Cosmic String/But For A Day debate.

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Cosmic String/But For A Day debate.

Posted by Skagdog on Dec-20-2004 15:17:

Cosmic String/But For A Day debate.

Can anybody confirm which is which of these 2 tunes. When I first got the originals on 1 record that told me which was which tune but now its come out on Vandit with Marc Van Linden mixes the tunes are the other way round.

At GC Ice Rink PVD played Cosmic String 1st and But For A Day last I think. This is what the original release said the tunes are and what has been right on all tracklistings up until recently. But Vandit says the opposite.

Anybody??

Posted by Rick D on Dec-20-2004 18:51:

from what i've heard, the vinyl is labeled wrong.

Posted by Tenshi on Dec-20-2004 19:14:

quote:
Originally posted by moondog
from what i've heard, the vinyl is labeled wrong.

which one? the vandit pressing?

Posted by sandstorm03 on Dec-20-2004 19:17:

quote:
Originally posted by Tenshi
which one? the vandit pressing?

yea

Posted by PEZ68 on Dec-20-2004 19:20:

Is it 'but for a day' or 'just for a day'. I remember seeing a rls with 'but'

Posted by Konijn on Dec-20-2004 19:20:

if someone can email mark and find out what's what we can get this resolved

Posted by swisstoni_uk on Dec-20-2004 23:20:

well im going off the Vandit releases for now. There website details agree with their vinyl, which by the way, also says JUST FOR A DAY

emailed Mark just then so lets see what he says

Posted by swisstoni_uk on Dec-21-2004 17:00:

from Mark himself:

Hi,

I will try and help you out but its been switched around by various labels
(incorrectly) several times now that i dont know which track is which myself
anymore! Ok, although i dont yet have a copy of the vandit release, as long
as they haven't changed it from the details i gave them, they are the
correct way round. Cosmicstring is the one with the big trancey pad
breakdown that repeats in the second half of the track. Just for a day
(which incidentally some people call But For a Day!) is the more unusually
constructed track with the arpeggio leads and strings.

Hope this sorts it out for you!

regards,

Mark (Marcos)

Posted by Skagdog on Dec-21-2004 18:40:

quote:
Originally posted by swisstoni_uk
from Mark himself:

Hi,

I will try and help you out but its been switched around by various labels
(incorrectly) several times now that i dont know which track is which myself
anymore! Ok, although i dont yet have a copy of the vandit release, as long
as they haven't changed it from the details i gave them, they are the
correct way round. Cosmicstring is the one with the big trancey pad
breakdown that repeats in the second half of the track. Just for a day
(which incidentally some people call But For a Day!) is the more unusually
constructed track with the arpeggio leads and strings.

Hope this sorts it out for you!

regards,

Mark (Marcos)
Glad thats cleared up. So the original vinyl that I got was wrong and it does say BUT for a day on it. And all the tracklistings ive seen up till recently have been wrong as well. Weird.

Posted by Konijn on Dec-21-2004 19:29:

looks like vandit got 'em right

Posted by mety333 on Dec-22-2004 12:50:

What the hell?!

On Blank & Jones The Mix Vol. 3 CD, I heard the tracks "Marcos - Cosmic String" and When I got the "Cosmic String/Just for A Day" Vinyl and played it, IT WASN'T THE SAME TRACK! But when I played "Marcos - Just for a Day", THAT WAS IT!

So who made the mistake? Vandit?

BTW, that track is awesome I love it!
But this thing confuses me because it seems that I listened to a track for a few months with the wrong name!!! (unless Vandit is the one who made the mistake)

Posted by CygnusX on Dec-22-2004 12:55:

Well mety333, it seems Vandit was right here.
I've also been listening to Just For A Day for months, thinking it was Cosmic String

Posted by Ricky Tan on Dec-22-2004 16:00:

Sorry, I'm still confused. Am I wrong in saying that listening to PVD's sets that the tracks were always ID wrong and causing us to think the vinyl is incorrect?

Posted by swisstoni_uk on Dec-22-2004 16:48:

according to Mark, Vandit have the right release, go check out www.vandit.de for samples so you can see which is which

Posted by Dj Gracjan on Dec-22-2004 19:15:

i love that vinyl regardless of the messup!! really nice tunes!!

Posted by mety333 on Dec-22-2004 20:46:

quote:
Originally posted by CygnusX
Well mety333, it seems Vandit was right here.
I've also been listening to Just For A Day for months, thinking it was Cosmic String

heh We were both fooled

Anyway, great release!