George Acosta presents The History of Trance 1993 - 2004

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Album Reviews / New Releases Discussion
-- George Acosta presents The History of Trance 1993 - 2004
Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Posted by Dan1584 on May-07-2004 22:44:

George Acosta presents The History of Trance 1993 - 2004

George Acosta presents The History Of Trance 1993 - 2004

CD # 1
-------------
1. Libra presents Taylor � �Anomaly_Calling Your Name�
2. Sasha � �Xpander�
3. Lustral � �Everytime� (Mike Koglin Remix)
4. Three Drives � �Greece 2000�
5. Paul van Dyk � �Another Way� (Club Mix)
6. The Thrillseekers feat. Sheryl Deane � �Synaesthesia (Fly Away)� (Paul van Dyk Remix)
7. Matt Darey feat. Marcella Woods � �Beautiful� (Pulser Remix)
8. Energy 52 � �Caf� Del Mar� (John �00� Flemming Remix)
9. Solar Stone � �Seven Cities� (V-One�s Living Cities Mix)
10. Delerium - �Silence� (DJ Ti�sto�s In Search Of Sunrise Remix)
11. Mauro Picotto � �Lizard�
12. Push � �Universal Nation�

CD # 2
-------------
1. Robert Miles � �Children� (Original Version)
2. Push � �Tranzy State Of Mind� (Club Mix)
3. BBE � �7 Days And One Week� (Ferry Corsten Remix)
4. Art Of Trance � �Madagascar� (Ferry Corsten Remix)
5. System F � �Out Of The Blue� (Original Mix)
6. Paul van Dyk � �For An Angel �98� (PvD E-Werk Club Mix)
7. Sunbeam � �One Minute In Heaven� (Future Breeze Remix)
8. DuMonde � �See The Light� (Original Mix)
9. Cosmic Gate � �Exploration of Space� (Club Mix)
10. Sosa � �The Wave� (Taucher Mix)
11. Trance Allstars � �The First Rebirth� (Taucher Remix)
12. Jon Secada � �Just Another Day� (George Acosta Remix)

***DANIEL'S REVIEW***

Personally I definetly rate DJ's on their ability to make GOOD store bought CD's in addition to rating them based on their live skills. I feel that it is as important for a DJ to pull off a CD mix as much as it is for them to pull off something live. George Acosta took a bold step in attempting to take 24 of the most classic and treasured trance tracks and mix them together in a 2 CD set. What he ended up with was a very uninspiring mix of great songs...

The first CD starts off with a decent start...not the BEST mix of "Anomaly_Calling Your Name", but it does alright, then "Xpander" comes forward and gets the emotion really set, as expected. But then after that everything seems to go WAY down hill. With each transition to the songs afterwords you have no emotional transition, just beats overlapped very nicely and then this long bland and beat heavy non-melodic transitions which kill the emotion and epic-ness of the mix. The transition from "Lustral" to "Greece 2000" is so damn boring that I wanted to kill myself...the mood is completely killed because your waiting for something to happen. After this first CD ended I felt like some of my favorite trance tracks were totally disrespected by being thrown into a totally uninspired and non-epic mix.

Now, I didn't have much hope for my purchase, but I decided to keep my head held high as I popped in the second CD. "Children" starts of the mix very nicely and the transition into "Trazy State of Mind" is perfectly good, nice emotion and transfer of energy. The next transition into "7 Days and One Week" goes over well too. Perhaps Acosta grew a brain? Transition after transition occurs with pretty decent emotional crossfades...at least 100% better than the first CD. This CD KINDA brings some respect back to Acosta for me, but this CD still doesn't "do" what it should have done it if someone truly talented was behind the making of this mix. I do have something good to say...George Acosta's remix of "Just Another Day" was actually a pretty pleasant surprise, except for the fact that is simply just ends outta nowhere.

Overall, this mix looks like a GREAT idea but it's pulled off in purely bad taste. The first CD is totally unispired and he actually found a way to strip these monumental songs of thier epic integrity. The second CD is a bit more pleasing, but nothing amazing to gawk over. Plain adn simply...don't go buy this mix. These tracks are much better listened to on their own. If your looking for a continuous mix of some good classics, go for it, but if you want a mix of classics that actually combine and compliment the epic-ness and beauty of each other then stay clear of this.

4 / 10

Posted by Ste on May-07-2004 23:01:

maybe you havnt realised, but:

a) compilation cd's are not sets ,they ar a colection of tracks to be listened to at home, cd compilations never flow. you are getting it confused with a mix cd.

b) the tracks are classics, what u expect, same reason as above.

c) anyone who judges a dj on the quality of a cd with his name is a bit of a daft twat. compilation cd's are almost always mixed on computer, usualy using tunes that were the cheapest liscence/on the same label as cd.

however i would hardly call a cd full of tracks from 98/99 the "history" of trance

Posted by Dan1584 on May-07-2004 23:13:

quote:
compilation cd's are not sets ,they ar a colection of tracks to be listened to at home, cd compilations never flow. you are getting it confused with a mix cd.

