TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Chill Out Room
-- Semi-rant
Pages (3): [1] 2 3 »
Semi-rant
Just got into an argument with my parents...I had made a fire in the fireplace and was listening to a lil trance and readin a book. Very pleasant cuz its pouring like hell outside. My dad comes in and the first thing out of his mouth is "Are you listening to TECHNO again?" emphasis with disdain on the techno. I explain that if hes going to generalize it call it electronica.
and he says something that makes me respond "If you think that if this music takes any less talent than other forms of music, you are a fool" and he says that musicians have WAYYY more talent and that these DJs are just "technicians"
SO i respond with a "well...technically all musicians are musical technicians. Instead of using the old technology of wood and string, they use circuit boards and vinyls, just a more recent instrument"
I continue to say that his belief that musicians who play intruments have some indefinable sould or spirit in them that Electronic artsists dont really pisses me off, and that thinking that something made from nature EG wood and gut would have more soul in it than a "cold electronic circuit board" seems pretty fucking pagan and lacking in good sense to me. (pissed him off cuz hes a Christian missionary and i called him a pagan).
It seems to me that people have a problem with electronica because they think it lacks "soul" (whatever the hell that means in a musical conotation I dont know) or emotion. They seem to have this troglodytic (A member of a fabulous or prehistoric race of people that lived in caves, dens, or holes.
A person considered to be reclusive, reactionary, out of date, or brutish.) outlook that new things are bad and cant be as good as the "old days". Sorry, but Gielen aint gonna sound like the Beatles, but they are still gonna pour their talent into a crowd of thousands.
I m pissed right now. I walked out with a parting "Its pretty fucked up to say that one form of music is less valid than another" and walked out...sigh. Dont fuck with my music when im listening to it and enjoying myself. The bastard ruined my afternoon.
Re: Semi-rant
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Orbax The bastard ruined my afternoon. |
i think its funny when people say that Electronica isnt really music because its all machines and anyone can really do it
Then you bring up the electric guitar, which is, in essence, the same thing.
That usually shuts em up
You had a lot of good defenses there. It's not often parents actually understand their kids music, just a fact of life. It sucks though when they sit there and rip on it. It wouldn't surprise me if your dad went through the same thing with his parents.
I hear ya man... I've been in the same kind of argument millions of times.
"Music is feelings and emotions put into sound"
I don't give a shit how the music is made, I just want the music to touch me, and inspire me.
Music has inspired me my whole life in many different forms, Rock, Electronic, Classical, Hip Hop, and much much more...
just listen.
his parents listend to Sinatra and called the Beatles "animal music"
yeah I brought up the guitar asking if it was just as much technicality saying 'first finger, 3rd fret' on a guitar and how I can play the exact same songs that Eric Clapton wrote about his child that died falling from a balcony and smile while he cries. The song itself is something you could punch holes in and feed to a computer...what the hell does he think MP3s are!@!!!!W@#@!#!@ Moron!
Awww poor Orbax! *hugs* Cheer up bub!
I know what you mean though. I can't stand it when people refer to it as "That techno shit", it drives me nuts! I flame whenever I get the chance. I remind them that most of the time those "hot" band and "pop" stars that they listen to have electronic music in the backround, and every type of music essentially comes from a beat, and that "TECHNO" as they like to call it, has one!
FFS! on that crap!
On a better note, I got my roommate to slowly transform into liking trance
Just ignore them. No matter what you say or do they will not change their minds. Why waste time on useless arguing?
i had a chat with my mum about the history of house music, at the pub a few weeks ago... the result.. im going to a northern soul night with her sumtime soon.
my dad likes happy hardcore and hardstyle... so i never had a disagreement with my parents about such an issue, but its annoying as hell when ppl cant see and understand whats being told to them
A quote that's actually from me that's made a lot of my friends stop and think:
To take music and play it like a machine... that's easy. But to take a machine and play it like music... that takes talent.
I played the piano since I was 6, I was a child prodigy. Won all sorts of competitions and stuff. I still have the greatest respect for the DJs and producers - at least, the good ones, those who have a real feel for the music and don't just beat match.
