New rules FIFA should implement. - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- FIFA World Cup 2006 - Germany
-- New rules FIFA should implement.

Posted by denys envy on Jul-12-2006 06:07:

New rules FIFA should implement.

With all the shit going on, what are some rules you think FIFA should implement???

i have one -

If a player stays down on the pitch for longer than 10-15 (time is debatable) seconds after being "fouled" he is automatically substituted.

That way, if a player does stay down, you know he needs that sub.

Posted by RapidFire on Jul-12-2006 06:30:

no graham poll. ever.

Posted by svens_bath on Jul-12-2006 08:44:

Re: New rules FIFA should implement.

quote:
Originally posted by Aristronica
With all the shit going on, what are some rules you think FIFA should implement???

i have one -

If a player stays down on the pitch for longer than 10-15 (time is debatable) seconds after being "fouled" he is automatically substituted.

That way, if a player does stay down, you know he needs that sub.

you would just be encouraging people who were actually injured to get up straight away without getting any treatment and risk possibly hurting themselves worse...think about Henry in the final...he would only have played 1 minute, which wouldve spoiled it.

they should bring in retrospective match bans for people caught by a video review panel to be blatantly diving in games. might soon stop it...but then you might get teams encouraging their shit players to become 'fall guys' so its not foolproof

Posted by denys envy on Jul-12-2006 13:29:

guess it's all fucked then.... what else is on tv anyway?

Posted by malek on Jul-12-2006 19:38:

usage of video to rule out diving and fake injuries.

a judge watching tv monitors would tell by radio the ref on the field if the hit really happened or not.

-----

no more PKs in the final stages of the world cup, after the first 30 minutes of extra time, each time would remove one or two player. Both would play till a team scores... golden goal style, or if FIFA is too pussy, let the 15 mins period end before a winner is declared.

The game would open up, there would be more space.

-----

A radical move would be to stop the time when there's a player changed or a player needing medical attention.

Posted by Dj Smitty20 on Jul-12-2006 21:33:

They should get away from this "professional referee" bullshit. I dn't want a full time grocer or teacher reffing a game. It should be ex players who know the game better than anyone. They'd have to be stringent on making sure to avoid bias, even more than they are now (but there is always bias, don't kid yourselves).

Cards/suspensions for clear acting and idiots who demand cards. Same for unnoticed offences, whether or not the referee called a fould or gave a yellow. How Figo played on after the headbutt is nothing but a disgrace.

Any player who is carried off the field on a stretcher sould not be allowed back on for at least 5 minutes. IT's pathetic to see someone get carted off, only to hop up and run back on 30 seconds later. It's deliberate delay tactics.

Subbing off an injured goalie shouldn't count as one of the three substitutions. That really fucked ARgentina. Perhaps an extra sub in AET as well.

Further relaxing of the offside rule if possible and they need to CLEARLY define ball to hand and hand to ball. So many fucked up calls on that.

Posted by Michael19 on Jul-12-2006 21:57:

quote:
Originally posted by Dj Smitty20
They should get away from this "professional referee" bullshit. I dn't want a full time grocer or teacher reffing a game. It should be ex players who know the game better than anyone. They'd have to be stringent on making sure to avoid bias, even more than they are now (but there is always bias, don't kid yourselves).

.

Ex-players dont want to be refs. It alot handier to go into coaching/tv. The way refs are treated is another major problem.

The only player who cant question a decision is the captian. Any other player who cries or wwhinges should be given a yellow card.

Posted by Dj Smitty20 on Jul-12-2006 22:03:

who says ex players don't want to referees in their 30s and 40s? I'm not talking about a guy like Zidane or Totti being a ref, but perhaps a player that was never a star or had to retire early for whatever reason. The officiating in football is getting horrendous; nobody knows what a foul is anymore nor what constitutes a card offence. Cards are being thrown out there way too early in matches by refs who feel that's how they can best control the game.

They really need to pull away from impulsive card use. 30% increase this WC was it? Horrible. Let the players play the game with a bit of contact and physicality. It wasn't meant to be like basketball on grass.

Posted by Michael19 on Jul-12-2006 22:07:

quote:
Originally posted by Dj Smitty20
who says ex players don't want to referees in their 30s and 40s? I'm not talking about a guy like Zidane or Totti being a ref, but perhaps a player that was never a star or had to retire early for whatever reason. The officiating in football is getting horrendous; nobody knows what a foul is anymore nor what constitutes a card offence. Cards are being thrown out there way too early in matches by refs who feel that's who they can best control the game.

They really need to pull away from impulsive card use. 30% increase this WC was it? Horrible. Let the players play the game with a bit of contact. IT was meant to be played that way.