Um last time I check this CD is a MIX CD...gee the tracks are MIXED together...compilations usually mean that it is a CD with tracks on it for collection purposes, like the "Now Thats What I Call Music" comilations...This is as much of a mix CD as anything else out there.

quote:
anyone who judges a dj on the quality of a cd with his name is a bit of a daft twat. compilation cd's are almost always mixed on computer, usualy using tunes that were the cheapest liscence/on the same label as cd.

DJ's have to be intelligent...off stage or on stage. One of the MAJOR parts of being a DJ is FORMATING or PROGRAMMING songs in a good order so that the whole mix sounds like one long song. This CD lacks majorly in the area of GOOD programming. DJ's SHOULD be judged by their CD releases AND their live performances. Just as Rock musicians should be judged on their recorded albums and their live performances...there's no difference.

This mix sux...plain and simple. I'm not saying George Acosta sux, but this mix sux. And btw why call someone names because they have a somewhat intelligent opinion on something...you my friend are a "daft twat"

Posted by Ste on May-07-2004 23:54:

quote:
Originally posted by Dan1584
Just as Rock musicians should be judged on their recorded albums and their live performances...there's no difference.

:

rock people do live performances and make songs, got not one iota to do with mixing sets. this shows you have no idea what you are talkign about.

haha get you, dont try and get all high and mighty. a mix cd is a recorded live mix, never usually released usually just given, like a promotional material, mr. this is a mix compilation, miced by a computer and a bunch of tracks which were easiest to get the liscence for, this is not a set, and this cd does not reflect in any way on the DJ. do you even go out clubbing?

i never said it didnt suck anyway, merely pointing out your misguided interpretations.

Posted by ASOT100 on May-08-2004 00:13:

george needs to stop coming out with compilations for quick cash

Posted by beema on May-08-2004 00:55:

whoever decided that George Acosta of all people should present the history of trance needs to be shot.
Acosta is a disgrace, and his fat retarded ass should in no way represent trance.

Posted by capricorn15 on May-08-2004 01:05:

quote:
Originally posted by Ste

however i would hardly call a cd full of tracks from 98/99 the "history" of trance

exactly, hahah, before i opened the thread, i wasnt expecting the tracklist i saw, he needs to review his "trance history"

Posted by Pio on May-08-2004 02:34:

another cash grab for Acosta. this guy is a joke.

12. Jon Secada � �Just Another Day� (George Acosta Remix)

That is a part of the history of trance?

Posted by 3xx3r7 on May-08-2004 03:42:

Posted by refuge on May-08-2004 04:20:

George -n00bosta.

Posted by flavdave on May-08-2004 04:28:

quote:
Originally posted by beema
whoever decided that George Acosta of all people should present the history of trance needs to be shot.
Acosta is a disgrace, and his fat retarded ass should in no way represent trance.

I'm pretty sure this was something that Ultra Records wanted to do since they seem to put out compilations just about every month it seems. I guess they got Acosta to do it because he is probably their most "high profile" DJ on their roster, obviously they don't have many to begin with.

I don't have the CD so I can't say if this is in fact mixed by Acosta or if it's mixed by computer. I do have Acosta's Touched CD and that is mixed live on turntables according to the liner notes. Someone who has History of Trance 1993-2004 should check the notes to see if it says anything about it being actually mixed by Acosta himself.

Posted by NPursuit on May-10-2004 19:04:

Posted by NPursuit on May-10-2004 19:06:

quote:
Originally posted by refuge.01^
George -n00bosta.

Yeah OK cool kid! I've been listening to Trance for 5 years now. Not everyone has the same taste.

Posted by refuge on May-10-2004 21:39:

quote:
Originally posted by NPursuit
Yeah OK cool kid! I've been listening to Trance for 5 years now. Not everyone has the same taste.

Do you think that makes you cool? I could care less how long you've been listening to it.. for I have been listening to it for equally the same amount of time.

// refuge

Posted by Az on May-10-2004 21:47:

quote:
Originally posted by refuge.01^
Do you think that makes you cool? I could care less how long you've been listening to it.. for I have been listening to it for equally the same amount of time.

// refuge

you're the biggest gimp on this forum
and I'm sure you were the biggest gimp on the forum with your previous alias, whatever it was

back to the CD
can someone tell me which track(s) on there were from 1993? or pre 97

Posted by Sand Leaper on May-10-2004 21:53:

quote:
Originally posted by Az
back to the CD
can someone tell me which track(s) on there were from 1993? or pre 97

The original version of Children came out in 1995. I don't see any from 1993 though.

Posted by UWM on May-10-2004 21:58:

I would maybe put 4 of those on a 2 disc comp outlining the History of Trance from 93 - 04.

MAYBE.

Posted by raditz on May-10-2004 22:55:

You know, should they had picked a different name for the cd it wouldn't have been that bad (well, relatively). Acosta must have little to no respect for the music that he plays to lend his name for a cd like this. In order to make such a compilation you'd need a lot more than just these 2 cds, and that's only if you included the most commercial tunes without necessarily having the milestones of the trance era.

