TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- Soemone is asking me for trance recommendations...
Pages (2): [1] 2 »


Posted by treeboo on Jan-16-2009 18:47:

Soemone is asking me for trance recommendations...

...and he's a relative newb to the genre. He knows some of the larger hits that have had major commercial success (Sandstorm, As the Rush comes, etc.) and is pushing for more tunes in the same vein. Given his novelty to the genre, I'd say anything from the early Magik series through the re-re-re-emergence of electro (2005 or so, right?) should be fair game.

I've got several ideas myself, but I'd like to hear anyone's recommendations. So, perhaps I'm asking for a recollection thread of some of the biggest tunes over that time span?


Posted by woscar on Jan-16-2009 18:49:

Save him some time and point him to house instead


Posted by MrJiveBoJingles on Jan-16-2009 19:12:

quote:
Originally posted by woscar
Save him some time and point him to house instead

Why not point him to both?


Posted by Meat187 on Jan-16-2009 19:17:

Someone is asking you for trance recommendations, so you're making a thread asking for trance recommendations. Brilliant!


Posted by MrJiveBoJingles on Jan-16-2009 19:19:

quote:
Originally posted by Meat187
Someone is asking you for trance recommendations, so you're making a thread asking for trance recommendations. Brilliant!

Quick, someone else make a thread asking for trance recommendations for treeboo, who needs trance recommendations for his friend!

We can get a chain going...


Posted by treeboo on Jan-16-2009 19:23:

I've got several songs in mind but I'm sure there are dozens if not hundreds of songs I've missed or forgotten. I'm hoping someone else can shed some light


Posted by Hrvoje on Jan-16-2009 19:24:

LOL


Posted by SMC on Jan-16-2009 19:56:

I don't get this fixation with 'the biggest tunes'.


Posted by woscar on Jan-16-2009 20:18:

quote:
Originally posted by SMC
I don't get this fixation with 'the biggest tunes'.


You can thank Armin and his 'tune of the week' for that


Posted by treeboo on Jan-16-2009 20:37:

I think the idea here is to expose someone to a genre. If you were trying to expose someone to rock, would you give them Led Zeppelin or some regional hit wonder?

Is this really that odd of a request?


Posted by woscar on Jan-16-2009 20:44:

quote:
Originally posted by treeboo
I think the idea here is to expose someone to a genre. If you were trying to expose someone to rock, would you give them Led Zeppelin or some regional hit wonder?

Is this really that odd of a request?


You're comparing Led Zeppelin to the commercially successful Trance artists now?

I'd say your buddy will enjoy any of the Tiesto/Armin/PvD/Markus Schulz mixes and compilations.


Posted by treeboo on Jan-16-2009 21:05:

quote:
Originally posted by woscar
You're comparing Led Zeppelin to the commercially successful Trance artists now?

I'd say your buddy will enjoy any of the Tiesto/Armin/PvD/Markus Schulz mixes and compilations.


That comparison isn't apt if we want to discuss the "faces" of a genre?

I'm looking for something a bit more specific than you've given, but of course I'm happy to do the digging myself. Just hoping the old forum could provide a shortcut or two...


Posted by Trance-M on Jan-16-2009 21:42:

Always thought the Trancemaster series was really good.
(Also among the oldest compilation series)

http://www.discogs.com/label/Vision+Soundcarriers


There is a new one:


Posted by Sykonee on Jan-16-2009 22:08:

If you want the Led Zeppelin analogy for trance, then go with anything from Oliver Lieb. Probably Best Of L.S.G. is a good starting point, although you can't go wrong with Rendezvous In Outer Space either.


Posted by kliq on Jan-17-2009 00:03:

hmm, i seriously doubt a newbie would appreciate anything hardcore/underground/critically acclaimed

if he's looking to see where the genre is currently at, something commercial like Armin's ASOT 2008 should one way or another point him to whether he likes trance or not

if he's not looking for current the ISOS series should work I guess...


Posted by SMC on Jan-17-2009 00:22:

quote:
Originally posted by kliq
if he's looking to see where the genre is currently at, something commercial like Armin's ASOT 2008 should one way or another point him to whether he likes trance or not


It will point him to whether he likes shit.


Posted by kliq on Jan-17-2009 00:32:

quote:
Originally posted by SMC
It will point him to whether he likes shit.


it will point him to 'commercial trance', the easiest to identify with for someone who isnt a seasoned listener of the genre...

whether its shit however is going to be his/her choice isnt it...


Posted by SMC on Jan-17-2009 00:47:

quote:
Originally posted by kliq
it will point him to 'commercial trance', the easiest to identify with for someone who isnt a seasoned listener of the genre...

whether its shit however is going to be his/her choice isnt it...


But why point someone to that which is easiest to identify with?


Posted by creon444 on Jan-17-2009 01:00:

Re: Soemone is asking me for trance recommendations...

quote:
Originally posted by treeboo
He knows some of the larger hits that have had major commercial success (Sandstorm, As the Rush comes, etc.) and is pushing for more tunes in the same vein.


OMG, Why do you still hang out with this strange Soemone person? What kind of name is it anyway?


Posted by kliq on Jan-17-2009 01:03:

quote:
Originally posted by SMC
But why point someone to that which is easiest to identify with?


in my experience it helps get newbies on their way, till their tastes get more refined, and they can digest sounds they cant easily identify with in the beginning

however i am generalizing, and if the person in question wants to challenge himself/herself, then throwing commercial out of the window might not be a bad idea...


Posted by SMC on Jan-17-2009 01:19:

quote:
Originally posted by kliq
in my experience it helps get newbies on their way, till their tastes get more refined, and they can digest sounds they cant easily identify with in the beginning

however i am generalizing, and if the person in question wants to challenge himself/herself, then throwing commercial out of the window might not be a bad idea...


I'm sure any serious music listener can try "The Best Of L.S.G."


Posted by Neo95gt on Jan-17-2009 02:23:

quote:
Originally posted by SMC
It will point him to whether he likes shit.



Posted by Mr.Mystery on Jan-17-2009 03:50:

quote:
Originally posted by SMC
But why point someone to that which is easiest to identify with?

How do newbies get into any genre?

Stop being a fucking ass and help the guy out.


Posted by SMC on Jan-17-2009 03:56:

quote:
Originally posted by Mr.Mystery
How do newbies get into any genre?

Stop being a fucking ass and help the guy out.


I think the OP already got all the help he needed. I was adressing what this other guy said and i think my inquiry is a valid one.


Posted by PETRAN on Jan-17-2009 04:04:

"I would say: Elect not to start with ASOT"







-nefardec


Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.