Iio- Rapture <--What Genre is this??

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Iio- Rapture <--What Genre is this??

Posted by Peter K on Sep-27-2003 02:12:

Iio- Rapture <--What Genre is this??

Why are people on here saying this is trance? its not is it?

Posted by Clyde77 on Sep-27-2003 02:13:

armin remix is trance and i believe the original is house?

Posted by mndeg on Sep-27-2003 02:13:

top40 trance

Posted by joeh on Sep-27-2003 02:18:

quote:
Originally posted by mndeg
top40 trance

original IMO wasnt too trancey.

Posted by joeh on Sep-27-2003 02:18:

How about we as Ishkur?

perhaps its Gabba

rofl

Posted by chjo on Sep-27-2003 05:38:

Why couldn't that be trance??

The original version of Rapture was at PvD Politics of Dancing, and I belive it's a trance album..

Rapture (original) is chilled and a bit ambitient.. but still trance IMO

Posted by Wretched on Sep-27-2003 05:40:

Soulside Remix is chilled

god that's a good song

Posted by starglider on Sep-27-2003 05:45:

quote:
Originally posted by chjo
Why couldn't that be trance??

The original version of Rapture was at PvD Politics of Dancing, and I belive it's a trance album..

Rapture (original) is chilled and a bit ambitient.. but still trance IMO

The original wasn't on POD, it was PvD's rework. The original is sorta commercial housey. It's not very good. Only the Riva/AvB remixes are trance, I'd say.

Posted by _Nut_ on Sep-27-2003 06:25:

Original is considered basic club/top 40. the original is not trance.

Posted by Neuro'99 on Sep-27-2003 13:16:

The 'J Creamer & Stephane K' mix is my favourite version of this song. It is considered under the general header of 'progressive' isnt it?

Posted by starglider on Sep-27-2003 14:14:

quote:
Originally posted by Neuro'99
The 'J Creamer & Stephane K' mix is my favourite version of this song. It is considered under the general header of 'progressive' isnt it?

While the differences between prog house and prog trance are not easily discerned and many tracks drift along the fuzzy border between the two, Creamer's mix qualifies as progressive house. So yeah, you could call it "progressive".

Posted by Neuro'99 on Sep-27-2003 14:58:

quote:
Originally posted by starglider
While the differences between prog house and prog trance are not easily discerned and many tracks drift along the fuzzy border between the two, Creamer's mix qualifies as progressive house. So yeah, you could call it "progressive".

yeah, I was actually tempted to define it as progressive trance but I figured it wud be easier to sit on the fence in case I was "wrong"

either way, to me this is definately in the genre of "good music that I enjoy listening to", as opposed to "music I dont like"

Posted by dreamdecks on Sep-27-2003 15:06:

Re: Iio- Rapture <--What Genre is this??

quote:
Originally posted by teknoking
Iio- Rapture <--What Genre is this??

it comes ounder the 'shit' genre, although the avb remix pisses on most tunes.

Posted by djshan on Sep-27-2003 16:16:

i would say its house/dance. or a dj danny d's favourite.

Posted by King_Mack on Sep-27-2003 17:22:

^^

lol dj danny d. the people's dj!!

Posted by djshan on Sep-27-2003 17:24:

quote:
Originally posted by King_Mack
^^

lol dj danny d. the people's dj!!

hey i like the johnny vicious remix.

Posted by DJ Freestyle on Sep-27-2003 21:01:

Original = Pop
Armin's Remix = Trance

Posted by Swamper on Sep-27-2003 21:06:

Well the Deep Dish Rmx is all that matters - and IMO it was brilliant cuz it transcends multiple genres and appeals to fans of each

*THAT* is something that RARELY ever happens... You had 'Trance' DJs and 'House' DJs caning that thing for all it was worth back in mid 2001.