Sied van Riel/Huinink "Minimal symphony"

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Sied van Riel/Huinink "Minimal symphony"

Posted by southbound24 on May-13-2008 00:34:

Sied van Riel/Huinink "Minimal symphony"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bFfrO1E6mY

Posted by smakmagik on May-13-2008 00:39:

Posted by MrJiveBoJingles on May-13-2008 00:48:

Eh...

It's amazing how quickly a lot of people will warm to a track if you just throw in a bunch of big, treacly-sentimental string chords.

Posted by ReclusNdangrmnt on May-13-2008 02:58:

It has its charm, but not too much of a shelf life. Needed more Huinink and less van Riel, imho.

Posted by r5a on May-13-2008 04:01:

ehh. im not sure how i feel about this.

its not bad, not great. some things i dislike and somethings i like. could be a lot better thou. right now 6.5/10.

Posted by narcism on May-13-2008 07:20:

really like this tune

Posted by TranceArmstrong on May-13-2008 07:35:

big epic cheesy symphony break AND awful techy synth line, this track is a winner

Posted by Armitage on May-13-2008 08:39:

I don't think you could make it more overblown if you tried.

Posted by Ted Promo on May-13-2008 09:14:

trance really does go in circles any more it seems. Let's bring back the 30 second strings build-up again. Cheeeeeck.

Posted by Ian on May-13-2008 09:59:

quote:
Originally posted by TranceArmstrong
big epic cheesy symphony break AND awful techy synth line, this track is a winner

precisely, the stupid beat/bass combination does not go with the symphonic sounds at all. It's pretty obvious to me which person has done what here, Geert is very capable of producing masterpieces (think Magik Journey & the work for Dawnseekers for example) but working with someone like sied really hasn't brought out the best in him. I was very interested when I first saw it on trackitdown but soon felt repulsed. Not the direction trance needs for sure.

Posted by Unable on May-13-2008 10:34:

Nothing on Malibeer.

Posted by kadomony on May-13-2008 13:16:

quote:
Originally posted by narcism
really like this tune

of course you do!

Posted by tibberino on May-13-2008 18:01:

Absolute Pish of the highest order!

Posted by JakeC on May-14-2008 10:24:

Minimal?

Posted by DJ Blitzkrieg on May-14-2008 13:01:

Yea this same structure and style that has been used many times before is still used and getting really old. That is why producers like Orkidea and Airwave are so great. They're way of building up momentum in a song is very original.

Posted by narcism on May-15-2008 08:01:

quote:
Originally posted by kadomony
of course you do!

well do u like this song