TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- opus 17 is repetitive...


Posted by Denser on Aug-26-2005 17:43:

opus 17 is repetitive...

rank 1 - opus 17


is basically too long and repetitive. its a good concept (although its been done before in shorter length in adagio for strings)....

but the song length is really pushing it.


maybe they need to learn a thing or two about making 12 minute songs from way out west.


Posted by Ted Promo on Aug-26-2005 17:58:

*waits for Benno's remarks on this.


I will admit, Opus 17 is definitely not my thing. I've had enough of those epic symphony tracks. Top Gear is where it's at in my book.


Posted by Kapedano on Aug-26-2005 18:01:

I personally like Opus 17 more then Top Gear and i find Top Gear to be Rank 1's worst work, but i respect the idea of them trying new sounds rather then being boring and having the same sound.


Posted by Cribby on Aug-26-2005 18:12:

I think Opus 17 is the best track this year...it's soo epic and beautiful


Posted by Denser on Aug-26-2005 18:20:

quote:
Originally posted by Crib
I think Opus 17 is the best track this year...it's soo epic and beautiful




exactly which month this year did you start listening to trance ?


Posted by Cribby on Aug-26-2005 19:21:

quote:
Originally posted by Denser
exactly which month this year did you start listening to trance ?


hmm about March.....2001


Posted by cluBBer on Aug-26-2005 21:29:

Arrow Re: opus 17 is repetitive...

quote:
Originally posted by Denser
rank 1 - opus 17


is basically too long and repetitive. its a good concept (although its been done before in shorter length in adagio for strings)....

but the song length is really pushing it.



I agree with you. The track sucks!


Posted by Ian on Aug-26-2005 21:34:

Re: Re: opus 17 is repetitive...

quote:
Originally posted by cluBBer
I agree with you. The track sucks!


any actual reasons for this, or is it going to be like that time you said all hard trance sucked because you didn't like it ?


Posted by sandstorm03 on Aug-26-2005 23:05:

Re: Re: Re: opus 17 is repetitive...

quote:
Originally posted by Ian^
any actual reasons for this, or is it going to be like that time you said all hard trance sucked because you didn't like it ?


well your a gimp because i say so, isn't that the same sort of thing?


Posted by Toufas on Aug-27-2005 00:03:

a hamster once ate the ass out my pants. i felt exposed seeing this was at school. My teacher tried to get me to change but they were my favorite pair. It scars me till this day to know that the whole day my ass was showing off to the world and its all because of that hampster.

years later i found him and ate him. that will teach him to eat pants


Posted by CleverName on Aug-27-2005 00:20:

If you don't like repetitive you might be in the wrong genre, pal...


Posted by leinaD mailliW on Aug-27-2005 00:58:

quote:
Originally posted by Toufas
a hamster once ate the ass out my pants. i felt exposed seeing this was at school. My teacher tried to get me to change but they were my favorite pair. It scars me till this day to know that the whole day my ass was showing off to the world and its all because of that hampster.

years later i found him and ate him. that will teach him to eat pants


lol 2 funny :P

Will


Posted by EverZ on Aug-27-2005 01:12:

Decent track, indeed a little repetitive. Top Gear is alot better.


Posted by Cobalt on Aug-27-2005 01:59:

Not to be too critical, but it's basically Orange Theme Part II, only five years too late.

Top Gear, on the other hand, is right up there with the Lyteo remix.


Posted by TOR on Aug-27-2005 12:10:

i don't like it at all. it's just too basic, doesn't bring anything new to the table.. this formula can work if it features a brilliant main melody, but this one does nothing for me. 10 minutes of standing still for me on the dancefloor..

Top Gear all the way!


Posted by PlasticSoul on Aug-27-2005 15:02:

quote:
Originally posted by Cobalt
Not to be too critical, but it's basically Orange Theme Part II, only five years too late.

Top Gear, on the other hand, is right up there with the Lyteo remix.


Agreed.
I like Opus 17, catchy melody and remember me orange theme, indeed.

Well.. if somebody is complaining about this song be so long and repetitive, so do a dj set and mix only about a few 5 minutes or try make 3 minutes rework, a "radio" edit, taht will work for you if taht is the problem.
Somebody saying a track is bad cus its long and repetitive is a bad argument IMO, sorry, it could be bad if talking about melodies and sounds, and taht's personal.
I prefer long tracks than 5 minutes ones...


Posted by AlonMiz on Aug-27-2005 18:16:

Arrow

opus 17 is a hit for me.
the melody is awesome. i love those symphonic style tracks.
although it was done million times before
i care mostly for the melody.
its the only thing that cannot ever be repeated.
about the length, u dont need to hear all of it.
and for top gear, like one said before, one of their most worst prodection ever. but i respect theier progress and trying to change a bit.



Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.