TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- DJs mix CDs attacked in attempt to control copyright


Posted by matt29 on Nov-16-2003 13:02:

DJs mix CDs attacked in attempt to control copyright

http://www.djmag.com/news_20.asp


Posted by razzi on Nov-16-2003 13:25:

fuck the RIAA


Posted by noikeee on Nov-16-2003 13:27:

:\

sometimes i feel like RIAA, the american government and friends are going to end up shutting down the underground dance scene for once. the problem is that, as an underground community, we are a minority that represent nothing in the society


Posted by udham on Nov-16-2003 13:29:

This is pathetic !!


Posted by Psionic on Nov-16-2003 15:24:

Is that legal?


Posted by k.k.d. on Nov-16-2003 15:41:

Funny, did those mixes contained songs by RIAA artists, or something? Because otherwise, I hardly see how RIAA can justify the legal ceasure of material over which it holds no right whatsoever.


Posted by matty on Nov-16-2003 16:10:

That is such horse shit....why can't they leave people alone, especially those in the EM community


Posted by papadoc on Nov-16-2003 16:16:

quote:
Originally posted by Galapidate
Is that legal?

It doesn't matter to the RIAA.
When did being legal EVER matter to the RIAA?


Posted by ALD52 on Nov-16-2003 17:16:

Grrrrrrrrrrr. Those ******s! Why us...


Posted by starglider on Nov-16-2003 17:26:

I'm not sure why everyone is so angry. The article wasn't talking about proper, licensed CDs; it was referring to homemade CDs that aren't legal to sell anyway. Obviously you're not allowed to record a mix, slap it in a jewel case and send some copies to local stores...


Posted by dartman on Nov-16-2003 17:40:

i thought that if you put "for promotional use only" on it and sold them for just enuff to cover the cost of making the cds that is was ok. almost every local dj in my area sells cds at the dj booth for like $10 a pop.

alot of times thats how i find out about some new music and end up buying the vinyls of the songs that i really like.


Posted by Psionic on Nov-16-2003 18:02:

I think we all should just sue the RIAA.


Posted by Roquer on Nov-16-2003 20:40:

Quote from a friend.



Actually, when I was a working DJ, and these so-called DJ Mix cds received permission to be made by the music labels to make the mixes. They made these mixes strictly for the club, in order to promote the song. I do know of some Remix Services that just make a mix illegally, without label permission, and they have been silently attacked over the past 10 years in the DJ community. If you're a DJ, you know who I'm talking about.

If I'm an artist on, say, Arista, I have basically given up my right to say how my music should or shouldn't be distributed

Actually, that's not the case. In the DJ Remix community, Janet Jackson, Michael Jackson, Madonna, and several other artists have prevented several remixes of their songs to be done by DJ's who create mixes for special promo cds. In the mid-to-late 80's, we had A LOT of Remix Services, like dozens, because artists and their labels were really open to 3rd party remixers, but today, we are down to maybe 3 that actually still make remixes and compilations. And one of them is still technically making remixes without 100% approval from the labels.

The dance scene and clubs do rely on these special remixes to keep people coming back. In fairness to the RIAA, they could be talking about the thousands of self-professed DJ's, who are a dime a dozen, who mix tracks and put them on a cd of their own, and then are selling them for profit in the stores. I've seen this on several occasions.

This is not right. These "DJ's" are ruining the reputation of legitimate producers who make their cds exclusively for club play. Also, the legitimate cds should NOT be put in public access, where anyone can buy them. Every single store I've been to, just anyone can buy a legit Remix Service cd, as long as they have the money. No questions asked.

It used to be when legit remix cds were in not-so-obvious stores, and only DJ's knew where to get them. Not anymore. The remix music is much more public than what it used to be.

But to get back on track, there are several artists who restrict their mixes to their own labels, and forbid ANY outside remixing. I suppose if you're not that well-known, then yes, you probably wouldn't care if some DJ remixed your music for club play. It would be interesting to see just what exactly was pulled from these stores, and who the cds belonged to.


Posted by Occasu on Nov-16-2003 21:21:

quote:
Originally posted by Galapidate
Is that legal?
In the words of the Dark Sith Lord:

"I will make it legal"


Posted by fitom tiel on Nov-16-2003 22:44:

it seems the big country has something against the 'dance' scene


Posted by j_spot on Nov-16-2003 23:12:

if they put a tiesto, onr G&D, or BT track, all of them are under Nettwerk, which is american, and can be part of the suit.

Its all horse shite, adn I wonder which artist is going to suffer before they realize that the system works fine as long as quality music is made. I used to like 'pop' then I stopped because the quality of it went down the tube.

its a sad state


Posted by Clyde77 on Nov-16-2003 23:26:

dont worry guys ;p
there's always a way out to everything.



Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.