Look at the way ref's are treated. Its terrible. I cant see many players(no matter what level) signing up for that. Alot more likely to go into coaching.

Also FIFA is to blame mainly. They decide the rules, they decide whhats a freekick and what isnt. Most of those refs wouldnt make it to the world cup becuase fifa want to protect the players from getting a few grass stains on there knees or white shorts.

The day FIFA isnt ruin by a bunch of clueless chimps is the day football will improve.

Posted by Dj Smitty20 on Jul-12-2006 22:10:

Well I agree with you totally. Blatter just doesn't know what the fuck is going on and I absolutely loathe his attempted interference into the domestic leagues. No thank you, the EPL is not going lessen the Premiereship because it's better for the CL. They already did that a few years back and 20 is as low as it's going to get.

I'd like to see a guy like Beckenbauer be head of FIFA. He knows what's wrong with the game today and isn't afraid to say it.

Posted by chucho on Jul-19-2006 02:52:

last minutes subs to gain
time...give me a f00kin break...that's retarted

and more retarted is the player who's coming in when there's 1 or 2 mins. left

i'd be like..."i ain't going in...i rather stay here than being rediculassed when the referee ends te match and i didn't even touch the ball"

Posted by Ian on Jul-20-2006 14:05:

quote:
Originally posted by Michael19
The only player who cant question a decision is the captian. Any other player who cries or wwhinges should be given a yellow card.

tell that to sylvain distin

SD - can I ask you a question ref?
Rob Styles - No, give me the ball
SD - I'd just like to know what basis the decision was given on
RS - give me the ball now
SD - wait a second please, I'd just like to know so I can inform my manager & teammates
RS - no ball, yellow card, you've been booked already, you're off

Posted by zoric on Jul-20-2006 14:18:

Graham Poll is going to be the referee when Serbia plays against Poland in the beginning of their qualifying campaign.

We've got the worst referee, now everyone can agree on that at least

Ban his ass forever.

Posted by RapidFire on Jul-22-2006 19:16:

quote:
Originally posted by zoric
Graham Poll is going to be the referee when Serbia plays against Poland in the beginning of their qualifying campaign.

We've got the worst referee, now everyone can agree on that at least

Ban his ass forever.

wonderful.

Posted by Goashem on Jul-22-2006 23:08:

dont know if anyone said it yet but, any player caught diving should be banned from a major competition (you got caught diving in the world cup, youre banned from the eurocup or the next world cup).

Posted by Ian on Jul-22-2006 23:36:

stop banning retired players

Posted by sensorium on Jul-23-2006 02:22:

Coaches can smoke inside the stadium.

Posted by raveed on Jul-24-2006 07:36:

quote:
Originally posted by malek
usage of video to rule out diving and fake injuries.

a judge watching tv monitors would tell by radio the ref on the field if the hit really happened or not.

This is necessary but at the same time, football is a game that involves continuous running and that is what makes the game so beautiful. With video replays arises the question of where to draw the line as to how much and for what cases should video be used so I dont see them implementing it in the near future.

-----

quote:
no more PKs in the final stages of the world cup, after the first 30 minutes of extra time, each time would remove one or two player. Both would play till a team scores... golden goal style, or if FIFA is too pussy, let the 15 mins period end before a winner is declared.
The game would open up, there would be more space.

What is this the slave ages?

Have a heart man, these guys have been running around for 120 minutes and you expect them to run more and that to with less men which will require them to run even harder. You saw how many and how frequently players broke down with cramping during extra time.

PKs is a sad way to lose but there is no other and better way to replace them.

-----

quote:
A radical move would be to stop the time when there's a player changed or a player needing medical attention.

lol, stop americanising the game. A better idea would be to have a player who needs medical attention be made to stay of the field for 5-10 minutes. That will help curtail faking of injuries to a certain extent.

Posted by Dj Smitty20 on Jul-24-2006 08:15:

i'd rather see them avoid using instant replays as much as possible. We don't need refs looking at monitors NFL style...that will KILL the game. It certainly kills NFL football for many people, although there are stoppages all the time for various reasons.

Two refs = no. If you think the officiating is inconsistent now, two refs who call the game differently will only make it worse.

Posted by A_M_8 on Jul-29-2006 06:43:

There arent many rules that can be implemented to improve football without making it less "fluent". All these ideas of videocameras and extra refs will only remove the smooth continuity of the game which is what makes it so great. Besides, the refs calls and the controveries have always added some spice to the game making it interesting (although I have to admit it has fucked up some games as well).

One idea that I think they could use without ruining the flow of the sport is inserting a really small microchip inside the football that would tell if the ball crossed the goal line or not.