TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Canada - Toronto & Southern Ont.
-- Is the term "weather girl" derogatory and sexist?

Is the term "weather girl" derogatory and sexist?

I hope this guy wins his lawsuit. Time to put an end to mindless political correctness

quote:

Liberal MLA Mike Murphy has slapped Tory Margaret Ann Blaney with a slander suit for accusing him of making a sexist remark in the legislature. Murphy, a lawyer, filed the action in Fredericton court Wednesday morning. Blaney was served with the suit in a back corridor of the legislature soon after. "These is a line in the sand and she's crossed it," the Moncton-area MLA said. "It was an innocuous statement and she knows it." Blaney, who represents Saint John Kings, told reporters that Moncton North MLA Mike Murphy referred to female weather broadcasters in a derogatory way during Question Period last Friday. "He was talking about the budget," she said. "He said, 'I want the minister to tell me what proof he has from any district engineer,' very professional term, 'any departmental official,' again, professional in approach, 'any climatologist' professional 'or any weather girl,' " she said, recalling Murphy's comments. "You know, we've moved on to the 21st century. I thought it was derogatory and I thought it was inappropriate and I thought it was the kind of language we shouldn't be employing in the house." Murphy said he is outraged that Blaney, who served as minister responsible for the status of women from 1999 and 2006, interpreted the statement in that way. He said he never intended the term "weather girl" to be offensive. "This is a slur against my family name. This is a slur against my wife, this is a slur against my children - of the five of them, two are teenaged girls and this is an insult to them." Murphy is seeking general and special damages, and costs. He says he will drop the suit if Blaney apologizes for the accusation. So far, she has refused.

that is awesome.

Wow some women really take it too far... idiot

quote:

Originally posted by Abercrombie

LOL

Jesus Christ, shes fucking retarded. Ugh.
Such dumb shit stuff.

Climatologist, bahahaahah

My scrot is sexist.

Labia are sexist.

quote:

minister responsible for the status of women from 1999 and 2006

ahahahahahahahahaha.

on a more serious note how the fuck would you call "weather girl"??

weather person?

she who gives us forecast??

on a totally serious note, when asked what he thinks about all this weather dude replied "dude...."

quote:

"You know,we've moved on to the 21st century. I thought it was derogatory and I thought it was inappropriate and I thought it was the kind of language we shouldn't be employing in the house."

its insulting to call girl A GIRL ????

i dont know what age are we living in but its scary. the line between normal and shit like this is getting really blurry

This is really stupid... I could understand (somewhat) if he called her the 'Weather Biatch', but 'Weather Girl'!?! Damn woman, get a grip!

quote:

Originally posted by Xavier Moriarty its insulting to call girl A GIRL ????

I suppose it depends on context and the connotative tone.

quote:

Margaret-Ann Blaney is a hypocrite when it comes to women's issues, says the Liberal MLA who is suing the Conservative legislator for slander Mike Murphy filed the suit against Blaney on Wednesday after she accused him of making a sexist remark. Murphy used the term "weather girl" in a discussion about the transportation budget during question period last Friday. Outside the legislature, Blaney told reporters Murphy had used the term in a way that was offensive to women. Murphy said he never intended the term as derogatory, and immediately slapped Blaney with a slander suit. Murphy said Blaney often cries sexism, but did very little while she was Minister for the Status of Women between 1999 and 2006. "She has done less for women in New Brunswick than any minister in the last 30 years," Murphy said, "and the fact that she is constantly trying to do something like this is very bad politics." Blaney made no public comments last month when it briefly appeared that women would lose access to publicly funded abortions in New Brunswick; her pay-equity plan calls for private-sector employers to voluntarily implement equal pay for equal work during the next five years. Blaney said she has accomplished a lot for the women of New Brunswick. "I'm very proud of what we've been able to do on women's issues in this province," the former cabinet minister said, "and I stand tall and proud on that front." Blaney has asked the house Speaker to rule on whether Murphy's lawsuit violates her privilege as a member of the legislature. Murphy says she can be sued because she made her comments outside the chamber

weather forecaster

on a related note... ive stopped politically correcting anything that has the word "man" on then end.

For example congressman, chairman, etc is applied equally to women and men who hold these positions. I do this for 2 reasons. 1)If true equality is the goal then why the need to distinguish between women and men? Isnt this what we are trying to end? 2) if anyone says that only "men" are represented by this term, may i remind them that the word "man" is the ending of both "human" and "woman"? Therefor they are fully represented in any title using the word man in it.

BTW i think using the term "person" on the end such as "chairperson" is truely bastardizing the english language. There is no need for it at all.

quote:

Originally posted by Xavier Moriarty on a more serious note how the fuck would you call "weather girl"?? weather person? she who gives us forecast??

meteorologist

Ya man.

quote:

Originally posted by AwakenedAddict meteorologist

A Meteorologist is someone who studies Meteorology, the scientific study of weather processes and forecasting. In other words, a scientist. This "weather girl" is most likely not a Meteorogolist. Most people who give the weather are not Meteorologists.

quote:

Originally posted by loconet A Meteorologist is someone who studies Meteorology, the scientific study of weather processes and forecasting. In other words, a scientist. This "weather girl" is most likely not a Meteorogolist. Most people who give the weather are not Meteorologists.

Yup, you are right. However, if you look at the origional context it was what he meant to say.

quote:

"He was talking about the budget," she said. "He said, 'I want the minister to tell me what proof he has from any district engineer,' very professional term, 'any departmental official,' again, professional in approach, 'any climatologist' professional 'or any weather girl,' " she said, recalling Murphy's comments.

When looking up the proper term I came across an award given by the "world meteorological organization" titled "Best Weather Presenter in the World". So "weather presenter" it is?

quote:

Originally posted by Jayx1

Additionally, how man ppl (read: women) use the term "guys" and "man" to refer to both men and women when speaking casually in everyday language.

Almost every single female I know will say "Hey guys" or "what's up man" even when speaking to a group composed ENTIRELY of females or when speaking to another female alone.

Its NOT a huge deal. Fuck.

quote:

Originally posted by Jem_hadar Additionally, how man ppl (read: women) use the term "guys" and "man" to refer to both men and women when speaking casually in everyday language. Almost every single female I know will say "Hey guys" or "what's up man" even when speaking to a group composed ENTIRELY of females or when speaking to another female alone. Its NOT a huge deal. Fuck.

I was thinking about this on the bus.. my thought process went something along these lines:

Would you call a man presenting the weather a "weather boy"? I don't think it would happen. So yeh, I think the term weather girl is a little sexist, but it's really not THAT big of a deal. I wouldn't make much of a fuss over it, but hey that's politics for you (petty politicians ).

quote:

Originally posted by AwakenedAddict I was thinking about this on the bus.. my thought process went something along these lines: Would you call a man presenting the weather a "weather boy"? I don't think it would happen. So yeh, I think the term weather girl is a little sexist, but it's really not THAT big of a deal. I wouldn't make much of a fuss over it, but hey that's politics for you (petty politicians ).

Nah, it's very common place to call the guy a "weatherman" and the gal a "weathergirl". I hope he wins this suit.

quote:

Originally posted by Hantu Nah, it's very common place to call the guy a "weatherman" and the gal a "weathergirl". I hope he wins this suit.

Me too! Fuck.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.