TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Over rated DJ's?
Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Over rated DJ's?

In modern dance music you just can't escape the super star DJ image. In this light I have a question for you, Who do you think is the most over rated DJ?

I'm probably gonna get a lot of flak for this but in my oppinion it's Paul Okenfold.

What do you peeps think?

After Oakies blinding EM i couldnt possibley say him, although i think picotoo is going downhill fast (jokes). Well most overated dj, after months of listening has to go to dave pearce after his shocking mixes on his weekday show

Err you do know that the mixing in his week day show isn't done by him don't you? They actually employ somone to do it for him

Yeah, Ill Back That One. I Saw Dave Pearce Live @ TallTrees Not To Long Ago, And No Joke - I Can Mix Better. He Was Failing To Keep Beats Whilst Mixng. Very Poor !

Well i suppose he is getting a little lazy, u learn something new everyday

i know a lot of ppl will hate me for saying this, but Johan Gielen...

together with Svenson, he can produce some nice tracks, but he makes 2 much errors spinning, and the "show" he gives away while fucking up his set, horrible, i still wake up at night, sweating, with the images of him spinning at Impulz Outdoor on my mind... THE HORROR!!!!!!!!

quote:

Originally posted by flystyler Well i suppose he is getting a little lazy, u learn something new everyday

LOL - It must be down to all them pies fat hands is eating

quote:

Originally posted by burns Yeah, Ill Back That One. I Saw Dave Pearce Live @ TallTrees Not To Long Ago, And No Joke - I Can Mix Better. He Was Failing To Keep Beats Whilst Mixng. Very Poor !

I have to disagree cuz i saw him at Eden in Ibiza and he blew the roof off the place, he was wikkid. And as for his Radio Show he doesnt actually do any of the mixing on that 'cept for bout 20mins on his sunday show towards the end when he plays his own favs of the week.

Peace

Dave Pearce is pretty shitly rated which is good he plays cheese if I can put it that way, he may have an occasional good set, but I can't actually get my head round to respect someone who spins Ian Van Dahl - castles in the sky fuck thats cheese and he's to blaim why a lot of cheesy trance is around. roll another one fat one you fat ****! lol

Oh and getting back to the thread subject I used to think Oakenfold was overated my cousin who lived in Scouseville (liverpool) used to rant on about his sets on the courtyard there all the time @ Cream, and I used to be like yeah he's ok, I saw him at GCSS and he was ok not to bad but that EM on saturday was fucking wicked, and my views totally changed on him, and I see a lot of anti Oakie crew on here being Quiet for once hahahahah.

My overated Dj has to be John Digweed I like most of Sashas stuff but I find Digweed very boring for some reason but thats just my opionion, theres 10000s out there who rate him but I just can't bring myself round to like his style and see why some many people like him.

quote:

Originally posted by Gekhous he makes 2 much errors spinning

if you're referring to the fading and scratching then i don't know if i would really call those errors. i just tend to think that he loves to experiment around during his sets and thats why i love it when he spins. having said that though, his mixing definitely isn't seemless to say the least but thats not just johan gielen. there are many other famous dutch/belgian/british DJ's that don't mix perfectly every set either.

quote:

Originally posted by Gekhous i know a lot of ppl will hate me for saying this, but Johan Gielen... together with Svenson, he can produce some nice tracks, but he makes 2 much errors spinning, and the "show" he gives away while fucking up his set, horrible, i still wake up at night, sweating, with the images of him spinning at Impulz Outdoor on my mind... THE HORROR!!!!!!!!

I have to disagree with you on that one, I saw Gielen here in Toronto last month and he was just awesome. It was such a small party(less than 100 people), but he made all of us unite into a blissful and euphoric crowd. You really felt his passion for the music, along with an awesome tracklist. It was a great night, until Tiesto overshadowed it 9 days later!

I personally think Oakie is overrated, I know alot of people regained some respect for him after his EM, but to be honest that EM didn't do it for me. He played alot of older songs, and that's exactly what he gets bashed for. Not to mention when he mixed into PPK, that was not the best mix. Oakie = Overrated.

I also think Scott Bond and JFK both get a hell of alot more credit than they deserve.

i would say that judge jules is pretty over-rated

quote:

Originally posted by kluba_702 i would say that judge jules is pretty over-rated

quote:

Originally posted by flystyler

sorry dude

i knew when i posted that it would anger some peeps, so in the interest of not starting a flaming war and going into this whole thing about why i dis-like him i simply voiced my humble opinion


agree to dis-agree??....

Mauro Picotto
Judge Jules (now)
Eddie Halliwell (in the UK anyway)
John 'smelly' Kelly

mauro is an amazing DJ!!!!!!!! amazing......and judge jules is da bomb too.....but...overrated DJ's...hmmm....let me think..... I wouldn't say trance DJ's really....I think Roger sanchez and arman ven halden are over rated crap......the trance Dj;s are all coo.....

why do you say Roger Sanchez and Armand Van Heldon are overrated? ive never heard any of there sets but there meant to be like house institutions... some of thier productions are pretty good too but i think you have to really be into house and all to appreciate them

quote:

Originally posted by kluba_702 i would say that judge jules is pretty over-rated

Hey Jules...
Don't take it bad...
Take a sad song, and make it better...


no seriously he's is OK, it's Oakie who's way overrated

John Digweed is NOT overrated at all! Sure, you may not like his style of music, but that doesn't mean he's bad. Mixing wise, he's one of the best, if not the best, out there without a doubt.

Hate the skill, not the music

i know i will get in trouble for this

but i think that dave seaman was a bit overated

and i definately agree that judge jules is over rated

you say that oakey's overrated........it may be true....but it's probably only because he's too popular now, a sellout.......back in the day......he was amazing.........I thought so at least....

he got me into a lot of sounds........

i dont think oakie's overated........maybe slightly but id still place himin the top 10

oakie is still one of my favs in my mind

yeah.....he's good.........but.......I think a dj is more than a mixer, or song selector........s/he is someone that interacts with the crowd, smiles, and goes to that place with you..........and not once have I felt that oakey was there for me............I felt more like he was grabbin the energy; not bringing any love.......(un-like tiesto)......that's a real DJ. In my opinion.
peace

i agree

arman van helden is a total asshole

did u know he still asks for the most to spin at certain events????


what a waste

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.