TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- adagio for strings - William Orbit or Tiesto?
Pages (3): [1] 2 3 »

adagio for strings - William Orbit or Tiesto?

I've checked discogs and it's pretty clear that the first original track is by William Orbit labelled as William Orbit - Barbers adagio for strings date: 99. Why is it that whichever live set I see and whenever I see this track listed eslewhere it's titled as Tiesto - Adagio for strings rather than William orbit - barbers adagio for strings(tiesto mix). Tiesto didn't make the song and while he might have remixed it, it doesn't give him the right to have songs mislabelled like that. ?

Re: adagio for strings - William Orbit or Tiesto?

quote:

Originally posted by Drastic_MaN I've checked discogs and it's pretty clear that the first original track is by William Orbit labelled as William Orbit - Barbers adagio for strings date: 99. Why is it that whichever live set I see and whenever I see this track listed eslewhere it's titled as Tiesto - Adagio for strings rather than William orbit - barbers adagio for strings(tiesto mix). Tiesto didn't make the song and while he might have remixed it, it doesn't give him the right to have songs mislabelled like that. ?

Barbar wrote it. William Orbit Pioneered it.

Re: adagio for strings - William Orbit or Tiesto?

quote:

Originally posted by Drastic_MaN Tiesto didn't make the song and while he might have remixed it, it doesn't give him the right to have songs mislabelled like that. ?

You clueless cretin

It's Barber who wrote it. Both Orbit & Tiesto sampled it, so in fact they did the same thing. No need for asking it to be Tiesto rmx while Orbit can be put as an artist.

Cretin? Go fuck yourself. I put a question mark at the end of the sentance for a reason. If the song is by Barbeer then why is it mislabbled by both Tiesto and W.O.?

quote:

Originally posted by Drastic_MaN Cretin? Go fuck yourself. I put a question mark at the end of the sentance for a reason. If the song is by Barbeer then why is it mislabbled by both Tiesto and W.O.?

Because they got the rights to do so. It's not really rocket science, is it.

William Orbit credited Barber in the title of the track, what more can he do?

tiesto loves making work his own

wait, i got a better one.

what are you talking about? barber works for tiesto, just lik cor fijman. OMG LOLROFLROFLORLOLO

you know, for all the years worth of discussion on TA, i'm surprised this topic hasn't been brought up before

Skip Raiders feat. Jada - Another Day


Best use of Barber's Adagio for Strings.

quote:

Originally posted by isoterra you know, for all the years worth of discussion on TA, i'm surprised this topic hasn't been brought up before

I'm sure i've seen this being debated before.

quote:

Originally posted by Mr.Mystery Because they got the rights to do so. It's not really rocket science, is it.

And Tiesto obviously didn't want Barber's name in there, because he thought it might detract from His. Although how he could be that proud of such an abomination is anybody's guess.

quote:

Originally posted by SMC I'm sure i've seen this being debated before.

You're a clever fellow, aren't you.

quote:

Originally posted by Mr.Mystery You're a clever fellow, aren't you.

I can kill you with my brain. I have no recollection of frequent threads about this, so his sarcasm wasn't obvious to me, if that's what you mean.

quote:

Originally posted by Drastic_MaN Cretin? Go fuck yourself. I put a question mark at the end of the sentance for a reason. If the song is by Barbeer then why is it mislabbled by both Tiesto and W.O.?

Because it's a piece of classical music you dolt. Samuel Barber is dead and the piece is probably in the public domain. Every dance version is a cover.

quote:

Originally posted by SYSTEM-J Because it's a piece of classical music you dolt. Samuel Barber is dead and the piece is probably in the public domain. Every dance version is a cover.

Yup...it's not copyrighted and Barber's dead so anyone can sample it without any sort of permission. I think it goes that after someone dies, they're work stays copyrighted for a certain amount of years...but he's long dead.

quote:

Originally posted by Atmos Yup...it's not copyrighted and Barber's dead so anyone can sample it without any sort of permission. I think it goes that after someone dies, they're work stays copyrighted for a certain amount of years...but he's long dead.

Anyone got any actual info on this? I heard something about money going to family or something but I'm probably wrong.

I quote "In general, the rights last for approximately 70 years after the death of the author before falling into the public domain."

Source: http://www.esa.int/SPECIALS/Intelle...QPQL26WD_0.html

"In the US, after the death of a copyright holder, heirs inherit the copyright."

Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyri...rcing_copyright

I'm not sure that's right... he only composed it in 1936.

Yea I just looked it up...I guess all I can do is provide the info on copyrights. I don't know about the rest then...maybe Barber's heir allowed it. I'm blank.

quote:

Originally posted by isoterra you know, for all the years worth of discussion on TA, i'm surprised this topic hasn't been brought up before

lolsarcasm

quote:

Originally posted by Darkarbiter Anyone got any actual info on this? I heard something about money going to family or something but I'm probably wrong.

copyright on a piece of music is life of the author + 70 years

quote:

Originally posted by Atmos Yea I just looked it up...I guess all I can do is provide the info on copyrights. I don't know about the rest then...maybe Barber's heir allowed it. I'm blank.

barber doesn't do it for the money/propietory rights. barber is open-source. iz how he rollz

wasnt ferry first who remixed the track ?

quote:

Originally posted by Arteh wasnt ferry first who remixed the track ?

no he remixed orbits remake. and i think skip raiders - another day was the first to track to use the melody back in 99. though i could be wrong

The original is still the best.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.