TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- digital releases
digital releases
as far as releases are concerned, usually we see them in CD or VINYL format.
i've been seeing WEB releases around, obviously composed of mp3 files, though i understand they can be ogg files.
are these legit?
i used discogs.com to see if something is legit.
if its not on discogs.com, i generally avoid it.
i will also check the artists website but have not found much on their "WEB" releases.
of course this assumes discogs.com is accurate, which is another subject.
anyhoo, this is discogs.com policy on digital releases ...
| quote: |
Due to the recent emergence of digital labels and the variety of those labels, we cannot establish firm guidelines on which digital releases will be accepted and which will not be accepted. However, below is a list of criteria which can prove the validity of a digital release. The more criteria that your release satisfies, the more likely it will be accepted into Discogs. The existence of the release can be proven with a hyperlink. The release has to be on a well known MP3 label. Tracks on mp3.com or other online-music portals are not accepted. The release has to be listed with a catalog number. The release is not available on any physical medium (it has to be MP3-exclusive). The artist also has physical releases which are appropriate for Discogs. The release does not consist of one single track, and the tracks have to be explicitly linked together as one release. The release has its own layout that can be printed and used for self-made CDr versions of that release. Discogs does not accept downloadable gimmicks from artist pages (Example: remixes, live-versions, etc.) or self-made music that someone has uploaded to his/her webspace. |
if you but the digital releases from a legit webstore, you know it's legit.
Just buy from well known, trusted sources. Beatport, AudioJelly, etc.
to give an example, i was on beatport looking at an above & beyond release.
i think it was can't sleep.
it had it available for purchase/download for that particular release, defined by its tracks, was no where to be found on discogs or a&b site, or anjunabeats site.
i understand if its available for purchase/download it should be considered legit.
but why is it not recognized on other sites ??
and whats the difference between these and WEB releases ??
or are they the same.
releases only appear on discogs because some member adds them.
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Pjotr G releases only appear on discogs because some member adds them. |
and like i said, i rely on discogs for "legitness."
hahaha.
it seems the single most organized, and usually accurate, source of information for artist/track information.
is there another place you guys use ??
dont get me wrong, i've seen mistakes and errors on discogs.
Why go to sites to check if they're legit 
If Beatport or any other download store sells tracks they are legit. And the fact some releases aren't mentioned on the label's website is due to not updating the site.
Anyway digital tracks are replacing vinyl and even cd more and more.
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Djeebie Why go to sites to check if they're legit If Beatport or any other download store sells tracks they are legit. And the fact some releases aren't mentioned on the label's website is due to not updating the site. |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by Djeebie Anyway digital tracks are replacing vinyl and even cd more and more. |
when you say WEB release that is linked to only illegitimate/pirate music.. so i dont think this would be the best place to talk about that stuff
just get your music from beatport/aj/vonyc/trackitdown/djdownloads/cdjshop/label's website and youre guaranteed to have music in the most legimate and in perfect download quality (sometimes wave, but it wouldnt be a shitty reencode 320 either)
| quote: |
| Originally posted by stan229 when you say WEB release that is linked to only illegitimate/pirate music.. so i dont think this would be the best place to talk about that stuff just get your music from beatport/aj/vonyc/trackitdown/djdownloads/cdjshop/label's website and youre guaranteed to have music in the most legimate and in perfect download quality (sometimes wave, but it wouldnt be a shitty reencode 320 either) |
WEB release does not mean it isn't legit. "Web Release" and "Digital Release" are synonymous.
Stick with major sites and don't buy from shoddy-ass ones, I don't see what's so difficult...
the WEB im referring to is usually linked with "scene" releases as PROMO_CDS/Vinyl/PROMO_CDM which are just ripped songs
Better be safe than sorry and just buy it off the main retailers where you know that there wont be any problems with the mp3/wav and if there is they can give you a refund 
since no one can really give a clear answer, ill abide by these.
| quote: |
| Originally posted by david.michael Stick with major sites and don't buy from shoddy-ass ones, I don't see what's so difficult... |
| quote: |
| Originally posted by stan229 Better be safe than sorry and just buy it off the main retailers where you know that there wont be any problems |
Oh in that case yes
for example
Thomas Bronzwaer - Constellation came on vonyc before it was on vandit.com and it was a vandit release
| quote: |
| Originally posted by washout still, ive come across releases on the major sites that are not recognized/listed on the artist site (or discogs)?? are webmasters for these artist sites collectively lazy ?? |
However, artists tend to update their myspace more often than their original site.
Web release is a scene release bought from online shops, not ripped from cd or vinyl
Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.