking sue me.

As Bart Simpson would say at a time like this....HELL! DAMN! FART! HELL! DAMN! FART!

Posted by starglider on May-17-2003 18:36:

Breaking news:

Two or more producers can independently come up with similar or even identical melodies. This is not uncommon.

Having said that, I do consider it interesting to find songs related in this way. There are better ways to bring one's attention to this, however, than "X ripped off Y!".

Posted by [mart] on May-17-2003 20:36:

Some of you really need to grow up!

Stop reading so much into this coincidence, stop flaming each other, stop fucking swearing every other fucking word bollocks, and CHILL.

So, anyone else noticed the recent surge of Sister Bliss - Sister Sister rip-offs?

Posted by eye_03 on May-17-2003 20:41:

who'da thunk it?

Posted by DaveSZ on May-17-2003 21:14:

quote:
Originally posted by Cyberwoo
As Bart Simpson would say at a time like this....HELL! DAMN! FART! HELL! DAMN! FART!

"Do you know curive???"

"Ya, I know 'hell,' 'damn,' bit..."

Pages (2): [1] 2 »