Same Melody? - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Same Melody?

Posted by damnuok on Dec-11-2007 19:24:

Same Melody?

Hey, ive just seen this thread somewhere else, and ive decided to put it here... tell my your opinion.

quote:
Are these 2 pads the same? or they're just very very similar?tracks :
Robert Nickson - Spiral - 2004

Breakfast - The Sunlight - 2007

[[ LINK REMOVED ]]

Posted by kadomony on Dec-11-2007 20:01:

oh boy.
this was a big issue back when the early version of sunlight was posted.

http://trance.nu/v4/forum/viewtopic.php?t=114649

the sunlight people are playing now is actually a reworked version of the old tune which was made in late 03 i believe.

Posted by trancedanne on Dec-11-2007 20:47:

Never thought about this but yeah the pads are verry similiar but i have heard much worse rip offs then this. & imo spiral is way better

Posted by isoterra on Dec-11-2007 21:01:

spiral wasn't exactly the most groundbreakingly original of melodies in the first place i remember people posting comparisons between it & the nocturnal creatures main string a few years back...

i thought the sunlight was way more special than spiral, the part where the chord sequence changes during the breakdown is fucking awesome & really adds a new dimension to an otherwise simple theme