Gabber vs. prog - the true duel of titans

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Polls - Music Related
-- Gabber vs. prog - the true duel of titans

Posted by Lira on Jun-10-2004 17:03:

Gabber vs. prog - the true duel of titans

Two of the most loved and hated genres here on TA. Pick your favourite!

(I chose gabber, by the way: It's fun, it's brought more musical innovations and and it's danceable )

Posted by jp on Jun-10-2004 17:22:

Without gabber trance wouldn't have been so popular

Posted by Coup on Jun-10-2004 17:45:

just because one style helped spawn another style does not mean the first style was actually shit.

if it was decent in the first place, no1 would have modified it

Posted by TranceMuzik02 on Jun-10-2004 17:56:

Happy Hardcore

Posted by Lira on Jun-10-2004 19:23:

3 votes for gabber, 3 votes for prog and no proghead's posted yet?

Them wimps

quote:
Originally posted by Coup
just because one style helped spawn another style does not mean the first style was actually shit.

if it was decent in the first place, no1 would have modified it

Good one

Was that you, who voted for prog, Coup?

Posted by Radagast on Jun-11-2004 07:05:

Between those two, progressive. There are plenty of other genres to go to besides gabba if I want fun.

Posted by whitey on Jun-11-2004 10:06:

GabberHardcore doesn't even compare to progressive. Gabber/Hardcore is just silliness especially Happy Hardcore

peace
whitey

Posted by XeQtOr on Jun-11-2004 13:06:

PROGRESSIVE

Posted by Sand Leaper on Jun-11-2004 13:27:

Both genres are quite shit at the moment. Back in the day I'd say both though.

Posted by UnBracKo on Jun-11-2004 13:28:

Between these two I'd pick prog. but neither is one of my fav. genres...

Posted by Stephenox on Jun-11-2004 14:21:

I hate gabber/hardcore stuff in general. I like progtrance but definitely not proghouse... so I prefer prog over gabber/hardcore in general.

Posted by Coup on Jun-11-2004 16:44:

prog is amazing.

Posted by R.j. on Jun-11-2004 17:18:

prog

Posted by jimmy makkas on Jun-16-2004 12:14:

the very first cd i bought was hardcore/gabba style, it was this music that eventually got me into trance (and i spose hardhouse )

Posted by Stuku on Jun-16-2004 16:22:

quote:
Originally posted by Coup
prog is amazing.

YES

Posted by ()mar.( on Jun-16-2004 16:47:

Progressive, no question. Prog., in my opinion, requires a shit loud of more talent, then just gabber. That stuff gives me a headache sometimes.

Posted by Hitman on Jun-17-2004 11:48:

Stupid comparison...

Posted by Lira on Jun-17-2004 15:19:

quote:
Originally posted by Hitman
Stupid comparison...

I know that it's stupid to compare a genre that not only puts you on a deep trance but also brought new possibilities and innovations to music as a whole with a genre that is roughly a flow of sounds that comes from absolutely nowhere and has definition whatsoever such as prog, but it's surprisingly on the lead so... oh well

Posted by websley on Jun-18-2004 18:01:

Gabber/Hardcore= (starts hating it!)
Progressive=oke, but you forgot about other great styles lately man, I obviously voted on the last option!

Posted by Psy-T on Jun-19-2004 14:01:

Mmmmm Prog!!!

Posted by Kurve on Jun-21-2004 19:39:

This pool is a no brainer........its like comparing Shit to Diamonds

Gabber = fruity loop creations by 12 year olds

prog = is gods gift to man!!!!! hehehehe (biased answer because prog is my fav)

Posted by emander on Jun-25-2004 04:02:

Count

Posted by Lira on Jun-28-2004 05:49:

(Kurve: remember diamonds are nothing but carbon, while shite is able to fertilise the soil and let life go on )

quote:
Originally posted by emander
Count

Someone who's actually being honest

Posted by noikeee on Jun-28-2004 10:16:

it's a bit obvious that i'm a prog fan

Posted by tactik on Jun-28-2004 13:48:

Since gabber doesn't require any talent and prog does, I'm voting for prog!