TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Chill Out Room
-- Movie "The Village": What Would You Do?

Movie "The Village": What Would You Do?

This may be a spoiler if you have not watched the movie, and this certainly is not a movie revue, and is not intended to be.

What I'm asking is:

1. If you were brought up in a town like that shown in The Village, and knew no different, how would you behave?

2. Would you live peacefully?

3. Would you wonder into the forest to meet the people that "we don't speak of"?

4. Would you defy authority and find your own answers?

5. Would you make the most of your life in The Village and be satisfied with your life?

6. Would you marry someone in The Village and have children without experiencing life somewhere else or with other people?

7. If you knew the truth would you stay there?

8. Would you tell your parents and all your friends to 'get fucked' if it involved exploring the world outside The Village.

Feel free to answer the above in more detail, offer some opinions, and answer less than all questions if you like, a discussion is better than short answers.

If you watched The Village expecting a thriller or an action movie you may have been disappointed, but when you think about the message, its truly powerful.

It really makes us ask questions of our own life and whether we are satisfied to live the life we think we should live, or whether we question EVERYTHING, and push the boundaries, and whether we experience life outside of our "Village", so as to speak.

If you haven't seen The Village, I suggest you hire it out and answer this quiz and look at what Village you live in.

This movie sucked, I only watched it because my parents made the mistake of renting it from Blockbuster and had nothing else to do that night. It takes alot for me to not enjoy a movie, but this one had all of the elements.

My view was the whole scenario was kinda fucked up. Where were the guns? Folks living back in those conditions normally had some weapons of some sort. I never even saw them attempt to defend themselves with a scythe, axe, or sledge even if they had no guns. What a cowardly world. It's understandable, since the fear was only self-inflicted in the first place, but even the retard seemed to be able to use a knife.


[[[smoke]]]

Suncreem vs Push - Please Save Me

Ooops! Sorry, I used the bad color...

quote:

Originally posted by TeKnoHe@d2025 This movie sucked, I only watched it because my parents made the mistake of renting it from Blockbuster and had nothing else to do that night. It takes alot for me to not enjoy a movie, but this one had all of the elements.

For a moment ditch the idea that we are talking about the movie, because talking about the message in the movie is different.

There have been few movies with such powerful messages, even if it came accross badly and was not entertaining.

But, for a moment, seriously, imagine you were a kid brought up in the village, and knew no other life, and knew no different to live living in an isolated town with no-one allowed to leave. Then answer the questions and see what Village you live in, because everybody does to a point.

quote:

Originally posted by smokeape My view was the whole scenario was kinda fucked up. Where were the guns? Folks living back in those conditions normally had some weapons of some sort. I never even saw them attempt to defend themselves with a scythe, axe, or sledge even if they had no guns. What a cowardly world. It's understandable, since the fear was only self-inflicted in the first place, but even the retard seemed to be able to use a knife. [[[smoke]]]

Yep, true, but for a kid that was born in that town, they wouldn't know what guns were...

well i have an overwhelming curiosity factor when it comes to mysteries... i generally won't do anything about the mystery but i'd try to find out as much information as possible about it... this would ultimately get me killed

so yeah - i'd die

I don't watch films (any, at all) so I'm not sure I understand the question, but knowing me, I would probably lay low if life was good enough, you know, no hardships or anything, if I could get on with my life there fine, I have no desire to explore or meet excessive amounts of people. I'm not sure how the people lived in this film though?

There are tons of examples of "isolated" places and people. There are those who have never saw a colored person, there are those who never saw snow before. Amish people don't use electricity, nuns don't have sex.

I'm not really seeing a point here.

Well living in THAT Village I would probably shag all the chicks, and when they have kids, I'd start my own football team, curiosity would also get the best of me, and I'd be killed.

As for the Village I live in now, nobody does anything but watch TV, and the nightlife is crap most the time, maybe I should look into starting a football team here.

quote:

Originally posted by TeKnoHe@d2025 There are tons of examples of "isolated" places and people. There are those who have never saw a colored person, there are those who never saw snow before. Amish people don't use electricity, nuns don't have sex. I'm not really seeing a point here.