Go to any junior music competition and you'll see hundreds of kids playing soulless, boring music. But a lot of African music, for example, is also built on repetitive rhythms and motifs and the entire "flow" and "direction" of that music is based on how those rhythms change, very gradually. This was drum music, tribal, it was around long before the first wind or string instrument ever came to be. "Techno" is a modern form of the oldest music known to man. Trance and other kinds of electronica are its descendants.
People are stuck up about their music, it seems. They like to think that only their music was TRULY groundbreaking and original. But if they don't understand where music came from, they sure won't understand where it's going...
I get pissed off when people say shit like that i actually want to keel them it makes me soo freakin mad and i cant control myself them ignorant bastards.
Oh and why do people always say like what kind of music you listen to and i say trance and they say whats that and i say its like techno or electronica so they know where im coming from and then they say what are you a fag??????? WTF why do they think people who listen to electronic music are gay i dont understand
great quote digi.
yeah, i wasnt so pissed that he doesnt like my music, i deal with that every day ("Turn that thumping off!") i was pissed because I was having an enjoyable stormy afternoon, reading a book that evoked old memories, just kind of a bittersweet melancholy mood today, and he fucked it all up. Hmph. Im gonna go make some more tea, maybe take a nap. I dont know yet.
If someone listens to some house music (not all) and says it doesn't have any soul, they are just plain ignorant.
ive got into this argument with my friends before, but never my parents, haha, my mom just gets mad if it is too loud. one of my friend said it wasnt real music, and i told her fuck you, and not to say that again, haha
I know what you're talking about, it pisses me off when people say that electronic music isn't 'real music', it makes them seem a bit musically ignorant or stuck-up, thinking their preferred style/genre is in some way better than yours.
i agree that electronic music takes less musical talent with respect to djs. anyone can put two records together. i think that there are different levels of talent for a dj based on how well they put a set together and make their audience feel, but i think that is quite different from musical composition.
when it comes to producing music, i think that electronic music is just as challenging as conventional genres and requires as much talent.
Re: Semi-rant
I guess his argument is that 'other' music is made using instruments made from 'living' things like trees etc.
Of course, it is hard for me to argue his side, seeing that I think that there is no difference in between these forms of music. I guess he is just disappointed that nobody is singing in this music, which -in his oppinion- might be the purest form of espression for oneself. Therefore nobody is putting his 'soul' into the music.
I get his point, but i think he is wrong. It is just the typical way to approach something that is 'unknown' in order to make it seem less valid. Bottom line: He doesn't like it and is making excuses why he doesn't like it.
| quote: |
| Originally posted by butterfly anyone can put two records together. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by drizzt81 no offense, but have you tried? It is not as easy as it seems, at least I have the hardest time doing it! |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by hadi ****** she is comparing it to producing, and as far as djing is compared to producing, djing is 100x easier |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by butterfly i think someone mentioned this earlier, but djing is more of a technical thing. you might be equally good at djing as doing lights (just an example) but that is very different than the music theory required to compose a soulful piece of music. OMG i sound like PP. shoot me. |
walker, your dad sucks
| quote: |
| Originally posted by butterfly i think someone mentioned this earlier, but djing is more of a technical thing. you might be equally good at djing as doing lights (just an example) but that is very different than the music theory required to compose a soulful piece of music. OMG i sound like PP. shoot me. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by DigiNut Well again, this is coming from a musician, composer, producer (not full-time obviously...) Matching beats isn't too hard, but a good DJ does a lot more than that. Especially the true techno DJs like Liebing or Cave - the kind of effects they put into it are incredible, so well-thought-out, and suddenly all those hard mindless beats start forming melodies and harmonies. "Matching" is more than just tempos, it's finding the feel of each track and creating a flow, and using effects to make it sound new and fresh every time. And don't even get me started on the DJs that do their mixing on 3 or even 4 decks (I watched Gaetek mix on 3 turntables and a laptop, FUCK!!!) It takes talent. |
buttefly is a smart girl, i like her, lets kiss
Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.