Anyway, I searched discogs for the years these were relased, just for the hell of it, and this is what I got:

CD # 1
-------------
1. Libra presents Taylor � �Anomaly_Calling Your Name� (1995)
2. Sasha � �Xpander� (1999)
3. Lustral � �Everytime� (Mike Koglin Remix) (1999)
4. Three Drives � �Greece 2000� (1998)
5. Paul van Dyk � �Another Way� (Club Mix) (1999)
6. The Thrillseekers feat. Sheryl Deane � �Synaesthesia (Fly Away)� (Paul van Dyk Remix) (2000)
7. Matt Darey feat. Marcella Woods � �Beautiful� (Pulser Remix) (2002)
8. Energy 52 � �Caf� Del Mar� (John �00� Flemming Remix) (2002)
9. Solar Stone � �Seven Cities� (V-One�s Living Cities Mix) (1999)
10. Delerium - �Silence� (DJ Ti�sto�s In Search Of Sunrise Remix) (2000)
11. Mauro Picotto � �Lizard� (1999)
12. Push � �Universal Nation� (1998)

CD # 2
-------------
1. Robert Miles � �Children� (Original Version) (1995)
2. Push � �Tranzy State Of Mind� (Club Mix) (2000)
3. BBE � �7 Days And One Week� (Ferry Corsten Remix) (2003)
4. Art Of Trance � �Madagascar� (Ferry Corsten Remix) (1999)
5. System F � �Out Of The Blue� (Original Mix) (1999)
6. Paul van Dyk � �For An Angel �98� (PvD E-Werk Club Mix) (1998)
7. Sunbeam � �One Minute In Heaven� (Future Breeze Remix) (2001)
8. DuMonde � �See The Light� (Original Mix) (1999)
9. Cosmic Gate � �Exploration of Space� (Club Mix) (2000)
10. Sosa � �The Wave� (Taucher Mix) (1997)
11. Trance Allstars � �The First Rebirth� (Taucher Remix) (1999)
12. Jon Secada � �Just Another Day� (George Acosta Remix) (????)

Now I also wonder where the hell he got 1993 from, amazing piece of crap...

Posted by NPursuit on May-10-2004 23:26:

quote:
Originally posted by refuge.01^
Do you think that makes you cool? I could care less how long you've been listening to it.. for I have been listening to it for equally the same amount of time.

// refuge

The point is people in this thread were discussing GA's new CD. The only thing you had to contribute was some punk ass remark. If you don't like GA than don't listen to him and don't post in threads discussing him. Not all of us like the same DJs but only the people that feel the need to act like a cool kid talk shit. It's taste in music there is no right or wrong, or "noob" music like you call it. There is only what you like and don't like.

Posted by NPursuit on May-10-2004 23:29:

quote:
Originally posted by raditz
You know, should they had picked a different name for the cd it wouldn't have been that bad (well, relatively). Acosta must have little to no respect for the music that he plays to lend his name for a cd like this. In order to make such a compilation you'd need a lot more than just these 2 cds, and that's only if you included the most commercial tunes without necessarily having the milestones of the trance era.

I was thinking it took some pretty big balls to name a CD that. It is a pretty decent CD but definitely not one of his bests. Plus most GA fans were looking for the usual 1 disc of Epic and 1 disc of Hard Trace.

Posted by refuge on May-11-2004 03:51:

quote:
Originally posted by Az
you're the biggest gimp on this forum
and I'm sure you were the biggest gimp on the forum with your previous alias, whatever it was

back to the CD
can someone tell me which track(s) on there were from 1993? or pre 97

Oh, I'm shaking! You're pretty tough to be sayin' that shit on-line.. you fuckin' e-thug!

Posted by JayD on May-11-2004 07:35:

Quit it please.

Thanks.

JaY

Posted by Ian on May-11-2004 08:32:

quote:
Originally posted by YaleTrance
another cash grab for Acosta. this guy is a joke.

12. Jon Secada � �Just Another Day� (George Acosta Remix)

That is a part of the history of trance?

it's one of those tracks you wish would go down in history to stop you being reminded of how gash it is

and I'm with ste, this has nearly fuck all to do with 1993-1997 bar a couple of tracks, this guy seems to be the hybrid of judge jules, dave pearce and atb.... and a bit of a wanker to boot, speaking of which, anyone sees him, please do so

Posted by Jordan Stevens on May-11-2004 09:35:

Posted by Pio on May-12-2004 00:34:

quote:
Originally posted by Ian^
it's one of those tracks you wish would go down in history to stop you being reminded of how gash it is

and I'm with ste, this has nearly fuck all to do with 1993-1997 bar a couple of tracks, this guy seems to be the hybrid of judge jules, dave pearce and atb.... and a bit of a wanker to boot, speaking of which, anyone sees him, please do so

I would if he weren't so fat.

Pages (2): [1] 2 »