Ferry Corsten vs Thrillseekers - Sublime & George Hales - Autumn Falls

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Ferry Corsten vs Thrillseekers - Sublime & George Hales - Autumn Falls

Posted by wrzonance on Aug-04-2004 07:04:

Ferry Corsten vs Thrillseekers - Sublime & George Hales - Autumn Falls

I was just chilling in my car, listening to some tracks... when I came across this interesting fact

Why does the main melody in George Hales - Autumn Falls sound so similar to The Ferry Corsten vs Thrillseekers - Sublime melody?

it's got a be a coincidence because those melodies are reallly similar, or is each adapting a melody from a different piece of music or is it just such a simple melody it'd be easy for 2 seperate producers to just come up with it?

help me out guys?

and oh yea, i'm not dissing on either cuz i think both just plain rule, i just want to clear things up and make sure im not the only one who's noticed it

Posted by george_hales on Aug-16-2004 09:20:

Howdy,

I do agree that they sound alike, but i actually came up with the melody without having heard sublime at all. The track has gone on to get major support from both Ferry Corsten and Steve Helstrip, so the legallities of it all seem fine.

Geo

Posted by meLon on Aug-16-2004 09:50:

Does that make you George Hales? lol

Posted by isoterra on Aug-16-2004 09:51:

It does :P

I thought it bore more resemblance to Trouser Enthusiasts - Sweet Release... you heard that one either revelx?

Posted by george_hales on Aug-16-2004 10:11:

I have, its quite old now, '98 i think... I dont think its got anything in common with it though :S

Posted by ASOT100 on Aug-16-2004 10:19:

when is sublime gonna be released!?!

i've already got autumn falls

Posted by netroM on Aug-16-2004 10:39:

quote:
Originally posted by meLon
Does that make you George Hales? lol

yup

And i'm still waiting for him to finish his remix of Push - The Legacy

Posted by george_hales on Aug-16-2004 10:50:

quote:
Originally posted by meLon
Does that make you George Hales? lol

Er... I think so :S

Posted by Mr.Mystery on Aug-16-2004 12:24:

Maybe Ferry just wanted to get back at you for naming one of your tracks Kyoto

Posted by DJAntSmith on Aug-16-2004 14:25:

They're both great tracks but I don't think they sound too alike. Sublime is out next week i think. :-) 21st August or around that time.

Posted by Billabong on Aug-16-2004 17:48:

Both tracks are great. Sublime was a big track when it was first heard, but, that was so long ago. I would have thought that it would have been released by now, considering i heard it atleast 6 months ago. If sublime had been released around when it was first heard, then im sure it would be a bigger hit, than it will be when it released next week, as some have said.

Posted by NiteMer on Aug-16-2004 17:58:

Any of you guys notice how much of a rip off Micro - Penetrate is off of Liquid Child - Diving Faces? It took me a while to put my finger on it, but, damn, it's like the same exact melody.

Posted by Omegasox on Aug-16-2004 23:40:

quote:
Originally posted by Nite-Mer
Any of you guys notice how much of a rip off Micro - Penetrate is off of Liquid Child - Diving Faces? It took me a while to put my finger on it, but, damn, it's like the same exact melody.

Why are there always new threads about rip-offs? Whose to say that they were ripped off? With the multitude of tunes that have been released since EDM started, of course there are going to be similarities. There are only so many variations to be had.

It's annoying.

Posted by TheVrk on Aug-16-2004 23:57:

quote:
Originally posted by revelx
Er... I think so :S

that is way 2 cool

Posted by itsTrueSonic on Aug-17-2004 04:49:

OOMG OMG OMG OMG!!!

'sublime' is going to be released...
well i do agree with the other guy that it would have been more massive if released at it's peak, but who cares..

this song rocks!!

just as the same question .. why didn't gabriel and dresden release ATRC earlier, at it's peak, rather than at it's staleness??

Posted by DJAntSmith on Aug-17-2004 07:41:

I'm guessing because Sublime was available as an album track since last August, that anyone with a cdj can spin it. I'm sure that they set-up a schedule as well for what tracks are going to be released and when as well. Although they could of moved it forward.

Posted by Plastick on Aug-17-2004 08:49:

To me, they're not really that similar that make me go 'OMG rip off!' I can recognise each of them pretty much well.

Posted by Simcut on Aug-17-2004 11:37:

Autumn Falls rox but Somatic Sense really fucked up the pressing