The point is that we all live our lives in a Village to some point, even if it is only a mental Village.

Sure we may not be living in an isolated community in the middle of no where, or be trapped with no contact with the outside world, but the message in The Village is a large part more powerful than that simple translation.

Just as the children in The Village are brought up with a set of ideals, and understanding of the world, and they could either choose to live in harmony and accept what is that world, or they can question and experience life for themselves. They can do the stuff they were told by their parents and major influences not to do.

A person's personal Village may be the religion their parents brought them up in, it may be the type of live they are expected to live, it may be the things we are taught to stay away from or that are bad, it covers lots of things.

Why The Village is so powerful is that if you went along with the story, we could be living our lives so far detached from reality and missing out on so many things just because we are scared to question and experience life for ourselves and do teh stuff we have been told not to do. Those kids in the movie really did think that those creatures existed, and why wouldn't they? We can also think our biggest fears are real, when in reality they are not.

quote:

Originally posted by -=M=- well i have an overwhelming curiosity factor when it comes to mysteries... i generally won't do anything about the mystery but i'd try to find out as much information as possible about it... this would ultimately get me killed so yeah - i'd die

Well, in line with the movie you wouldn't be killed you'd get to experience the real world, and lots of stuff that you didn't even know existed.

The movie sucked big time

i loved it, all of M. Night shama lama ding dongs movies are the shiznit.

Re: Movie "The Village": What Would You Do?

1. If you were brought up in a town like that shown in The Village, and knew no different, how would you behave?

i would behave the way i developed to behave, im clueless as to what way that is though

2. Would you live peacefully?

yes, im mentally stable enough to live out any existence peacefully

3. Would you wonder into the forest to meet the people that "we don't speak of"?

nodbody ever said those are people if i remember right.
if i believed the sayings of the people i respected in the village, id have no need to explore for myself, if i hadnt believed them, i would probably explore for myself.

4. Would you defy authority and find your own answers?

see 3

5. Would you make the most of your life in The Village and be satisfied with your life?

see 2

6. Would you marry someone in The Village and have children without experiencing life somewhere else or with other people?

depending on the factors of 3

7. If you knew the truth would you stay there?

if i knew the truth, id be biased towards living on the outside.

8. Would you tell your parents and all your friends to 'get fucked' if it involved exploring the world outside The Village.

yes.

How are ya liking the responses so far Tobias?

I will continue the trend of not responding to your intent and mention that the entire plot of the movie was stolen from a Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode from 1994

http://www.startrek.com/startrek/vi...sode/68152.html

"Suspicious, Sisko questions Alixus about how she conveniently managed to end up on a planet that so completely supports her philosophy of life without technology."

...

"Alixus admits to creating the situation that has kept them there. Her people turn against her, now knowing the truth, but they ultimately elect to stay."

Why the hell did they send a blind girl who knows jack shit about the outside society when one of the seeing elders could have just as easily jumped the fence, grabbed the medicine, stopped for a beer, and then returned with no one the wiser? Sending the girl was unnecessarily retarded. I would kill all the elders for being so goddamned dumb, that's what I would do.

no need to search for deeper meaning in a dumb movie. shall we dicuss scooby doo next and the role of a patriocal society?

Can you please be Spec again?

quote:

Originally posted by UWM Can you please be Spec again?

who's spec? never heard of him?

I would live alone in my own house and if people came near, I would run out at them, screaming obscenities and jibberish, while hurling angry cats at them.

i just saw this movie last weekend...


i think if you lived in a village like that...you wouldn't know any type of life other then what you were born into. if you were seriously raised to believe that there were these terrible creators in the forest that will kill you...and it was reinforced in every facet of life, i think it would be a great deturrent from you trying to discover it. i don't know how i would behave because i probably wouldn't think the same way that i do know. a lot of my opinions are based around a knowledge that i've learned over the course of my life and without that knowledge...i might not be in a position to challenge things....

i dunno...interesting concept though...

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.