"Birth of An Angel" vs "Shivers" - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Polls - Music Related
-- "Birth of An Angel" vs "Shivers"

Posted by LeopoldStotch on Jul-14-2005 01:40:

"Birth of An Angel" vs "Shivers"

has this been done before ?? if not, then woo hoo! i'm original! .. if it has already been done, then flame me .

what's better ???

birth of an angel or shivers ??

both the same song, but the difference is shivers has vocals.

so do you like the vocal version, or the "instrumental" version (no vocals) .?? ..

i chose "shivers" because i love the cheesy lyrics . who doesn't ?

Posted by aloep on Jul-14-2005 03:24:

Dislike both equally.

Posted by Uplifting on Jul-14-2005 14:08:

i like shivers, with vocal

Posted by Project 7 on Jul-14-2005 14:32:

Birth Of An Angel, i prefer

Posted by isoterra on Jul-14-2005 15:48:

aka "pile of turd" vs "pile of turd with flies around it"

BoaA i guess

although i went for the last option

Posted by Iceferno on Jul-20-2005 20:07:

I prefer Birth Of An Angel. I think the vocals mess up the song. Perhaps if someone like Justine Suissa did the vocals, I might like it better...

Posted by tubularbills on Jul-21-2005 05:18:

I actually like the version of Shivers on ASOT 2005 - not the full vocals, just a main chorus line. sounds really slick.

Posted by Ted Promo on Jul-21-2005 05:40:

Birth Of An Angel. It almost made me believe Armin could still pump out those banging uplifting tracks. Then he had to resort to Shivers vocal add-ins and stoop to the likes of Oceanlab, or a previous production... namely... Burned With Desire.

Posted by Hanki on Jul-21-2005 14:12:

Both sucks...

Posted by MaGiK54 on Jul-21-2005 16:53:

Birth Of an Angel

Posted by jp on Jul-21-2005 16:58:

Shivers is cheese

Posted by tactik on Jul-21-2005 17:31:

Don't like either, both suck imo.

Posted by Nayil on Jul-22-2005 09:13:

confused...the non vocal 1

Posted by bananas on Jul-22-2005 17:20:

quote:
Originally posted by aloep
Dislike both equally.

yes +1

Posted by Kapedano on Jul-22-2005 23:26:

Re: "Birth of An Angel" vs "Shivers"

quote:
Originally posted by LeopoldStotch
i chose "shivers" because i love the cheesy lyrics . who doesn't ?

i dont, i dont like both of them, but if i had to listen id listen to birth of an angel, anyways im not a big fan of armins productions.

Posted by sEpH on Jul-23-2005 01:08:

Birth Of An Angel

Posted by aralemomdadok on Jul-28-2005 01:57:

Shivers make me shiver. a different vocalist may do the trick.

Haven't heard of BoaA, but based on my brain filtered version of shiver, I think it has potential.

Posted by Hman on Jul-28-2005 09:01:

shivers

Posted by Epic Star on Jul-28-2005 14:31:

Birth of an Angel