Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb (Blake Jarrell vs Nosmo's Lasershow Bootleg)

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Album Reviews / New Releases Discussion
-- Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb (Blake Jarrell vs Nosmo's Lasershow Bootleg)

Posted by Dj.telry on Dec-01-2006 15:55:

Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb (Blake Jarrell vs Nosmo's Lasershow Bootleg)

BOMB!!!!!!

Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb Original is Psychedelic Rock! i like too

but can...change to Progressive House/Trance VERY VERY AMAZING Tune !!!

10/10!!

Posted by RJT on Dec-01-2006 16:16:

Sample?

Posted by SMC on Dec-01-2006 16:34:

Re: Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb (Blake Jarrell vs Nosmo's Lasershow Bootleg)

quote:
Originally posted by Dj.telry
Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb Original is Psychedelic Rock!

If anything, it's progressive rock.

Posted by RJT on Dec-01-2006 16:35:

Either way, Blake sounds like a perfect fit for this remix.

If you've ever heard "Thumpie" you know what I'm talkin' bout!

Posted by Blakey on Dec-01-2006 20:05:

Re: Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb (Blake Jarrell vs Nosmo's Lasershow Bootleg)

quote:
Originally posted by Dj.telry
BOMB!!!!!!

Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb Original is Psychedelic Rock! i like too

but can...change to Progressive House/Trance VERY VERY AMAZING Tune !!!

10/10!!

The original is a 'very very amazing tune', this remix hasn't brought anything new to the table. All it sounds like is he's added his usual bassline. 5/10 at the most.

Posted by SMC on Dec-01-2006 22:27:

Re: Re: Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb (Blake Jarrell vs Nosmo's Lasershow Bootleg)

quote:
Originally posted by Blakey
The original is a 'very very amazing tune', this remix hasn't brought anything new to the table. All it sounds like is he's added his usual bassline. 5/10 at the most.

I agree, i listened to it and i'm not impressed. I'm not a big fan of double tempo edm overdubs. However i don't think it is an attempt to bring anything new to the table.

I'll stick to the live version from The Division Bell tour on PULSE, best track ever.

Posted by nchs09 on Dec-02-2006 01:31:

Scissor Sisters - Comfortably Numb (Paper Faces Mix) > all

Posted by Blake_Jarrell on Dec-02-2006 02:15:

Re: Re: Re: Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb (Blake Jarrell vs Nosmo's Lasershow Bootleg

quote:
Originally posted by SMC
i don't think it is an attempt to bring anything new to the table.

we definitely werent trying to be "cutting edge" with this, redoing pink floyd with hoovers 303's and wide open filters wouldnt sound good.

we just wanted to make something playable.

we did add alot, but it was all organic sounds, so its not going to be obvious as to what we added (basslines, drums, choirs, strings, fx, pads, etc), but if you listen to the original versus the remix you will definitely hear what we did. also, bootlegging severly limits you to what you can add, there is only so much headroom for new sounds, so you cant expect much.

Posted by RJT on Dec-02-2006 03:21:

I really think this remix stays very true to the original tune, something projects like this oftentimes don't really do and should. Don't get me wrong, I can appreciate a solid new take on an old favorite, but there are some classics that really don't need much and this is one of them.

I think you guys did a great job Blake - I really enjoy this one

Posted by SMC on Dec-02-2006 04:42:

Re: Re: Re: Re: Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb (Blake Jarrell vs Nosmo's Lasershow Boo

quote:
Originally posted by Blake_Jarrell
we definitely werent trying to be "cutting edge" with this

I understand that, it's sort of what i was trying to say. But i just thought the amazement expressed by the thread starter was unproportionate, in spite of it being a decent work given the circumstances, which would be the limitaions inherent to this type of bootleg remixing. I'm into production, so i understand what the process is like.

Posted by Pinokio on Dec-03-2006 01:20:

I like this remix, It's not anything special, but it's not bad either.

Posted by AMP on Dec-03-2006 16:20:

I love it. I play it at every gig... and it goes down very well. Not much else I can say

Posted by bobba lou on Dec-03-2006 17:20:

so can i be sorted with a link or something? the amazment by the thread started didnt catch me, blakes comment about organic sounds did..

sort me out

-Harold

Posted by RJT on Dec-03-2006 21:06:

Went down rock solid live last night