Is this penalty legal?! - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Sports Discussion
-- Is this penalty legal?!

Posted by razmataz on Feb-04-2005 19:07:

Is this penalty legal?!

right click save as

http://xandru.footballclips.net/Oth...ndsport-2-0.avi

Discuss.

After my own discussions and references, the general consensus is that it is in fact legal even to this day.

Strange that you don't see it these days.

Posted by noikeee on Feb-04-2005 19:27:

i've got no clue, but the keepers surprised (lack of) reaction is awesome

Posted by InterMilan31 on Feb-04-2005 20:10:

OLE!!!

Posted by chesco on Feb-04-2005 21:18:

I think as long as the ball travels forward then it's legal alright.

Posted by Acid Circus on Feb-04-2005 22:23:

Yup perfectly legal.

Posted by InterMilan31 on Feb-04-2005 22:36:

As long as he was onside when he passed it off.

Posted by fastmp3 on Feb-04-2005 22:55:

then how come we don't see such penalties anymore ?

i'm sure it's now forbidden

Posted by Michael19 on Feb-05-2005 01:01:

quote:
Originally posted by fastmp3
then how come we don't see such penalties anymore ?

i'm sure it's now forbidden

nope.

the law says once the ball travels forward in a penalty then its fine. the attacker must be outside the box aswell when the ball is kicked.

the reason its not done now is because defenders run in aswell. if you look at the cyruff one theres only 2 oppisition players standing there, and they dont bother even moving.

if it was tried now, chances are a defender would have a good chance of getting a tackle in, thats why it not done. would be perfectly acceptable if tried though

Posted by techno_freak on Feb-05-2005 02:18:

i dont think so....

Posted by sensorium on Feb-05-2005 05:54:

Illegal if you do it to Real Madrid.

Posted by Deejiuana on Feb-07-2005 15:43:

it is perfectly legal:
1-the attacker who was passed the ball was outside the penalty box
2-the ball travelled forward
3-After the penalty taker touches the ball, anyone can get in the penalty box and touch the ball (we do see this when keepers dont grab the ball but just hit it)

y is this not done so often?
1-i doubt nowadays there are a lot of keepers that r just gonna stand there like this keeper
2-after penalty taker touches the ball, a lot of defenders get inside the penalty box

this happened to us once in a soccer tournament and we thought it was illegal n bla bla bla, but it wasnt....they showed us a lot of things n shit

(but those penalties can only be made during the game of course)

Posted by CHIVA FIGTHER on Apr-18-2005 03:19:

MMMMMMMmmmmmm

I think is Legal 100%

Posted by denys envy on Apr-19-2005 16:51:

seeing how this team is getting destroyed 5-0 at this point, i don't really think the defenders care much about charging into the box, especially when it's Cryuff taking a PK they probably expect him to make it. And the fact that they suck also tells me why Ajax even attempted this shit. The truth is if they were playing in Europe Johan would probably go with the shot instead of risking crap like this around world class defenders.

Posted by Peter K on Apr-21-2005 10:00:

can someone upload this to yousendit.com? i wanna see this

Posted by Disney on Apr-21-2005 12:20:

quote:
Originally posted by Peter K
can someone upload this to yousendit.com? i wanna see this

http://s20.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=...OB3KRO4PCJS4C6O